10 ms·
Physicists Observe ‘Unobservable’ Quantum Phase Transition
- smfugit 3y agoIts almost sounding like sociology, watching groups of people bumping into each other and measuring what info is retained.
- firtoz 3y agoAllegedly physics conferences are where most of the entanglement of your kind happens
- moomin 3y agoIt’s interesting to note that by this point “Quantum Supremacy” is well and truly established and is being used for something that’s actually useful. What we still lack, however, is any demonstrated supremacy outside the realm of “model quantum mechanics”.
- prof-dr-ir 3y agoCan you provide some evidence for your first sentence? As far as I can see, this article is about a prediction made by theorists about the evolution of certain quantum devices when you frequently measure part of it. This was a nice theoretical idea which has now been tested experimentally. The article itself does not seem to contain any claim of quantum supremacy, even for this specific subject. Also, while I think the research is really cute, I do not see it being 'actually useful' in any sense - and the article also does not seem to make such a claim.
- moomin 3y agoI’d claim this highlights just quite how established quantum supremacy is. Specifically, they just did the work using quantum computers because they were the best tool for the job. We’ve moved on from the question of “are they good for anything”? In the field of quantum simulation they’re manifestly useful. “Useful”, however, doesn’t need to be transitive. It’s perfectly possible for it to be useful to perform research without the research itself being useful.
- bowsamic 3y ago> Physicists have since largely shed that discomfort. They now understand what Einstein, and perhaps Schrödinger himself, had overlooked — that entanglement has no remote influence. Very false. Many many physicists still accept non-locality
- ithkuil 3y agoMost of the times that's because we find it hard to imagine how it would "feel" being ourselves entangled with the thing we observe. Accepting that there is effectively a copy of you that is effectively fully casually disconnected from you goes strongly against our instinct that wants us to be "us" unique and objectively existing
- neom 3y agoCan you dive into this a little more? I think I understand what you're saying but it's a very interesting idea and I'd love to understand it more if you don't mind. :)
- eurier_br 3y agoI, personally (and a bunch of other physicists), think that the issue is not exactly the entanglement. If you take a pair of gloves and send each piece to two separate people, the moment either of them open the box they will know instantly which piece (left or right) the other got, because both of them knows that a pair of gloves comes with a right piece and a left piece. This is why entanglement doesn't violate general relativity, each person updates their knowledge instantaneously but there is no flow of information from one person to the other. The true issue, according to some people (me, an experimental materials science-focused physicist, included), is the measurement problem. It updates the state of entangled systems instantaneously, including very space-separated systems. In this way the measurement is provokes the collapse of the quantum state in a non-local way. The problem is that the effects of measurement in quantum systems described by a postulate in quantum theory. So, in my opinion, the non-locality remains not explained and is generally neglected as a non-issue by the community at large.
- robinduckett 3y agoPreface: I know nothing. Is it really a problem that we can’t apply special relativity to subatomic particles? Doesn’t the very nature of our measuring systems being made of atoms and subatomic particles mean they will always destructively interfere with any quantum effect we wish to measure?
- Etheryte 3y agoEven if your measuring system interferes with the measurement, if the interference is small enough or diverse enough based on the conditions, you can still learn useful things.
- prof-dr-ir 3y agoBut we do apply special relativity to subatomic particles, using a framework called relativistic quantum field theory. It is important to consider relativistic effects when the subatomic particles move close to the speed of light, which they do in particle accelerators. So the outcome of accelerator experiments is described extremely well by relativistic quantum field theory. The hard part is combining the principles of relativistic quantum field theory with general relativity, or gravity, which describes how matter propagates in a space curved by its very presence. The effects of gravity are indeed completely negligible in particle accelerator experiments, which is why we can describe their outcome in a theory that does not include gravity. But these same effects dominate in other scenarios, for example in early universe cosmology and black hole physics. Understanding the physics of these other scenarios is one motivation, but on top of that physicists just find it really irksome to not have a single theory that (at least in principle) describes all physics at once, because it indicates that they are missing something fundamental. That is why they are working so hard on topics like string theory. All of this is is no way related to the article, by the way. First, everything related to the measurement 'paradox' is a big deal in popular science but firmly in the rear view mirror for almost all practicing physicists. Second, the experiments discussed in the article are described perfectly with ordinary quantum mechanics, which in the above context is just a limiting case of relativistic quantum field theory. (In particular, of course doing a measurement means interfering with the system, but that is all understood perfectly well and does not mean that we cannot observe quantum effects.)
- datavirtue 3y agoI think we should have these people explain all of this to toddlers and let them give the thumbs up or thumbs down.
- imglorp 3y agoIs this finding consistent with Wolfram's hypergraph?
- mike_ivanov 3y ago<rolling-eyes>Einstein disliked the reach of entanglement (which he would later refer to as "spooky")</rolling-eyes>