2 ms·
> you have your phone with the SIM card. Yeah, or a fraudster that talked my provider in to SIM-swapping it or porting out my number (quite possible, since man
by lxgr 3y ago
> you have your phone with the SIM card.
Yeah, or a fraudster that talked my provider in to SIM-swapping it or porting out my number (quite possible, since many phone providers don't have 2FA themselves!), or malware on my Android phone with access to incoming SMS, or (although much less likely) an SS7 attacker...
A SIM is indeed a smart card theoretically capable of acting as a true "possession" factor (e.g. using EAP-AKA/EAP-SIM, although almost nobody uses that) – but calling it a possession factor for SMS-OTP is at least as much as a stretch as calling an email inbox a knowledge-only factor: Accessing my inbox requires a FIDO authenticator and password.
> Note that NIST also recommends against email as a factor in 2FA
I guess bad decisions and/or lobbying aren't limited to European regulators/legislators then.