3 ms·
They tried so hard. I went through Stanford CS in the 1980s, just as it was becoming clear that the predicate-calculus / expert systems approach to AI wasn't g
by Animats 3y ago
They tried so hard.
I went through Stanford CS in the 1980s, just as it was becoming clear that the predicate-calculus / expert systems approach to AI wasn't going to do much outside of very well defined problem spaces. It was very frustrating. I'd already done machine proof of correctness work, but that's in a problem space you can formalize. So I had a sense of the limits of the approach, and was rather surprised by the broad claims made for it at Stanford.
I took McCarthy's "Epistemological problems in artificial intelligence" class. One day he was describing the missionary-and-cannibals problem (amusingly, in a less violent form). He started out with it as a word problem, and then he set it up so that his new "circumscription" approach could be applied. Turn the crank on that algorithm, and an answer pops out. The word problem to formalism conversion struck me as the step where, as an old New Yorker cartoon showing a mathematician explaining something put it, "a miracle occurs".
Formalizing the problem is the hard part.
The classic critique along those lines is "Artificial Intelligence meets Natural Stupidity", by Drew McDermott.[1] That was written in 1976, and basically describes why that class of AI systems hit a wall in the 1980s. The "AI Winter" followed, the 1980s AI startups went bust, and not much happened for 15 years. Well-known history.
[1] https://cs.fit.edu/~kgallagher/Schtick/Serious/McDermott.AI.MeetsNaturalStupidity.pdf https://cs.fit.edu/~kgallagher/Schtick/Serious/McDermott.AI....