3 ms·
> The short story as I understand it is that HMOs actually worked early on, but realized people got really really upset when told that their personal doctor suc
by Aurornis 3y ago
> The short story as I understand it is that HMOs actually worked early on, but realized people got really really upset when told that their personal doctor sucked and the treatment recommended sucked. They’d bail for whatever insurer covered every damn thing. So insurers realized better to just jack prices rather than control costs.
I don't know how true this is for the HMO story, but I do know that many patients absolutely hate being told "no" after they've convinced themselves that they need a certain treatment.
We've all heard the stories about the patient who was right about their own diagnosis but was denied care by their doctor, but these are the rare stories. Providers get bombarded daily by demands for antibiotics for colds, for example. If you're well educated about antibiotics you probably wouldn't believe the number of people who think antibiotics treat every infection and doctors are just meanies for refusing to hand them out. Many doctors get tired of fighting these battles and just write prescription after prescription for antibiotics on demand, which creates a loyal customer base of patients who are happy because they get whatever they ask for.
The situation is even scarier for controlled substances. The internet and sites like Reddit have a weird way of convincing people that they need Adderall and/or Xanax, and that doctors are evil if they won't prescribe them no questions asked. I've heard too many horror stories from my psychiatrist friends who get patients showing up demanding Adderall, but on closer examination will describe classic depression symptoms (e.g. having trouble focusing after a recent breakup, but no problems for the first 2-3 decades of life). Some of them have been convinced by Reddit (it's always Reddit) that ADHD is the explanation to their mental health problems and a high dose of Adderall will solve all of their problems.
Then when they say "no", they get pinged a few weeks later by the psychiatrist down the hall because the patient is back with a different doctor trying the same story. The sad part is that they often continue this rotation until someone shrugs and writes the prescription. A disappointing number of providers don't mind having a lot of controlled substance patients because it's a steady stream of easy appointments to write new prescriptions every few months.