5 ms·
The Stoics were right – emotional control is good for the soul
- xchip 3y agoWhat a surprise to discover that lack of emotional control is a bad thing.
- eimrine 3y agoWhat a surprise to discover that emotions are able to be controlled.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoWhen I began practicing Centering Prayer / Hesychasm, I was indeed surprised to learn that I could take control of my thoughts in a very real way, and thereby control my emotions as well. Since we spend all day, every day, immersed in our own thoughts, it is not easy to realize what types of thoughts are abnormal, or unwanted, or uncontrolled, until we start quantifying that and comparing them to other people's experiences. Myself, suffering C-PTSD and a lot of ruminating, recurring negative thoughts, of course they hold me back, and I do not want them. So contemplation is a good opportunity to take control of thoughts, or more precisely, to let go of that which is unwanted, to just let them float down the stream while I observe and direct. To center my thoughts on Christ and contemplate His essence, this is the core of existence. Once I complete a session, my emotions are calmed, anger is quelled, and I also find that the associated physiological symptoms are improved commensurately. My PCP, for example, pressured me so hard to go on statins, that I practiced some intensive Centering Prayer for a few months while eating organic, home-cooked meals. I monitored my blood pressure, and I was able to demonstrate concrete and dramatic improvement over a few months' time.
- xchip 3y agoThis looks like an advertisement.
- robnado 3y agoThis raises the question of why passion and empathy are so in vogue these days.
- r4t4t4k 3y agoNot only that. The stoic values also seem to be under much scrutiny in the broader "toxic masculinity" narrative.
- Sakos 3y agoI mean, we know why. It's been co-opted by toxic male communities and is being bastardized by people who twist it to justify them being assholes. It is interesting though that Stoicism has this problem but Buddhism doesn't, even though they have similar ideals and concepts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoBecause Buddhism is strongly non violent
- whythre 3y agoThat’s largely just the brand of Buddhism that’s gotten the most bandwidth in the west. Historically some variants were exceptionally violent. Feudal Japan had entire sects of Buddhist warrior-monks they accepted and even celebrated violence. A modern example of followers of Buddhism engaged in violent conflict is myanmar’s 969.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoThat is the exception not the norm though. Non violence is one of the strongest tenets of Buddhism. Bhikkhus, even if bandits were to sever you savagely limb by limb with a two-handled saw, he who gave rise to a mind of hate towards them would not be carrying out my teaching. — Kakacūpama Sutta, Majjhima-Nikāya 28 at MN i 128-29 So it is quite hard for the red pill movement to co opt Buddhism and thank goodness for that.
- bigredhdl 3y agoI've been wanting a device that would notify me when it detects that I am getting emotional. Particularly if my heart starts pounding and my voice is raised. I was hopeful that Amazon's Halo would be that device, but it's voice analysis was not always on and you had to go look at it after the fact.
- smokey_bajokey 3y agoYou come with self-awareness built in. Costs nothing
- jrh3 3y agoFeelings are not facts.
- yencabulator 3y agoIt could be considered a fact that you can be experiencing some emotion. Our scientific ability to read brain's inner functioning isn't quite there to measure it objectively, but I find that plausible. Measuring changes in your heart rate, face flushing, breathing and on are definitely objective facts. More to the point, our potential ability one day to objectively say "this person is experiencing loneliness" doesn't strengthen the importance of the feeling, so whether they're "facts" or not isn't really relevant. I'd try this instead: Feelings are just feelings, and don't have to be anything more than that. Observe them in yourself, but choose what you do about them.
- rg111 3y agoI have a question- why does Stoicism get this much attention in the digital space, as compared to other schools? I found Epicureanism, Existentialism (esp. Nietzsche, Heidegger, Camus NOT Sartre), and the writing of Montaigne to be much more relevant in this day and age. Why is Stoicism disproportionately famous? Is it because of Aurelius's Meditations? Writings of a Roman Emperor that every average Joe can confidently think that they understand? Any other reasons?
- robnado 3y agoIn a world that has gone so far in the direction of hedonism, the opposite message is a centring force that helps people find balance in their lives. As one of my coworkers used to say “always choose the middle way”. I’m honestly more surprised that people aren’t talking enthusiastically about asceticism to be honest.
- rg111 3y agoWho is living in all this hedonism? Every person like me (white collar middle/upper-middle class) is extemely aware of their health, regulates choice of food severely, lives a disciplined life. Every poor person I know works two shifts or has a secondary occupation to make ends meet, and is one medical emergency away from bankruptcy. Now, I have known few uber-rich who live in hedonistic ways, but the number is extremely small. All of us are living an extremely self-regulated lives. Where are all the hedonistic people I keep hearing about? I am seriously asking.
- yungporko 3y agoi'm not being hyperbolic when i say that i genuinely don't know a single person in real life whose life isn't entirely governed by the search for instant pleasure/gratification.
- _kulang 3y agoRemember than hedonism is not necessarily about all of those rich pleasures. It’s a philosophy. And you are most likely surrounded by people like yourself, so you probably can’t see it. I see plenty of regular people who are driven by feeling good almost entirely