3 ms·
> The truth, as ever, has turned out to be more complicated. Last year, an influential review of the available data concluded that there was no clear evidence t
by Aurornis 3y ago
> The truth, as ever, has turned out to be more complicated. Last year, an influential review of the available data concluded that there was no clear evidence to support the theory, and the ensuing headlines left many bewildered about who or what to believe.
This article makes the same mistake as many other journalists: You don’t need a deficiency of a neurotransmitter for a medication to have an effect.
For an obvious example: People experiencing severe pain don’t have an “opioid deficiency”, yet opioid medications can alleviate their symptoms. Likewise, you don’t need to have a “serotonin deficiency” for drugs that interact with serotonin to have an effect on depression.
The whole “chemical imbalance” theory of depression was a reasonable guess at the time, but neuroscience largely moved past it decades ago as a singular explanation for depression. It has largely persisted among pop science, though, which creates confusion every few years when journalists get ahold of some scraps of research and try to stir up some controversy about depression medications.
Basically, ignore this section of the article. Serotonin deficiency was never necessary for SSRIs to work and we’ve known that for decades. The authors of these books throw out some vague explanations for why they think they work, but the reality is that it’s all very complex and our understandings are still evolving. Engineers tend to hate medicine because they want to think of the brain as a well-understood computer program that can be debugged and treated with the right inputs (medications) but ultimately a lot of what we know is from empirical testing. We can throw theories out all day long, but at the end of the day the only thing that matters is what shows results in studies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vhcr 3y ago> Previous research in people with chronic pain has shown that they have reduced availability of opioid receptors (the molecules opioid drugs bind to) in the brain. https://www.nccih.nih.gov/research/research-results/paininduced-changes-in-the-brains-opioid-system-may-explain-the-limited-effectiveness-of-opioid-therapy-in-chronic-pain https://www.nccih.nih.gov/research/research-results/painindu...
- julianeon 3y agoI think his example is more like this: A nail gun shoots a nail through your foot. You go to the hospital and the nail is removed, but the pain remains. There's nothing wrong with your opioid receptors: the pain you feel doesn't result from some kind of imbalance in them. It's 'valid' pain - no malfunction there - telling you that your foot is in a bad way. When they give you opioids for this, it's not treating the core problem, at all (no problem w/the receptors). Yet it's still helpful, and does good, because it's dulling the overwhelming and excessive amount of pain you would otherwise be feeling.
- InSteady 3y agoThis example is technically correct, but not appropriate. Since we are comparing pain to depression, the comparison should be for chronic pain not acute pain. Otherwise we would also be talking about curing grief and sadness with neurotransmitters, which clearly isn't a thing. Getting a nail stuck through your foot is more like a close friend or relative dying. Having chronic pain is more like having depression (well, that and chronic pain very often leads to depression, and the reduction in opioid receptor availability may be somehow related, but that's a whole other thing). The parent comment's point about opioid receptors becoming less available in chronic pain (and the linked article pointing out that opioids are generally terrible for dealing with chronic pain) is quite relevant here. Opioids kind of work at first for chronic pain, but they progressively work less and less and have increasingly negative side effects over time. There are certainly some parallels with many people's experience with some neurotransmitter targeting meds. None of this means that GP is necessarily wrong about their assertions regarding SSRI and similar medications, but it is worth stopping to consider the possibility at least.
- balfirevic 3y ago> Engineers tend to hate medicine because they want to think of the brain as a well-understood computer program that can be debugged and treated with the right inputs Why this unnecessary dig in an otherwise good comment? As an engineer, I don't even think of most programs as being "well-understood".