3 ms·
.. and how many of the Microsoft applications actually use WinUI3? As far as I can tell they're doing their own thing (Office) or are Electron (Teams) or, at le
by pjc50 3y ago
.. and how many of the Microsoft applications actually use WinUI3? As far as I can tell they're doing their own thing (Office) or are Electron (Teams) or, at least in Windows 10, haven't actually been updated from WinForms.
The overhead of WinUI3 is pretty huge. The visual designer, a winning feature of Visual Studio for decades, is AWOL. Why? It's XAML, the same as the previous XAML designer! It's just .. broken?
The backward compatibility story is a disaster: you can get stuck in the UWP sandbox https://github.com/microsoft/WindowsAppSDK/issues/1780 https://github.com/microsoft/WindowsAppSDK/issues/1780
What's the big Microsoft WinUI3 flagship app, then? Something people are actually using? Rather than just a few system dialogues. (How many Win11 settings pop up a Win32 dialogue box, still?)
- fassssst 3y agoFile Explorer is using it. Much of the Windows 11 shell, including the taskbar, Start menu, Settings, notifications, and Microsoft Store is using WinUI 2 (only because WinUI 3 wasn’t ready at the time). Even apps like Notepad, Paint, Sound Recorder and Media Player use WinUI. WinUI 2 and WinUI 3 currently share the same look and feel but new apps should use WinUI 3.
- pjc50 3y ago> new apps should use WinUI 3 Other than apps written by the Windows team and shipped with Windows, what's the flagship WinUI3 app? How large is the actual WinUI team, approximately? We can make guesses from the number of committers on github, which appears to be about half a dozen people? It just doesn't feel like Microsoft themselves are really committed to making it work and then forcing it on Office or Teams. At some point soon I'm going to have to do a native app to do driver control, and it seems the elegant simplicity of WinForms has been lost compared to how much "runtime" nonsense is hiding underneath the two different WinUI2/3 implementations. (You've done a Python 3 there!)
- fassssst 3y agoThe new Apple apps and WhatsApp and Adobe Fresco use WinUI. Arc browser’s upcoming Windows version uses WinUI.