3 ms·
"It's silly to think that these people are going to work until they are 75." That's how it worked for my grandparent's generation, and likely most others befor
by giantg2 3y ago
"It's silly to think that these people are going to work until they are 75."
That's how it worked for my grandparent's generation, and likely most others before that. So not really that silly (but still sad). It'd be great to adjust the work so it's not as destructive. I don't think adjusting to earlier retirement isn't really an option based on history (retirement is a recent thing).
Yeah, modern capatism may not be great for society in general. But how does it compare with the prior models, like monarchy? Or even things like socialism? Seems like corruption and human nature ruins even the best theoretical systems.
- jewayne 3y agoIf you actually look at it, the number of people who were actually able to carry on at a physical job until 75 was always small. That's why people had large families, after all -- they were your retirement plan.
- giantg2 3y agoDo you have a source for a number on that? It seems like most of the people in my grandparent's generation worked physical jobs and continued into their 70s. I can see that prior generations maybe took on less physical roles as the next generation took on the more physical farm roles. Still today, we see that Amish tend to have a large number of men working in physical roles at least into their 60s and often times longer.
- jewayne 3y ago> my grandparent's generation But what about the other 3 grandparents? Sorry, after you did it twice I couldn't help myself.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI would bet people had large families due to lack of available birth control lack of women’s economic independence. At least my grandmothers and great grandmother I asked did not mention retirement when I asked them why they had the number of kids they did.
- jplusequalt 3y agoThe quality that disgusts me the most about society is mass apathy. It's so incredibly upsetting that the majority agree that our current systems aren't working and will only get worse with time, but most people just ... accept this? Now, I'm no different than most people. I am extremely apathetic about our situation as well. However, it's still soul sucking to realize I'm contributing to the path we're on while feeling like there is nothing I can do. Feels bad :/
- giantg2 3y agoSome of it might be apathy. I think a lot is also ignorance. On top of that, there aren't any great solutions being proposed. There are some that might be feasible, but they also seem to be limited in scope. Overall, we have made great strides over the past few generations. With human imperfections, where should the bar to acceptable be set?
- acuozzo 3y agoIt seems like apathy and, for some, I'm sure it is, but I'd wager that for most it's just a matter of making lemonade. Many Baby Boomers went through something similar in the 1970s when the last of the radical political movements with teeth died down. They retreated into themselves and started viewing the crumbling world around them (e.g., late 1970s NYC) as "beautiful".
- jplusequalt 3y agoIt seems human adaptation is just an uncanny ability to roll over.
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoModern technology has allowed us to reduce the scarcity of a lot of our daily needs to the point where they're dumped in landfills in order to manufacture scarcity. Much of the requirement for individual people to remain productive is largely unnecessary. Clothes, fruit, vegetables, medicine, etc. Its not even theoretical. We just put the value of one's private property(not personal) and Capital over the value of general well being.