5 ms·
Everyone Is a Girl Online
- simmerup 3y agoThis is a hard read. It seems to require a lot of context to understand. Is it basically saying everyone online wants attention and that makes them girls?
- pierat 3y agoThis feels like a boiling down a masters thesis from a women's studies thesis-> gender studies thesis -> human intersectionality thesis. (The names of this field try to distance themselves from their roots at every step, because even women know "women" is bad. Sigh. Just dumb sexism all the way down.) The language they use has multiple overloading definitions, some of which conflict, and others are just completely opaque. And since it's about the "gender wars written from a woman", any critique will be tarred and feathered as "patriarchy". For example, this is the second-to-last paragraph and single massive run-on sentence: "It may well work in our favor to accelerate our way into Total Girl—that is, to consider the girl as a specific technology of subjectivity that maxes out on desire, attraction, replication, and cunning to achieve specific ends—and to use such technology to access something once unknowable about ourselves rather than for simple capital gains, blowing a kiss at individually-scaled pleasures while really giving voice to the egregore, the totality of not just information, but experience, affect, emotion." That's just dense-prose-diarrhea that basically means nothing. There's at least 6 different definitions of "girl", and which this sentencegraph uses different ones than above. And mixing para-psychology, science, technology, and occultism gives the "aura" (HAH!) that they have and know more than the rest. And in the end it reads like a cross between a newspaper horoscope, the "History Channel" (aliens!), and a rerun of 1990's Outer Limits.
- bowsamic 3y agoYou should see some of Hegel's run-on sentences...speaking of which, that's even immensely clear compared to Hegel
- pierat 3y agoI find the needless complexity in any realm to be distracting and usually not worth my time. The needless complexity is usually a marker that it's for others on the "in crowd" for the thing, and primarily used as a exclusion tool. I get that complexity is needed, and reducing something too much destroys the ideas behind it. But packing up to 6 different definitions in a single word is just... stupid. It's like confusion is the point, and it's being used as a weapon to berate anyone who complains.
- bowsamic 3y agoI don't think it's the authors' choice what the word means lol. The "6 definitions" are how people use it in the English language People are expecting this woman to play God, it seems
- jstarfish 3y agoIt's very dense, and I'm surprised to see this authored by a woman. > Every ordinary person has to, in some way, pay attention to their semipublic image, even if that image is one that resists appearing on a platform. The internet is a social platform upon which patriarchy has been subverted [in virtual reality] without anybody even noticing. This is the age of social engineering. We all have to live like teenaged girls engaging in cliquish behavior whether we like it or not. Everything you say that can in any way be attributable to you will be used against you out of context. If you don't think you do, then nobody has found a need to cancel you yet. Just wait until you get in another "girl's" way for a promotion or you're the target of staged histrionics so they can evade accountability for some other shit they did. Give it time and watch your back. It's a quiet war you don't even realize is being waged until your life becomes a smoldering crater. This is by design. The favored weapon of women has always been poison, and it's not always the chemical kind. I hadn't considered the sexist angle even after noticing my stepdaughter snooping on her parents' phones and cyberstalking me and was thinking just yesterday that it feels like I have to like like an aspiring presidential candidate. All skeletons must be macerated, all dirt must be swept away, all witnesses discredited or eliminated. I've seen what she does to the rest of her family with weaponized intelligence. There's no discernible endgame, just defamation and humiliation of everyone for the sake of elevating herself. I now understand how teen girls get bullied into suicide by other girls. Some shit, you can't live down.
- simmerup 3y agoThanks, that’s more understandable
- bowsamic 3y ago> It's very dense, and I'm surprised to see this authored by a woman. A lot of philosophers are women
- jstarfish 3y agoNo doubt-- my surprise was more about the subject matter. I've only ever seen scattered theories about the "girl code" put forth by MRAs.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoIt's a dense read to be sure, but no more dense than any of the hard-to-read continental philosophers such as Hegel[1] or Ricœur[2]. My gist is that the author is basically saying that the category of girl is experiencing a cataphatic expansion - that is to say it's expanding in positive definite terms. It's also saying that this is a good thing and that it should be accelerated[3][4]. It's clear the author is well read enough to hint at ideas which such velocity that it overwhelms the reader. For example, I'm quite certain that the author would feel right at home talking about the category of girl in terms of reterritorialization a la Deleuze and Guattari[5]. But, the author never explicitly makes this connection. Like nearly all philosophical works, it draws from, reapplies, or is a response to existing works. It doesn't go out of its way to tell you what they are - it expects you to be familiar enough with the topic that you can discern that from content and context. I think it's easy to criticize the piece as being not accessible, but also, maybe the target audience (which the author assumes familiarity with) doesn't overlap with the population of HN readers. I don't think it's a stretch to say that author would see programming concepts as equally incomprehensible and requiring a foundation found elsewhere. Back to summarizing the piece, the author write after a series of specific points "Living as “male” is to live in horror of ever being a girl." Going back to the point of the "category of girl is experiencing a cataphatic expansion," you can see how "male" is being defined apophatically[6] - that is to say, by negation. The author combines this positive definition of girlness with the question "What is being rewarded by online platforms?" and arrives at the intermediate conclusion that the manipulation of desire(my words) is rewarded. The piece then goes on to question, are the girls subject to the influence of platforms or can they wield this power to achieve goals? Finally, I'm reserving the right to be completely wrong about my interpretation of this. I'm not exactly holding this interpretative view very strongly. 1. See The Phenomenology of Spirit (1807) https://archive.org/details/phenomenologyofs0000hege_n6q1/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/phenomenologyofs0000hege_n6q1/mo... (translation) 2. Or see Time and Narrative (1984) https://archive.org/details/timenarrative0001ricu/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/timenarrative0001ricu/mode/2up 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism 4. Some form of Girl/Acc? (50% /gen, 50% tongue in cheek) 5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reterritorialization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reterritorialization 6. https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=Apophatic https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=Apophatic
- GauntletWizard 3y agohttps://archive.ph/OaAFG https://archive.ph/OaAFG
- resharpe105 3y agoThis is nonsense.
- omscs99 3y agoWhat the hell is this thing even saying Does the author think that redefining a bunch of words makes them “deep” or something? Either make an attempt to be understandable or don’t publish. And shame on wired for dropping the bar so low, you wouldn’t see this type of laughable shit out of a more respectable outlet like new yorker
- bowsamic 3y agoWhat do you mean? This reads like any other contemporary philosophy I've read
- cherrycherry98 3y agoAfter their Hogwarts Legacy review where they gave the game 1/10 and talked more about the controversy around Rowling than the game they have no credibility to me.
- hollerith 3y agoSubmissions like this make me wish I could downvote submissions.
- mock-possum 3y agoI mean sure, if you look at every definition of the word ‘girl’ through every lense, you can find a way to frame the world in such a way as to produce… whataver this article is I just don’t get this piece.
- confd 3y agoIs Wired in general taken seriously by this community still?
- gnicholas 3y agoI still take Wired seriously, though somewhat less so after seeing this article.
- lordfrito 3y agoWoof. Talk about hyperreality. As if this stream of nonsense matters to anyone or anything in the real world. Chasing status seeking false realities that are meant to be consumed as the real. A sign of the times. Glad I grew up pre-internet.
- bowsamic 3y ago> As if this stream of nonsense matters to anyone or anything in the real world. I'm a little confused at what makes you think that the internet is not included in the set of things considered to be real
- johnea 3y agoIt's not the internet that's not real, it's the dream space that it induces in it's victims. This is the same as the dream state involked by, say, reading a novel, or watching a movie, or even going into that out-of-body experience that occurrs when someone is immersed in code development, or painting. But the dream state invoked by the internet is interactive, personallized, and orders of magnitude more potent than any of those traditional media pathways. What's not real is what the human is imagining while they use the internet. It's a fantasy world. And while transcending to a fantasy state is essential for imaginative innovation, like solving a hard programming problem, it's equally essential that those benefits be brought back to the real world, physical 3D reality. This is the part that doesn't happen with the fantasy escape of trending "nonsense". The meme-speak is just a medium of expression for the illiterate. Really sad that once again "girls" are just a means of enforcing mindless consumption for the benefit of ownership. This break from physiccal reality has been abrupt, and near ubiquitous, and quite likely the end of the modern world order...
- bowsamic 3y ago> This is the same as the dream state involked by, say, reading a novel, or watching a movie, or even going into that out-of-body experience that occurrs when someone is immersed in code development, or painting. I don't understand. All those things are real to me. What definition of real are you using?
- acadapter 3y agoReading that article, I think "someone apparently ingested something inappropriate at Burning Man". What a chaotic mess.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThat read like satire. I'm actually glad this showed up in my feed because of how fascinated I am with the content of this article.
- josteink 3y agoSelf-centered, self-inflating and generally impossible to read. If this is what a girls internet produces, they can keep it for themselves.
- stuckinhell 3y agoNot what I expected at all, and a bit nonsensical. I expected more along the lines of Face editing: Japanese biker tricks internet into thinking he is a young woman https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-56447357 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-56447357
- bowsamic 3y agoGreat philosophical treatise and analysis. I have observed this phenomenon quite widely since COVID. It's partly what led me to delete my twitter account
- powerslacker 3y ago[flagged]
- bowsamic 3y agoDo you think only big name celebrities should be published or something? She is an academic at a London arts school and has relevant academic training. She's not just some random lay person
- powerslacker 3y ago[flagged]
- bowsamic 3y agoI don’t see how posting articles about social analysis and philosophy is pretty risky, and I don’t see how it shows she can’t form coherent opinions. Did she contradict herself in this article? If so I missed it
- powerslacker 3y ago[flagged]
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoDunno bout that. There's pretty hardcore pushback on these topics. For example, "girl dinner" is just "eating whatever is at home that you don't need to cook." Which means that most of Gen X was eating "girl dinner" decades before anyone coined the term, and bachelors have been eating "girl dinner" for centuries.
- kbelder 3y ago"girl dinner", I.E., "guy dinner", I.E., meaningless.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoThe article keeps mentioning "post-platform" and then seems to speak about how women can hide behind "girlness" to get away with manipulative nonsense. How an Instagram Influencer continues doing whatever it is they do if they are not on a platform is beyond me.