3 ms·
Any site design will look stale after five years, no matter what standards you follow. It's just an unfortunate reality, there is no way off of the wheel unless
by SoftTalker 3y ago
Any site design will look stale after five years, no matter what standards you follow. It's just an unfortunate reality, there is no way off of the wheel unless you are like Craigslist and deliberately reject all convention.
- ics 3y agoI wish this wasn't such a commonly shared opinion. Too defeatist, in my view. Craigslist is spartan, sure, but there are less extreme examples such as McMaster-Carr. They've had the same design more or less since 2010 at least and it is usually considered both functional and tastefully current. I think in the early 2000s they had a different design which was fine, and they obviously skipped the whole "web 2.0" era of design.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYou're right, there are a few exceptional sites that manage to have a "timeless" look and I'd probably put McMaster in that category.
- nextaccountic 3y ago> there are less extreme examples such as McMaster-Carr. They've had the same design more or less since 2010 at least and it is usually considered both functional and tastefully current. This? https://www.mcmaster.com/ https://www.mcmaster.com/ On desktop, sure. But they don't work in mobile. And that's easily 80% of the troubles of modern design: to avoid building everything twice, today people write "responsive", "mobile first" websites that, on desktop, tend to have an excessive amount of whitespace and other issues (see for example the old vs new reddit layout) What's being demanded of websites in 2023 is just much more difficult to do well than what people wanted in 2010.
- domh 3y agoIt is my first time going on mcmaster.com and it's working great on mobile for me (Android, Firefox). It feels snappy, good button sizes, great filtering options, no dead ends in flow until login to purchase. Top marks from me!
- sverhagen 3y agoIt isn't immediately clear to me what about that website isn't working on Mobile, as it seems to look pretty decent for me? (Firefox on a Galaxy phone.)
- bryanrasmussen 3y agothirding the mobile experience for me looks great on first try. I mean really really good.
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoWhat are you talking about? That site looks great on an iPhone SE. Are there some issues? Sure. That doesn’t mean throw the baby out with the bath water, redesign to whatever’s trendy today, and kick the can down the road.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoSpeed never falls out of fashion. They're not the prettiest to look at but pleasant to use.
- asoneth 3y agoI am disappointed any time "modernize" comes up as one of the priorities on a redesign, especially for enterprise products. Most enterprise software does not gain much from looking "modern" and like all fashions the more modern the UI the more quickly it becomes dated. In extreme cases of very large products whose owners want them to look exceedingly modern it can be like painting the Golden Gate Bridge: by the time they finish implementing the last components and icons, the ones that were implemented at the beginning of the project are already due for an update. The job security simply isn't worth the maddening repetition.
- amatecha 3y agoYeah, you should see the Canada.ca design system[0]. It's ultra-boring, but it works, and has been the same for a very long time (and I'd be happy if it doesn't change much at all). Having such a simple design standard makes it so I can hit the website of any government service and understand how to "parse" the site and find my way around. I never have to relearn a totally new design language and information architecture, which is huge for me, as I cannot stand having to "re-learn" sites every couple years! [0] https://design.canada.ca/ https://design.canada.ca/
- blitzar 3y agoIf you write html properly - in 5 years do a minor tweak to the css and you have a new fresh look.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agohow will that help you keep employed though, better to have the css as part of your JS so any redesign is months of tiring work to earn those big consulting bucks! /you may get the impression I'm bitter.
- blitzar 3y agoMe too my friend, me too. (btw your solution is needlessly complicated and way too much hard work - easier to sit with the client, exhale deeply then say "A full redesign? Thats quite a big project and its a lot of work, are you sure?" offer a fixed rate contract assuming 100's or even 1000's of person-hours and deliver (after a polite overrun of a few weeks) the updated css.) /you may get the impression I'm bitter and cynical.
- bryanrasmussen 3y ago>btw your solution is needlessly complicated and way too much hard work it's not my solution, it's the solution I'm suffering through because our styling, as determined by external company, is handled via Chakra UI meaning that redesign requires JS work.
- high_5 3y agoThis is a discussion about governmental sites. I don't use them because I want to but because I have to. So, current fashion and appeal are second to usability. There are some fundamental laws and limitations on how people process the presented information and that SHOULD be taken into account in designing a public service. Ideally, there is an interest in both parties (state and citizen) that their interaction is correct in order to fulfill their obligations and ensure their rights. Also many of the interactions with governmental digital services happen only once a year. I've been in helpdesk supporting people on a webapp with an obnoxious interface that they had to use 3 to 4 times a year to fulfill their project report in order to get paid for their project work. The UX was so out of the conventions that people hated it with passion and I had to help the laggards to use the application.
- pjc50 3y ago"Stale" is good for government websites. If you've got to interact with a form regularly as part of a legal requirement it is good that it never changes and looks exactly the same time every time you load it across a decade.