4 ms·
> The general principle that governs taste is the association of ideas, and this, fortunately, can be most easily illustrated: “I like such a person because her
by pjc50 3y ago
> The general principle that governs taste is the association of ideas, and this, fortunately, can be most easily illustrated: “I like such a person because her voice puts me in mind of my mother’s. I like this walk because I was very happy the last time I was here with my sister. I think green is the prettiest of all colors; my father’s room is painted green, and it is very cheerful, and I have been very happy in that room, and besides, the grass is green in spring.”
This feels like an extraordinarily Modern view, in that it's not suffering from the idea of an ideal standard of divine beauty embedded in the universe, but rather that it is discovered by the viewer and their emotional associations.
It's also very pluralist, this advice to expose your child to the best examples of art from a variety of cultures.
- shakow 3y ago> in that it's not suffering from the idea of an ideal standard of divine beauty embedded in the universe Frankly, it's your take that feels extraordinarily modern. Do you really believe that people living at this time, being familiar with centuries of style movements (from Greco-Roman antiquity to Italian Renaissance through Baroque and Bronze age Egypt) that were all considered to be beautiful, would cling to an ideal standard of beauty? Why do modern humans believe that for some reason, they discovered thinking very recently and that all their forefathers were obscure brutes?
- pjc50 3y agoYou can find people today arguing for a single absolute standard of beauty. Usually they mean "neoclassical architecture". And indeed it's what the original author from that time was arguing against, the "bigotry" mentioned. So it was clearly an attitude held by some people at the time.
- mistrial9 3y agoI can find identical twins joined at the hip today, too .. that does not mean it is prevalent or even important to note in every example
- ilyt 3y ago> You can find people today arguing for a single absolute standard of beauty. Usually they mean "neoclassical architecture". And I'd call them imbeciles, why you think that "the people like that exist" is argument for anything ?
- castlecrasher2 3y ago>And I'd call them imbeciles, why you think that "the people like that exist" is argument for anything ? I agree, I don't understand these sorts of arguments. While I suppose deference to anecdotal evidence has always been around it seems more and more prolific as of late, and more often than is used as justification for a baseless argument simply because others argue baselessly.
- Dig1t 3y agoThey are not only arguing in favor of neoclassical architecture, I have met plenty of people who believe that Bauhaus is the only standard of beauty and that every space should look and feel like an Apple Store.
- mistrial9 3y agoBela Lagosi is dead! he is dead!
- shakow 3y agoI'm not saying there were no dumb people in the past, I'm saying that being amazed that most people of the past could not see further than their nose is a very naive take.
- hoseja 3y agoThey also sometimes argue for Art Deco any others. Basically anything that is the anathema of CAD-drawn monstrosity of rebar concrete sheetmetal and glass by an establishment celebrity architect with overblown ego.
- finite_depth 3y agoAs a person very much raised with heavy upper-class British influence (one side of my family comes from nobility, and while I'm American, I maintain very strong cultural, philosophical, and even linguistic ties to Britain), I'm gonna take this top comment spot to hang on a caution: this way of thinking can be really really bad for you in sufficient quantities. It turns experiences into thoughts. It separates you from your emotions by changing your priority from experiencing, processing, and accepting your feelings to trying to analyze them. And if you, like me, are prone to mental illness, this can be devastating - because emotions often do not have a reason, especially if your brain has strong natural tendencies. When you're depressed or anxious, sadness or anxiety form of their own accord. You can feel terrible even when things around you are good, or scared even when there is no danger. And it is very easy to get into the habit of trying to justify these feelings after the fact. When you feel sad and the world around you provides you no reason to, the justification you can give - if you're trying to rationalize your emotions - is that the problem is you, and that is an abyss you can easily find yourself trapped in. Worse, this habit leads to you being "on the side of" those tendencies. When someone tries to help you to understand that your view of the world is skewed, your habit of justifying and rationalizing makes that feel like an attack on your reason or intelligence. You're not depressed, see, because there's this logical reason you came up with for why you feel bad. And there is always a reason you can give, a justification for why you feel bad, because life always has problems that can be invoked to explain emotions that exist in their own right. But they're not why you're miserable, they're just the reasons you give for why being miserable is rational and right. Healing from that kind of illness requires recognizing your reason and your feelings are different things with different roles, and that to try to rationalize emotion is to make a category error. Introspection can be good, but introspection must pair with experience, not replace it. You may like such a person because her voice puts you in mind of your mother's, but that origin or association is usually not what is important - the fact that you like them is. You may like the walk because you had a lovely day on it once, but what matters is that the walk brings you joy. The analysis is useful largely when your emotions misguide you ("I keep getting into bad relationships because they draw from X emotional weakness", for example), but even then, you want to feel your feelings even if you do not let them guide your beliefs. When I'm in a depressive episode, I can't not feel bad, but what I can do is recognize that my negative feelings are not truths about the world, so that they do not poison me into a factual belief that things can never improve. When I'm anxious, I can't not feel the fear, but I can recognize that it's not a sign of real danger and that I may need to endure it to make some personal progress. These things aren't about rational understanding of my emotions, they're about a recognition that I do not and cannot control them, only how I respond to them. I tend to think this sort of thing is a pretty big "original sin" of Anglo-American (or perhaps more generally Protestant?) culture. It arises in a kind of guilt-based virtue ethics, one that I think was originally religious, that tells us that our moral value comes from our impulses and drives, not from what we choose to do with them. It told me, in particular, that my inability to force myself to be more motivated or calm was a personal failing, not a piece of me fundamentally separate from my reason or my virtue. It tells us, as a culture, not to listen to ourselves, not to accept half of what we are, in favor of suppression and repression and self-judgement, and it leaves us as half-people as a result.
- hoseja 3y agoAlso, on topic of green rooms in Britain, they were most likely toxic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scheele%27s_Green https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scheele%27s_Green