8 ms·
Is it though? The promise of gaming on iPhone (and mobile gaming in general) has been taken over and destroyed by freemium games whose only goal is to push micr
by paxys 3y ago
Is it though? The promise of gaming on iPhone (and mobile gaming in general) has been taken over and destroyed by freemium games whose only goal is to push microtransactions. What is a marginally better GPU going to accomplish? Help games sell me their "bundle of gems" faster?
Developers simply do not have the incentive to build any other kinds of games when the current crop of addictive shovelware is so damn profitable. The sad part is that Apple encourages this practice because it is easy money for them (via their 30% cut). The problem needs to be fixed by better quality control and transaction/gambling rules, not a faster processor.
- mcphage 3y agoI think there will always be a market for freemium games, because it's nice to try things without having to put money down. But I think the freemium market can co-exist with a premium game market. Like, the premium game market still exists and still is going strong, no reason it couldn't live on mobile devices also.
- afavour 3y ago> But I think the freemium market can co-exist with a premium game market I agree... but there isn't one. And I don't think it's because of an underpowered GPU.
- mcphage 3y agoI agree.
- paxys 3y ago> But I think the freemium market can co-exist with a premium game market Not so when all the big gaming mobile companies are assigning their top talent to building stuff like Clash of Kings. And why wouldn't they, when they can make so much more money doing so than working on a quality prestige game that no one will pay for. > the premium game market still exists and still is going strong, no reason it couldn't live on mobile devices also. It's actually the opposite. Mobile-style microtransactions are slowly taking over the premium PC/console gaming market.
- stephc_int13 3y agoGamedev here. If you look at the numbers on mobile, it makes no sense from a business perspective to create non-F2P games on this platform. You can still make money with so-called "premium" games, that were simply normal games before Apple poisoned the well, but the potential is considerably lower.
- bombcar 3y agoI can't think of (offhand) even one premium game that is native to iOS, everything is or got a port. Part of it may be the "don't want to pay upfront" but shareware knows how that goes (free first part of the game, then pay $30 for the rest or whatever).
- danaris 3y agoI really, really hate the mindset that it "makes no sense" to do something that's not absolutely the most profitable course possible. If a game developer can make a living making "premium" games, then it makes sense to do so, especially with the very real ethical problems with making free-to-play games laden with microtransactions. Just because you would only ever choose to do what makes you the most money possible, and damn the rest of the world, that doesn't mean everyone would or should make that choice.
- com2kid 3y ago> If a game developer can make a living making "premium" games, then it makes sense to do so, especially with the very real ethical problems with making free-to-play games laden with microtransactions. Most developers cannot make a living selling premium games on mobile. There have been plenty of cost breakdowns posted to HN by game developers. Occasionally a big mega-hit can make a profit, but for the majority of developers, free is now the only viable way.
- theshrike79 3y agoThe cold hard fact is that F2P games bring in RIDICULOUS amounts of money. I moved from doing code for industrial use and public admin as a consultant to mobile gaming. We have one hit game and the _daily_ marketing (a.k.a. user acquisition) budget for us is an order of magnitude bigger than the biggest projects I did at my old job. All the "ethical problems" usually are just older (usually) men in IT not understanding that people want to pay money to have fun. Some people go to bars to relax after a work week and drop $100 gladly. Others use that for going to the movies, some go to have a nice dinner. And some people really like relaxing while playing games and they want to pay for that, because they think it's worth the price.
- GeekyBear 3y ago> The promise of gaming on iPhone (and mobile gaming in general) has been taken over and destroyed by freemium games whose only goal is to push microtransactions. Wasn't that a reaction to users who refused to pay for games and just sideloaded them instead? I can remember there being five dollar games in the early days of iOS that sold well. I can also remember developers trying games that had ads until you paid to remove them.
- albedoa 3y ago> Wasn't that a reaction to users who refused to pay for games and just sideloaded them instead? No. That was a minuscule number of people. It was a reaction to Candy Crush making insane amounts of money using casino mechanics.
- GeekyBear 3y ago> No. That was a minuscule number of people. I can certainly remember developers of early popular games that you paid for up front saying that they tracked how many copies of their game were out there, and only a minuscule percentage of those games had been paid for,
- lawlessone 3y agoIt's far easier to pirate on PC yet we have plenty of non freemium games. And hardest to pirate games on iOS yet theres a glut of freemium games. On Android you'd still have to explicitly enable side loading I don't think piracy is the issue here, the issue is on mobile devices you already have quick payments setup for very fast transactions through the app stores. It's easier to assume to assume the person using the phone authorized to make the transaction and enable lots of small transactions. On PC it's much easier to enter my card details for each new transaction, so i never save the card in Steam etc. Doing the same on the phone is tiring, so i have my card saved. Apple and Google also make a little money on these transactions and have less incentive to promote non freemium games.
- michaelt 3y ago
- gretch 3y agoThis is a really short sighted and defeatist view on the potential of mobile gaming. Mobile gaming started before iPhones, and it will be around probably for the rest of human civilization. There is no way 1 generation of games can "take over and destroy" the "promise of gaming" because there are no restrictions on what future innovators can do with the tools and the platforms. The existence of some bad games doesn't preclude future good games. As an example, my favorite mobile game is Slay the Spire
- goosedragons 3y agoIs Slay the Spire a mobile game or a game ported to mobile? It originally launched on PC, then consoles then mobile. It's a game that works well on mobile and on touchscreens yet that wasn't the priority...
- pradn 3y agoNothing will change barring a change in economics (subsidies for quality games, Apple not taking a 30% cut on microtransactions, somehow prices for good indie games going up) or a change in human nature (people seem to just play shitty games from what I see in the NYC subway). We already have beautiful mobile games, like Monument Valley. But that's not what the market is about. The very term "mobile game" reeks of low quality at this point. I don't see it changing.
- gretch 3y ago> We already have beautiful mobile games, like Monument Valley. But that's not what the market is about. The very term "mobile game" reeks of low quality at this point. What exactly is it that you are after? It seems like you are not content simply getting the games you want, such as Monument Valley. You also need everyone else to live their life a certain way? Why not simply conclude that the market is big enough for everyone to coexist. And as long as there's games for you, you don't have to lament other people sitting around enjoying candy crush.
- derefr 3y ago
- xienze 3y agoYeah, exactly. They’ve been playing up how the latest iPad/iPhone/etc. is just as powerful as <some previous generation console> for years now. And I don’t doubt that. But it doesn’t do much good when barely anything approaching AAA gaming shows up on the platform. The potential is wasted on lots of garbage freemium games.
- Firmwarrior 3y agoYeah, I'm so sick of lugging a Switch and a ridiculously huge Steam Deck around when my iPhone 14 is way more powerful than either one, but all that power is wasted since there just aren't enough decent games to play
- nmarinov 3y agoI guess the emphasis is on enough but I was pleasantly surprised to find some really good games on Apple Arcade: Slay the Spire, Dead Cells, Exit the Gungeon, Limbo, Stardew Valley, The Oregon Trail, Cityscapes. A lot more outside Apple Arcade but I prefer buying them on Steam so not much first hand experience with them.
- carlosjobim 3y agoBefore smart phones became something for everybody, 99% of "gamers" would game on lottery tickets, casinos, slot machines and such. They are still the majority and they want their slot machines, where they don't have to think or learn to progress. Computer / video game tropes are just an aesthetic to skin a slot machine on your phone.
- lawlessone 3y agoSome truth to this, many people playing mobile games would never have owned a laptop/PC/console. They play these games on the commute or while watching TV. A "full fledged" game and it's large upfront costs wouldn't interest them.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThank you, you said it much better than me.
- wmf 3y agoApple's new gaming strategy (as of today) is ports of console games. It's not worth developing good games specifically for mobile but that's not necessary if iDevices can run console ports.
- absoluteunit1 3y agoI really wish micro transactions were made illegal in applications on the app stores…and video games in general. It encourages additive behaviour and lowers the quality of games as the purpose becomes to make the additive micro transaction aspect as addictive as possible. If some new policy changed this, I think we’d see a whole new wave of higher quality games
- NeoTar 3y agoHow would you define a micro-transaction? Maybe we need a pornography-like definition ("I know it when I see it") but I think there is certainly a continuum from high-quality DLC / expansions to existing games (which can be basically a new game) down to crystals which allow you to instantly buy something which you'd have got anyway if you had waited. So, consider a basic, Mario-kart like racing game - which of these are OK, and which are micro-transactions? - buying additional courses, - buying additional characters (drivers), vehicles, or components of vehicle (e.g. wheels, engines, bodies), - buying purely cosmetic changes (e.g. driver outfits, vehicle colours), - buying permanent upgrades to your vehicle(s) (i.e. more speed, better acceleration, better handling) - buying one-off power-ups that last for a single race, or are time-limited (+50% acceleration for 1 hour) - buying 'cheats' - obvious play-to-win items (e.g. needing to complete 1 fewer lap than your opponent), - buying regular game-progression; e.g. maybe 100 races/wins/hours of play are normally required to unlock all courses, but this can also be instantly purchased. - any of the above options, but not bought directly, but rather via purchasing 'crystals' which can be exchanged for the above. - any of the above options, but in a 'gatcha' style (i.e. loot boxes; you cannot choose which upgrade you want), I think I'd be totally OK with the top three, maybe OK with buying permanent upgrades, and unlocking game progression (in this case), but the others are too far for me.
- jquery 3y agoAll of them are micro-transactions. Some micro transactions are tolerable, some of the time, but every single one of these commercializes the product. IMO if they exist, the game should be free-to-play. Where I really get annoyed are games like Lego2K (racing game) where you pay $60 to play, and then it's also full of microtransactions (for cars, courses, cosmetics, you name it). I think it's a different matter when it's a content-filled DLC add-on to the game. Yes, the line for that is a bit arbitrary, but the classic example would be Starcraft: Brood War (well, technically that was an expansion pack, but same idea). Adding a single additional course to a racing game blurs the line, I generally think content should be bundled so the gamer isn't constantly making financial decisions while playing.
- jacobr1 3y agoThey built Arcade+ in part to provide alternative to microtransaction games.
- danudey 3y agoAnd there are a lot of games out there featuring microtransactions, but which also have Apple Arcade versions which don't have microtransactions. It's pretty great to be able to grab a game that looks fun and know that you can just sit down and play it, rather than having to tap through seven different pop-up windows trying to sell you on the battle pass, buying boosts, buying more coins, spending the coins you already have so that you'll have to buy more coins next time you need coins, three different currencies, are you sure you want to restart the level you can just keep playing for only a buck!, and so on.
- mjamesaustin 3y agoOh, I did not know this! Can you confirm if microtransactions are prohibited amongst Apple Arcade games? This would be a big selling point for me.
- simonh 3y agoThey are. Apple Arcade is about at the point where it has enough great games that it might be worth it. Certainly it’s well worth paying for a few months to try them all out.
- lxgr 3y agoThey are indeed prohibited as far as I know and experienced, which makes it a great selling (and gifting) point of me as well!
- edualm 3y agoNot who you are replying to, but I can confirm it!
- theshrike79 3y agoThey are 100% IAP and ad free. One of the reasons I got Apple One, the kids can install an endless amount of decent to excellent games from there and I don't need to worry about them wasting money on them or getting predatory ads. Sneaky Sasquatch is the hidden gem in there. It starts off simple, but it's a really cool and complex world you can explore
- mdavidn 3y agoEarly mobile games were such a delight. I have fond memories of Angry Birds, Plants vs Zombies, Cut the Rope, Flight Control, Threes, Monument Valley, Bad Piggies... But then predatory freemium games like Clash of Clans and newer replacements for Angry Birds and Plants vs Zombies burned me out. They eliminated any desire I had to invest time or money or attention into mobile games. Popular freemium games in the App Store now bury any new gems. It's quite disappointing. A better GPU isn't going to help the situation.
- simonh 3y agoIt’s still a bit thin on top class games, but I still hold out hope for Apple Arcade.
- firecall 3y agoApple Arcade is excellent value IMHO!
- javajosh 3y ago>Angry Birds, Plants vs Zombies, Cut the Rope, Flight Control, Threes My list of games is basically the same. I think they are legitimately rare, and we believe at the time that they are not. It's like YouTube. You find one 3blue1brown or Adam Neely and you think there are a hundred more. There aren't.
- itishappy 3y agoAnybody remember GeoDefence or Tap Tap Revenge? These weren't hidden gems either, these were front and center promoted links in the App Store. I'm sure it's possible to find experiences like these in modern games, but I've given up hope long ago. I don't have time to sift through the trash.
- jerojero 3y agoI still play Threes! to this day, still haven't been able to get a 6000 card even after all these years. I don't think there's a mobile game out there that has given me more entertainment.
- nebula8804 3y agoAt least on a positive note: an iPhone + Dev account + some tiny controller addon can equal a great pocket emulation machine on the go. If someone can design a nice controller add on, we can ditch the Chinese pocket gameboy/switch/other extra devices you dont need. It so absurd: We need to carry the device anyway since its a phone, it has a great GPU and there are thousands of existing great games that have been created that the device can easily run. The only problem has always been the stupidity of the code not being available to run on this device. :/
- rcarr 3y agoYou might want to have a look at the razer kishi. Alternatively if you want a standalone controller, you might want to look at the following 8bitdo products: - sn30 pro - lite 2 - zero - micro The latter two are comically miniscule. In my opinion the sn30 pro is the sweet spot between portability and actually being able to play comfortably.
- nebula8804 3y agoThese suggestions look really good. Thank You!
- jordanmorgan10 3y agoI mean…I don’t entirely agree, they’ve created an entire service to avoid the problems you are describing with Apple Arcade.
- armchairhacker 3y ago> Developers simply do not have the incentive to build any other kinds of games when the current crop of addictive shovelware is so damn profitable. Personally, I don’t have the incentive because 1) paid mobile gaming isn’t a big market (see: top paid apps being the exact same years-old, curated Apple apps not having many reviews/downloads), 2) there aren’t many options to develop games targeting iOS which also target Android and Windows/Linux (at least if you want to use Swift), and 3) Apple could remove my game at any notice and I don’t get 30% of the revenue. If Apple introduces a way to easily port desktop games to iOS, or even develop entirely new games which can run on Linux and mac and iPhone, I think we’d see a lot more iOS games. Maybe the new GPU isn’t only faster but also supports Vulkan/wgpu better?
- runjake 3y agoDid the Game Porting Toolkit[1] and the Unity integrations not meet that last need? If not, where have they fallen short? Legitimately asking. I'm not up to speed on the subject. 1. https://developer.apple.com/games/planning/#bring-games-to-apple-platforms https://developer.apple.com/games/planning/#bring-games-to-a...
- Cloudef 3y agoIts not only the low quality games, mobile controls also suck for gaming.
- enos_feedler 3y agoOne of the main benefits of Apple Arcade was to recognize this problem and carve out a space for games that do not suffer from these issues (while making services revenue at the same time). I think it worked pretty well. It doesn't have the AAA though.
- Hammershaft 3y agoBetween terrible incentives created by Apple's cut structure, and Apple's disregard for backwards compatibility, mobile indie devs never stood a chance. Rami from Vlambeer said it well. “You earn $3 and then you update it for the next 10 years. If you’re making free-to-play games, if you keep earning money with a game, yeah, that’s a great model because you can make more money by updating.” Ismail pointed to Vlambeer’s “Ridiculous Fishing,” which won a number of awards from gaming publications and Apple. “‘Ridiculous Fishing’ is never going to make more money,” he said. “Yeah, some new people might buy it, but we made our money with ‘Ridiculous Fishing’ in 2013 and that money is spent, It’s spent on ‘Luftrausers.’ It’s spent on ‘Nuclear Throne.’ If somebody upgrades their phones to the new iPhone. Yeah. You have ‘Ridiculous Fishing’ in your account, Yeah you paid $3 for it. Yeah, it’s broken.” That’s what caused the last major update Vlambeer did for the game. A major change by Apple in 2017 that switched from 32-bit to 64-bit apps, breaking a slew of content on their phones … including “Ridiculous Fishing.” “All games broke,” he said, “Every game that wasn’t programmed for it broke. We updated ‘Ridiculous Fishing’ then but it feels like a mistake almost. It feels like, OK it’s 2018 and this game that we made money with that somebody bought in 2013 is now broken outside of our fault. We didn’t change anything. We didn’t break the game. We didn’t introduce a bug, but this continuous ecosystem that Apple has created, that comes with you with every new phone, broke it. “ Ismail said that either Apple has to start designing for backward compatibility support on their end or that people are going to have to get used to the idea of games dying and disappearing. “Some of the best ios games from 2010 are gone,” he said. “Those developers, they don’t exist anymore. They went out of business. They split up. They started a new thing and they just don’t have the money or time to do it.” https://variety.com/2019/gaming/features/android-ios-apple-google-game-dev-problems-1203191551/ https://variety.com/2019/gaming/features/android-ios-apple-g...
- Gareth321 3y agoWell said. Apple has no incentive to improve backwards compatibility because they make more money keeping the transactions flowing. People being apple to use their applications for a long time is bad for business. Unfortunately the market hasn't punished them for this behaviour, so they keep doing it.
- faeriechangling 3y agoNever had much trouble finding quality phone games which don’t use this model. Some of the most popular mobile games in the world like PUBG are not like this.