2 ms·
"Unless you turn it off, Google uses your Gmail to train an AI to finish other people's sentences. It does that by analyzing how you respond to its suggestions.
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
"Unless you turn it off, Google uses your Gmail to train an AI to finish other people's sentences. It does that by analyzing how you respond to its suggestions. And when you opt in to using a new Gmail function called Help Me Write, Google uses what you type into it to improve its AI writing, too. You can't say no."
The mass media and blogs love to present Big Tech's tactics as a fait accompli. Instead they should be making the point that "defaults" are used to deceptively "gain consent". We need legislation to stop this practice.
The paragraph begins "Unless you turn it off,...", then it states "And when you opt in ..." and then it ends with "You can't say no."
Well, which is it. Can they say no by turning it off or not opting in. Or is it impossible to say no.
Of course they can say no. And when they do, it complicates matters for Google. If saying no were useless, then privacy-eroding "defaults" and so-called "dark patterns" would not exist. Why bother tricking people into saying yes or not saying no, if saying no was meaningless and consent is an afterthought. Before you cynically conclude, "there's nothing anyone can do" (watch the replies), ask yourself why dark patterns exist and why Google pays billions to multiple companies to be the "default search engine". Big Tech and smaller so-called "tech" companies put a lot of effort into these tactics. Why. Because they are bored and enjoy manipulating people? No. (Well, maybe. But that's another topic.) It's because people can say no, and when they do, it can have potential repercussions.
Anyway, no problem with the rest of the article. Although it's more about what the companies are doing versus what computer users could be doing, namely, objecting.
- rpbiwer2 3y agoYou've touched on some good points. It makes me wonder: what kind of objection can one raise that would actually make a difference? Send a mean tweet? Call my senator? And tell them to do what? IMO simple objections will not sway tech platforms from the status quo of free-for-all data hoarding. We must vote with our feet and move away from the data-hoarding incumbents towards user-centric alternatives. Where suitable alternatives don't exist, we'll need to create them.
- EricMausler 3y agoEthical Defaults is something I've been casually supporting for a long time. I think the statistics around organ donation are what got me started on it. We really should have legislation mandating minimum consent by default options, and then additional legislation that creates allowances for non-minimum consent on a case-by-case basis. So we can allow, if we want, for organ donation to be consented to by default if the general public feels it is more ethical to default to consent on that option than not. And if harvesting everyone's data for AI is going to be default, then we would need a similar public consensus The more work a company needs to do to get consent from its users, the less bullshit they are going to create and try to get away with because they'll need to actually convince people to care enough to change their defaults. It will better align incentives between consumers and companies imo