4 ms·
If you rent you need to spend less on housing in the early days, and invest the difference. If you do this all along you should be fine. However if like many
by bluGill 3y ago
If you rent you need to spend less on housing in the early days, and invest the difference. If you do this all along you should be fine. However if like many who rent you just taking your savings from rent (vs a house - including not just the payment but also property taxes, insurance and maintenance) and party you are in trouble. Houses can be a great forced savings plan. (so long as you don't cash our refinance like many do, you don't move too often, and a bunch of other fine print things)
- ghaff 3y agoA lot of people probably underestimate how much a house costs even if you ignore mortgage (or have paid it off). It varies of course but I figure it's a good $1,000/month and that probably understates various infrequent but expensive maintenance items.
- BizarreByte 3y agoMy house has cost significantly less than that over the time I've owned it. Last year I spent 4000$(CAD) on maintenance, this year I'm at just under 1000$. It's about 60 years old and it really doesn't take much to keep it in decent condition, but I'm also happy to and skilled enough to do a lot of work myself. If I owned a giant American style McMansion I could see it costing that much, but it's a very modest house. When it comes to maintenance costs it's hard to estimate when talking online because every location, house, and person is very different.
- ghaff 3y agoIt is an old house but it's less than 2,000 sq. ft. which is not small but certainly not McMansion size. $4K/year property taxes, >$1K/year insurance. Plowing (though that's fairly cheap because my neighbor who shares use of my long driveway does it). I do a lot of little routine stuff but did have a bunch of new windows about 5 years back and a bathroom needed to be redone at about the same time. Have to pay for trash collection. Have had some major projects over the years that were necessary like a new roof. Need a couple new appliances and associated work at the moment. So, yeah, even owning my house outright, it probably costs a good $1,000/month to pay regular bills and keep it in a reasonably stable state.
- BizarreByte 3y agoYah, I think this just comes down to location more than anything. I don't directly pay for garbage, plowing, or anything like that. When I replaced the exterior doors and half of the windows that was about an 8000$ year and that is the worst it's ever been. The guy who installed those was a family friend though, so it was a bit cheaper and I helped. This year I had to replace the water pump, but I did that on my own and it was about a 400$ job. I had to fix one of the soffits, but that was a pretty simple job too. The only thing I dread is the roof, but that's still years and years off since it was new when I bought the place. Generally if I put away 4000-5000$ a year for future maintenance I'm happy, that'll leave me with a giant fund if needed.
- svachalek 3y agoWhen doing a cost comparison of rent vs buy, don't count the principal payments. The interest payments, maintenance costs, and property tax are just as much money down the drain as rent is. What has made owning a house vastly worth it over the past couple of decades is severe under-construction of new housing which has led to prices spiraling upward and creating a gold mine for homeowners. Will that continue? Probably yes. But consider the risk that it doesn't.
- ghaff 3y agoThe properties can also be different. In general, you often can't rent a house long-term and set it up the way you like it. (It's simultaneously true that buying that house represents a much bigger commitment than renting an apartment is.)
- bluGill 3y ago> don't count the principal payments. I strongly disagree. You compare all costs. Interest, principal, maintenance, insurance, taxes... If I knew how to calculate them I'd add things like risk that you need to move (realtor fees, potentially making payments on a house you are not living in...) If you sell the house before you die, then you can pull out the difference, which can be applied to nursing home costs. Otherwise the gain of a house is in the lower rent you pay after you pay it off.
- svachalek 3y agoHouses have some big ticket maintenance items that come up rarely though. New roof, any kind of foundation work, etc. You've got to keep savings for these things. That said, a modest size and self maintenance go a long way.
- tristor 3y agoRenting isn’t cheaper than buying at nearly any point from 2008 to 2020 in any US city. Renting being cheaper than buying is a “new” phenomenon and still debatable since renting doesn’t result in equity and can never result in ownership. A house isn’t just an asset, it’s a place to live.
- falcolas 3y agoBut as long as you need a place to live, you can't use it as an asset. You might be able to get a few loans on it, but that just means you keep paying monthly, like you're renting. It's not an investment asset if you require it to live. That said, renting is just as expensive as owning right now too. You're paying a mortgage and taxes and repairs and insurance either way, and with renting, you're also paying for a bit of landlord profit.
- bluGill 3y agoA you own house is both an asset and a place to live. If your accounting models cannot handle that concept then you need to update them. Accounting 101 probably can't as it is complex and tricky, but more advanced models can. Now because you have to live someplace a house is not an asset you can just go and trade for whatever, but it is still an asset.
- wing-_-nuts 3y ago> Renting isn’t cheaper than buying at nearly any point from 2008 to 2020 in any US city There's a lot of nuance in disagreement with this. Renting often makes sense for young workers who have not yet settled down. Also in many parts of the US one can rent a simple 1bd apartment where one could not buy such a house. I rented and invested in stocks up to about 5y ago and I've come out much further ahead than if I purchased a house.
- tristor 3y agoSure, there's a lot of nuance in any sort of multi-variable economic question. That's not the point, the person I was replying to said renting is cheaper than buying, that hasn't been true for over a decade pre-pandemic. The primary reasons why this weren't true were low interest rates and a gradual recovery in housing prices after the correction 2008. 2020 changed both of these things, and so they are correct /now/, but /most/ people who own a home didn't buy in it the last 2 years, so their advice against buying a house on the basis of it being more expensive than rent is mute. As a simple example, my fully-laden (mortgage + insurance + tax) cost on a 2600 sqft 4br/3.5ba house on a 1/2 acre lot in a nice suburb in San Antonio purchased in 2012 was around $1400/mo compared to this being the typical rent for a 1br apartment pre-2020 in San Antonio anywhere that wasn't in the ghetto. That was largely thanks to having a 2.4% interest mortgage and being able to buy in 2012 in the dip for property values. The same property that was purchased for $162k in 2012 sold for $340k in 2022, and the mortgage rate for the new buyer was around 6.5%, doubling both price and interest rate greatly changes the equation, but let's not act as if that hasn't been a relatively recent (pandemic-tied) shift.