3 ms·
> Economies of scale aren't a goal on their own. Scaling something up will always have side effects... in the case of too dense urban areas, it's for example th
by lmm 3y ago
> Economies of scale aren't a goal on their own. Scaling something up will always have side effects... in the case of too dense urban areas, it's for example the sheer amount of traffic. For example, a quarter full of high-rises, no way you can get away without expensive high-capacity subterranian trains to handle commuters, and surface traffic is going to be a hot mess even with just shuttling the basic supplies for supermarkets, restaurants and the likes in one direction and waste on the other direction. In contrast, even a standard European mid-sized city can get away with cheap bus and tram lines.
But that high-capacity transit more than pays for itself (just the land value increase alone is more than the cost of building it). Yes there are costs to building densely (obviously to build a skyscraper at all costs more per square metre of floor space than building on the flat), but the end result is that more people can live (and more productively) for less total cost.
> Another effect of urban over-density that's often neglected is human health, both physical (we've seen that with COVID, just how fast pathogens can spread in urban areas) and mental. I mean, even here in Munich or Berlin we're not at the US levels of mental health and housing issues with people defecating on the sidewalk, but still it's noticeable how cities tend to have more anti-social behavior, as poverty and boredom are definitely contagious especially when not backed by the implicit social control that life even in smaller cities brings.
Do you have any evidence for that? The last results I've seen are that suburban living is significantly worse for mental health than dense urban cores (and I wouldn't be surprised if that was true for physical health as well), and frankly that fits with my experiences.
- kkfx 3y ago> but the end result is that more people can live (and more productively) for less total cost. Another classic scam: metros are very energy efficient in travel time, when loaded enough. But you need to move at any time of the day, differently by many others needs and desire, as a result OR you make the service run 24/7 nearly empty most of the time or you can't satisfy personal traveling needs most of the time. Beside that the mere cost of a metro respect of "glorified electric golf cart" for a less dense are is ENORMOUS and no, it does not pay up. Not only why keep moving in a city? Most activities there are doable from remote, just cutting such commuting to move only for pleasure and the reaming needs is FAR cheaper. > Do you have any evidence for that? In most of the world life expectancy in cities is LESS than outside by few years, gut microbes are far less in people living in dense area not to count pollution effects.
- lmm 3y ago> Beside that the mere cost of a metro respect of "glorified electric golf cart" for a less dense are is ENORMOUS and no, it does not pay up. I think you missed or added some words there, so it's not very clear what you were trying to say. The cost/benefit of metros stacks up, that's why cities build them - not necessarily in terms of value that can be captured by charging fares, but certainly in terms of overall benefit. > Not only why keep moving in a city? Because the agglomeration effect still works; the more people within a 30 minute commute range, the more useful stuff they can do in less time. Again people wouldn't pay what it costs to live in a megacity if it wasn't worth it. > Most activities there are doable from remote, just cutting such commuting to move only for pleasure and the reaming needs is FAR cheaper. If there's less need for commuting then surely by your own argument that makes the case for living in a big city stronger, since there'll be less need for underground metros. > In most of the world life expectancy in cities is LESS than outside by few years Is that after controlling for wealth? > gut microbes are far less in people living in dense area Is that good or bad? > not to count pollution effects. Pollution is important though. The more you can walk or cycle, and more generally the lower the per capita energy use, the less pollution and the better for human health.
- kkfx 3y agoSorry for my English, I try to clarify like this: - cities material costs (meaning raw materials, energy etc) is enormous compared to the same people of any city living a far less dense area with single families homes AND commerce around intermixed. In such scenario moving with light electrical vehicles, mostly recharged from local p.v. since it's effective in most of the inhabited word is FAR cheaper (again in resources) than collective transports in a dense city; - WFH in a dense city is a nightmare, because you miss nature and social contacts together. I came from a large EU city, now living in the Alps, WFH. In the city I have had a FAR LESS social life, simply because it's limited to a small number of selected friends doing service-based activities, like eating together in a restaurant, going to some events etc. Here being less dense anyone (almost) interact with almost any other, normally, and that's completely change the social paradigm compensating the "alienation" of working at home, distant from your peers. As a result I can WFH and remain a social animal in a not so dense area, where I can goes around, find people etc WITHOUT services, and the anonymity of the crowd. I probably can't in cities. Doing so means also I travel LESS (no commute) and longer trips are almost meaningless since I mostly recharge from my p.v. I keep more stuff at home, so I have less "impromptu trip" to buy something and so on. I'm more in nature, more social, more resilient (for instance no long series of stairs if there is a blackout and still have my home powered). About health: > Is that after controlling for wealth? I do not know if most studies have taken family economy into account BUT so far people in cities are normally a bit more wealthy than outside, and still, they tend to live less. > [gut microbe] Is that good or bad? Perhaps not definitively clear, but typically healthy people have a significant set of gut microbes... > Pollution is important though. The more you can walk or cycle, and more generally the lower the per capita energy use, the less pollution and the better for human health. In toxicology pollution is measured in density, too little oxygen and we die, too much and we die as well. Similarly a poison below a certain threshold it's harmless. Try looking at ANY city, there are some more polluted than some others, but all are more polluted than far enough surroundings. People activities do pollute. You can walk, but the truck bringing you food does not.