>> If you’re not paying towards that, then it’s likely you – or your data – are the product > Ignoring the fact that this is not how it works - there are plent

>> If you’re not paying towards that, then it’s likely you – or your data – are the product > Ignoring the fact that this is not how it works - there are plenty of services where you pay and still are the product That refutation of their statement is not how logic works. They made a !A -> B statement ("not pay" -> "you are product"). Your statement, ! (A -> !B), which is equivalent to B -> !A is orthogonal to their statement.