8 ms·
Breaking Through Depression
- colecut 3y agoChemical imbalance? Pretty sure it's due to my only sibling overdosing in 2019, and the mother of my son dying of cancer in 2020, and my fiancee dying of cancer in 2021.
- confidantlake 3y agoSorry to hear. Hope things get better.
- pstuart 3y agoI'm sorry for your losses, but depression in the context of the OP is a biochemical issue. What you're experiencing is profound sadness (I lost a brother to an OD, a nephew to rabies, etc., it sucks). Time theoretically will help heal your wounds but for many it's not that simple (as the article points out, we're still trying to figure it out). An incredibly bitter irony is that one can take steps to ameliorate the condition but when in the throes of it, finding the strength and ability to do so is incredibly challenging.
- networkchad 3y agoJesus I am so sorry to hear about that. I have no idea how I would cope dealing with that. I sincerely hope life gets better for you over the next few years. Stay strong brother.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI’m really sorry. My brother in law overdosed in 2020. Like you, I haven’t really gotten over it. I just try to remember the happy times. If you want someone to talk to, you can email me or DM via Twitter. Happy to just listen.
- colecut 3y agoIrony, my brother's name was Shawn
- extragood 3y agoI can't imagine the pain you must live with every day. I'm so sorry. The article does disambiguate between (what they call) "true sadness" and depression: > Gold dismisses the common idea that depression is medicalised sadness, noting that “true sadness is often associated with cherished, loving memories of, for instance, a lost loved one, combined with grief over their loss, and, at times, a bittersweet feeling encompassing both the bounties of life and the harsh reality that all relationships must come to an end”. Such feelings, he says, are typically unavailable to seriously depressed individuals, whose emotional repertoire is constricted to “a deadening litany of self-excoriation and hopelessness”. And I think it is an important distinction. "Depression" has been treated as a catch-all term for what turns out to be a myriad of different causes that happen to look the same to an outside observer. I personally experience chronic inflammation due to Crohn's disease and it does cause depressive symptoms even though there isn't any major external reason that I should feel that way. And it makes no sense that the same treatment should be used in both of our cases.
- ovulator 3y agoOne thing a therapist told me during a session one time is: "It sounds like your life just sucks right now". It isn't always something internal, but the outside world impacting us. Chin up, do it for your son, best of luck my man.
- rexpop 3y ago> One of the first things we discover in these [peer support] groups is that personal problems are political problems. There are no personal solutions at this time. There is only collective action for a collective solution. -- Carol Hanisch, 1970
- rexpop 3y agoNot to trivialize or dismiss the undeniable tragedy of your lived experience, but--yes, there is a neurological, and therefore chemical, component to trauma-induced depression. > If you get exposed to a lot of glucocorticoids, you're more at risk now for depression. You can see this epidemiologically: you get people, and statistically, before their first major depressive episode something awful stressful occurs. Have one of those first depressive episodes, due to some stressful event, you come out the other side eventually. You are no more at risk for depression than anybody else. Along comes a second major stressor, and you fall into depression, come out the other end, no more at risk than anyone else for depression. Somewhere around the fourth or fifth stress-induced depression, something happens and things start cycling on their own there and you no longer need a major stressor to cause you to get depressed like that. That's when the clocks are off and running. That's the transition.[0] Will your life ever have meaning again? Probably not, no. Not the meaning it had before those three very important people were taken from you. Probably nothing of value makes sense, anymore, not in light of their absence. What's the point of watching TV you can't talk about with them? What's the point of going on trips you can't share photos of with them? At least, that's how I've been thinking about my losses. I'm just a stranger on the internet, but if you told me life had lost its meaning I would believe you, and you would be right. ...but there is also a neurological component. 0. Dr. Robert Sapolsky, PhD, 2009 - https://youtu.be/NOAgplgTxfc?t=2165&si=P0pg-W5lOe3n0LWb https://youtu.be/NOAgplgTxfc?t=2165&si=P0pg-W5lOe3n0LWb
- Aurornis 3y ago> The truth, as ever, has turned out to be more complicated. Last year, an influential review of the available data concluded that there was no clear evidence to support the theory, and the ensuing headlines left many bewildered about who or what to believe. This article makes the same mistake as many other journalists: You don’t need a deficiency of a neurotransmitter for a medication to have an effect. For an obvious example: People experiencing severe pain don’t have an “opioid deficiency”, yet opioid medications can alleviate their symptoms. Likewise, you don’t need to have a “serotonin deficiency” for drugs that interact with serotonin to have an effect on depression. The whole “chemical imbalance” theory of depression was a reasonable guess at the time, but neuroscience largely moved past it decades ago as a singular explanation for depression. It has largely persisted among pop science, though, which creates confusion every few years when journalists get ahold of some scraps of research and try to stir up some controversy about depression medications. Basically, ignore this section of the article. Serotonin deficiency was never necessary for SSRIs to work and we’ve known that for decades. The authors of these books throw out some vague explanations for why they think they work, but the reality is that it’s all very complex and our understandings are still evolving. Engineers tend to hate medicine because they want to think of the brain as a well-understood computer program that can be debugged and treated with the right inputs (medications) but ultimately a lot of what we know is from empirical testing. We can throw theories out all day long, but at the end of the day the only thing that matters is what shows results in studies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vhcr 3y ago> Previous research in people with chronic pain has shown that they have reduced availability of opioid receptors (the molecules opioid drugs bind to) in the brain. https://www.nccih.nih.gov/research/research-results/paininduced-changes-in-the-brains-opioid-system-may-explain-the-limited-effectiveness-of-opioid-therapy-in-chronic-pain https://www.nccih.nih.gov/research/research-results/painindu...
- julianeon 3y ago
- Panini_Jones 3y agoFor anyone experiencing depression right now, this video helped me immensely at one point in my life [0]. CBT has also changed my life; I highly recommend the book 'Feeling Good'[1]. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVgQ_tgWMyU&t https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVgQ_tgWMyU&t [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Feeling-Good-New-Mood-Therapy/dp/0380810336 https://www.amazon.com/Feeling-Good-New-Mood-Therapy/dp/0380...
- raylad 3y agoCBT is one of the few therapies that have been extensively validated in scientific studies. For example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7001356/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7001356/
- bheadmaster 3y agoCBT being validated in scientific studies is caused by CBT's obsession with measurable progress and short term benefits. The first task you get when you enroll in CBT is to write down "current state of affairs" and "desired state of affairs" so that you and your therapist can focus on playing whack-a-mole with the symptoms for the next few years. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the people who seek therapy don't really have any major psychological issues, but are simply in need of some advice and support - CBT would be greatly exploiting that because there isn't even a test whether or not you need CBT - it's just assumed that it's a one-size-fits-all solution. Psychological studies are hard, and human suffering is hard to measure. CBT is abusing this fact in order to appear scientifically valid, but as the saying goes, not everything that is measurable is important, and not everything that is important is measurable.
- webmobdev 3y agoIt sounds like you've had an awful experience with CBT. Whatever be the therapy, the skill and experience of the therapist matters a lot too. From what you've said, I get the feeling that you think (or experienced) that CBT is all goals, task and work without being properly heard or understood. That is absolutely not so. CBT is built upon the older "talk" therapies, including Behaviour therapy. And listening and empathising with the patient is very much an important part of it too. Yes, it is important to understand the "current state of affairs" and "desired state of affairs" for goal setting (again, something common in most "talk" therapies, and definitely not a new feature of CBT). But that doesn't mean that the moment you meet a CBT therapist, they give you a pad and ask you to write down these things - good therapists actually spend the first one or two sessions talking to you to understand your issues, figure out your personality, explore your problems to diagnose you, clarify your concerns, and try and establish a rapport and boundary with you. (The whole basis of "talk" therapies is that talking and listening does qualitatively help people - and hence it is an integral part of CBT too). > I wouldn't be surprised if most of the people who seek therapy don't really have any major psychological issues, but are simply in need of some advice and support - CBT would be greatly exploiting that because there isn't even a test whether or not you need CBT - it's just assumed that it's a one-size-fits-all solution. Depression and anxiety are the "common cold" of mental health - everyone of us experiences it more than once in our lifetime. So yes, you would be partly right in saying people who are mildly to moderately depressed and anxious "just need some support and advise". Luckily, this is where CBT really shines - it can cure depression and anxiety without any medication (and that's been validated in many studies - in fact, it was found that not only is CBT equally as effective as anti-depressants, it is also more long-lasting than anti-depressant medication - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15809409/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15809409/ ). > CBT would be greatly exploiting that because there isn't even a test whether or not you need CBT While CBT has recently gained popularity as a self-help treatment mode, note that it is actually an empirically investigated systemic psychological treatment with various "schools of thoughts" including ACT (acceptance and commitment therapy), DBT (dialectic behaviour therapy), ST (schema therapy) CT (cognitive therapy). And there are CT diagnostics tests, like the Burns Depression Checklist or the Burns Anxiety Inventory test, that are used to determine depression and anxiety (respectively) to determine if someone needs CBT. On the more advanced issues, a psychiatrist has to diagnose if there are other serious issues (like personality disorders) at play before the treatment modality is decided. So yes, while you are absolutely right that CBT is not a "one-size-fits-all" solution, only an unethical therapist would try and treat you with CBT without proper diagnosis. While the media may portray that therapists want to keep you dependent and talking with them forever (to earn money) the reality is that a good therapists will actually recommend you to someone else if they feel you aren't progressing under their care.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoWhatever else is true, in my personal life a dose of Prozac completely transformed me from who I was to who I am. It took months, and it was a gradual change, but pretty much everyone in my life universally noticed the difference. Me most of all. I haven’t had intense thoughts for years, whereas they were a daily occurrence before. I started in 2016, and can safely say I’d be a worse person without it. I only wish I’d started when I was 17, but unfortunately my mom had the brilliant idea of slipping me antidepressants while saying they were something else, which made it rather hard to trust anything to do with antidepressants. I imagine people here have different horror stories that make it hard to just try them for a few months. There may be no clear evidence that they work, but they do something for me. What do they do, if not work? It produced a positive outcome which wasn’t placebo.
- mortureb 3y agoWill you have to take them for life?
- sillysaurusx 3y agoMaybe, but I won’t mind. Everyone’s different and experiences different side effects, but for me personally the side effects were much more preferable to the way things were.
- mortureb 3y agoI know I can look it up but what are the side effects?
- sillysaurusx 3y agoSome honest commentary is over at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37490719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37490719
- ClassyJacket 3y ago"I imagine people here have different horror stories that make it hard to just try them for a few months." Post SSRI sexual dysfunction. SSRIs cause decrease in sexual function for most people who take them while they're on them, but for some, it's permanent. There is no effective treatment, you are stuck sexually dysfunctional for the rest of your life. Doctors do not warn you this is a possibility. Just bam, no warning, life ruined forever.
- xnx 3y agoGot ketamine as part of treatment to reset a dislocated shoulder. I had no prior knowledge of the treatment or the drugs effects, so it was a pretty clean unintentional experiment. I didn't think I was depressed prior to accidentally dislocating my shoulder, but my mood was greatly improved for months afterward and I had a very different perspective on things.
- Mistletoe 3y ago> For some commentators, the recent downfall of the chemical imbalance theory has cast doubt on the use of existing antidepressant drugs, which were meant to restore the lost serotonin. Yet the data certainly suggests that they work better than placebos I would argue with this statement. Antidepressants don’t work better than active placebos like atropine that make you feel “something is different” like dry mouth or elevated heart rate. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/are-antidepressants-just-placebos-with-side-effects/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/are-antidep...
- darklycan51 3y agoWell my personal case is basically just that I had undiagnosed Attention deficit disorder, my grades and stuff suffered from it, deppression really started during covid though because I kept gaining weight as I drink too much soda and they basically banned going outside for months, ended up at 100kgs and brain fog and stuff just got even worse, ADD also got worse with weight gain. I did however manage to recover because I got supplements (vitamins/minerals) and I think those helped me enough that I managed to stop drinking soda for a while, only tea first then water and when I lost about 20kgs, my deppression went away. I stopped taking vitamins after I ran out for a while and I gained weight again, so I definitely think it's something I have a deficit of. Nowadays I am diagnosed so I take concerta, but I also take additionally the supplement (vit/min) and additionally taurine (since I saw the benefits of supplements myself not gonna lie that I am biased about them, so now I saw the study that claimed that it might help prolong your life so I said why not since it's extremely cheap and just bought a 400 pills of taurine). Is my ADD "cured"? no, but I do notice that I am somewhat more productive when I take it than not, you can't really feel the concerta, like you can a drug, it's mostly just that you without noticing lack a bit of that self restriction you have to doing mental tasks when you have ADD.
- voisin 3y agoNot depression, but I had pretty significant (to me) anxiety that seemed to permeate every spare second of my waking life. I saw a TikTok recently of someone who said Magnesium supplements helped them very quickly. I thought “what the hell” and tried it. I was shocked how fast it worked for me. Within two days the anxiety melted away. Placebo, maybe. Couldn’t care less. It worked, for all my purposes.
- Philadelphia 3y agoDo you know what form and dose you used?
- illumi2001 3y agoAny form that is chelated is usually recommended but it also depends on desired outcomes, for example threonate form of magnesium supplements is able to cross the blood brain barrier. I personally use magnesium glycinate at 200mg almost daily.
- voisin 3y agoI use Magnesium Bisgylcinate, 200mg. (Bisglycinate is apparently the same as Glycinate, just depends on how close to the scientific name the marketing people went) Some people take 500mg but I couldn’t find that in Canada. Also, despite selling Magnesium + Calcium supplements, apparently the Calcium competes with the Magnesium for absorption so never take those together.
- ehPReth 3y ago[flagged]
- afpx 3y agoNot SSRI, but Bipolar depression (4% of pop.) can be effectively managed with mood stabilizers and antipsychotics. SSRIs did almost nothing for me. But, on bipolar meds, I maintain a very steady 7.6/10 mood.
- thenerdhead 3y agoStephen Collins has done some work with probiotics to demonstrate reducing symptoms of depression for those suffering with IBS. Maybe in the future we will learn more about microbes or “psychobiotics”.