4 ms·
gorhill is a hero and legend to me. One of the most important players in making the modern web. I'm still holding out hope that either he or someone else pick
by freedomben 3y ago
gorhill is a hero and legend to me. One of the most important players in making the modern web.
I'm still holding out hope that either he or someone else picks uMatrix back up. It's such an incredible tool, and I'm worried about the day when it no longer works.
- frogelos 3y agoPersonally i use AdNauseam but if i click on uBlock button and then select "more" twice i get similar interface to uMatrix. Are there any features lacking in there compared to uMatrix?
- squarefoot 3y ago> Are there any features lacking in there compared to uMatrix? uMatrix had a much better UI which allowed finer granularity and immediate feedback when blocking this or that for a given site.
- somat 3y agoCan you actually do anything with that display? As a fellow refuge from umatrix. I would love some of umatrix functionality there. So to test if I was remembering correctly I just played with the ublock expanded list a bit. You can click on some things(but not everything) and the color changes(sometimes). but I still could not figure if it is just a status display or if it can be used a a tool. As far as I can tell most of ublocks power is hidden inside scripts with no real ui.
- Yujf 3y agoWith that display you can totally block or allow (sub-)domains on the current website (or all websites) so it does have some power, but it is not as powerful as the the scripts which allow much more granularity
- freedomben 3y agoYes, but it's all "network requests" for each subdomain. You can't for example allow CSS and HTML and scripts, but disallow XHR, which is a common configuration that I use :-(
- amaranth 3y agoWasn't uMatrix dropped because at this point it's just a more powerful UI to do the same things uBlock Origin lets you do?
- contact9879 3y agoThat was my understanding.
- Zuiii 3y agoYes, and that's exactly why other people including myself still use it.
- freedomben 3y agoIt is objectively not a more powerful UI if you want to allow/disallow different categories of "network request." For example, allow CSS and HTML, but block scripts and XHR. If you want to to do that, you have to write the rules manually. Basically, there's no UI, not a more powerful one.
- contact9879 3y agoWhat does uMatrix have that uBlock Origin doesn't provide?
- wtallis 3y agoA better UI for fine-grained control over what kind of requests get blocked.
- freedomben 3y agoExactly. Say I want to block cookies, media, and XHR requests on the current site as well as on a linked 3rd party site (like cloudfront), but allow css, scripts, and frames? In uMatrix such a configuration is trivial. In uBO AFAICT you're probably gonna have to write the rules manually. The grid UI in uBO doesn't get that granular, just "network request" level.
- pmontra 3y agoThe UI is many orders of magnitude better. uMatrix vs uBlock Origin is a textbook case. UbO's matrix is the masochist's teapot in the cover page of The Design of Everyday Things https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things uMatrix is a teapot with the handle where it should be. If uMatrix will stop working I'll install NoScript. I'll keep using UbO for ads and cosmetic filtering.
- sebzim4500 3y agoHow so? I think uBO has a pretty nice UX for what I want to do. Especially like the element picker UI, where you can independantly control what element you want in the hierarchy and also how specific the selector should be.
- Zuiii 3y ago> How so? I think uBO has a pretty nice UX for what I want to do. I'm happy for you but I think uBO has a horrible UX for what I want to do.
- Dwedit 3y agoAs far as I've seen, the most recently committed fork of uMatrix is this one: https://github.com/nicolaasjan/nuTensor https://github.com/nicolaasjan/nuTensor Why not just use the final release of uMatrix? Because it has a bug where it can delete your logon cookies when you navigate to another site. It also has bugs where the wrong rule is applied for a particular request (it picks the action defined for a different site).
- 8bitsrule 3y ago>gorhill is a hero and legend to me. I wish a had an 8x10 I could gold-frame, to hang over my desk.