8 ms·
Nvidia deeply unhappy with TSMC, claims 22nm essentially worthless
- katane 15y agoI feel like this is a tech-problem that will have a tech-solution. No idea how that fits into an "International Trade Partner Conference". That said, you can't outsource your complete manufacturing process only to come back later and wish for "virtual IDM" partnerships. Thats all of the benefits and none of the risk.
- ak217 15y agoRhetoric aside, Nvidia is the designer who keeps breaking transistor count records and is a dominant OEM supplier. That makes them both a technology and business leader among TSMC's customers, so it makes sense for TSMC to devote resources to them, since the experience they get in working with them can't be gained elsewhere and is applicable to their other customers down the road.
- ajross 15y agoPretty sure most of the (logic) transistor count records are held by FPGAs, no?
- pmjordan 15y agoNot at the clock speeds that nvidia chips run at.
- ak217 15y agoI guess you're right: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_count http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_count But they are very different beasts with different technology and a different (much smaller) market, right?
- vtail 15y agoYou are right: 2.6B for CPU, 4.3B for GPU and 6.8B for FPGA. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_count http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_count
- ak217 15y agoVery interesting. Those really are pretty stunning words for a business relationship as big as this. If I understand correctly, Nvidia has nowhere else to go since TSMC is so far ahead of other independent foundries (I'm not sure how independent GF really is - is it conceivable for Nvidia to work with GF?) and it can't very well go to Intel given the amount of competition they are engaged in. Maybe Samsung? Also, I'm not clear on the arguments presented in the slides. The transistor normalized price curves for 20nm and 14nm do eventually cross over the preceding curves, unlike the 40nm curve. And even putting the same transistor count on a smaller process node can result in lower power consumption once the leakage problems are mitigated, so the value is increased. Edit: For historical background, here's a fascinating conversation from 5 years ago between Morris Chang (founder and chairman, TSMC) and Jen-Hsun Huang (CEO, Nvidia): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-x7PdnvCyI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-x7PdnvCyI
- ajross 15y agoit can't very well go to Intel given the amount of competition they are engaged in That's not the reason. Intel's fabs are at capacity producing chips with much higher margins than GPUs. Check the price per die area on Geforce card vs. the CPU that goes on the same motherboard, and then remember that the video card is assembled and stuffed (with a ton of DRAM) and board tested where the CPU just has to be packaged and shipped. The economics simply wouldn't allow it even if Intel wanted to play.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Symmetry 15y agoErm, you're off by a process node. Haswell is produced at 22nm, not 28nm, and its due for public release in 2013. However, Ivy Bridge is also produced on 22nm and that's the one that will be coming out in a few months. That's still a half node[1] ahead, but this is mostly a matter of Intel in specific rather than CPU manufacturers in general being fast to adopt more advanced process nodes. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-node#Half-shrink http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-node#Half-shrink
- ajross 15y agoI'm sure there's a lot of interesting dirt here. But some of the analysis is a little weird. The cost-per-transistor metric isn't the right one, for a start. Imagine a world where you could get all the 1975-era 5v 74HCxx chips you wanted for free, with zero manufacturing cost. Would you choose to build a smartphone out of them? Of course not. The newer transistors are better (faster, lower power) and the products built out of them are more valuable. So yes, production costs have increased. And that may have (is having, I guess) effects on the speed at which new technologies are adopted (i.e. the crossover into "worth it" is delayed). But isn't that just a way of saying that semiconductors are finally becoming a mature technology? That's not really such a shock, nor does it justify the poo-flinging at TSMC. So the real question in my mind is whether TSMC is having problems that the other foundries (Samsung or Global Foundries, say) are not. Given that Intel has been sampling 22nm parts already, it seems like the real news hers is that TSMC sucks and the bit about production costs are just ammunition.
- wmf 15y agoThanks to the end of Dennard scaling, newer transistors are only marginally better. If NVidia doesn't care about those marginal improvements in performance and power, it seems legitimate for them to complain about price. If an entire industry's financial projections are based on exponential improvement then becoming a mature technology is apocalyptic, especially if it happens earlier than predicted.
- vtail 15y agoI'm a bit surprised by a wafer pricing chart. Sure, the individual wafer cost goes up; but if you have a design with the same transistor count, the size of your chip is going _down_, which means that you'll have _more_ chips per wafer (assuming comparable yields), which means that individual chip cost will go down. (40/28)^2 ~ 2, so if 28nm is not that bad comparing to 40nm, assuming, again, comparable yields.
- jrk 15y agoThis is precisely the analysis given in the per-transistor pricing crossover chart. That shows that the old rate of wafer price increase still allowed for significant per-transistor cost advantage fairly quickly. The whole point is that the rate of wafer price increase has itself increased to the point where these crossovers are barely happening anymore.
- nicholas_tuzzio 15y agoProblem is, they aren't going to have comparable yields at the same time. The newer tech will have a lower yield.
- AceJohnny2 15y agoThis presentation is more evidence that Moore's Law is dead. Nvidia and AMD can blame their partners, but the reality is that they're hitting increasingly costly technological hurdles. Of course Nvidia can't just throw it's hands up and say "welp, we've hit the wall" when it has someone to blame. It's fascinating to watch those predictions about the end of Moore's Law come true.
- gamble 15y agoThe last time I did some reading into the limits of Moore's Law, about four years ago, the industry consensus was that ~12nm would be the practical limit for traditional CMOS scaling. It's interesting to see evidence that prediction does appear to be holding out.
- excuse-me 15y ago12nm might be a technical limit - but if those 12nm transistors cost more than a 28nm transistor then nobody wants them. The main reason for going small is cost - Silicon costs you per sq in - smaller transistors are supposed to buy you more hardware for the same money. If that stops there is less reason to go small.
- ebiester 15y agoTo clarify, there are still advantages to 12nm, in that the speed of light allows the 12nm transistor chip to be faster (all other things being equal) than the 28nm chip. However, there are limited uses for that speed at this point, which bring into focus cost/performance. Further, part of bringing costs down involves efficiencies of scale. If you don't have the scale, the price will limit the output. It might be back to the supercomputer world for those who need that particular extra bit of speed.
- Symmetry 15y agoWell, we're staring at the end of shrinking silicon feature sizes all right. There might be more order of magnitude improvements in store with the use of new technologies, but we should certainly be prepared for a lengthy interregnum.
- stewie2 15y agowhy do companies want to be design only?
- sparky 15y agoThese days, it's not really up to a company whether it wants to be fabless or an IDM. Apart from the several billion dollars needed to build a competitive fab, you'll also need to contend with the 20+-year head start existing IDMs and foundries have on you in terms of experience and expertise. As far as I can tell, there are too many moving parts in a fab for a new company to simply poach a few key people and be competitive quickly. I can't think of anyone apart from Apple or a nation-state that has enough money to wait around while their new division learns how to build chips. That aside, assuming a fab better than TSMC's showed up on your doorstep today, you're not out of the woods in terms of being dependent on suppliers. On the contrary, designing fab tools is also a very capital-intensive business and tends towards an oligopoly, so the TSMCs and Intels of the world are just as dependent on tool vendors as NVIDIA is on TSMC. The same holds for the very specialized materials and consumables fabs use, like the glass to make mask sets.
- wmf 15y agoYou could probably buy your way into the Common Platform, but it would still cost billions. I agree that it's not realistic for NVidia to try that.
- stewie2 15y agowho is the best company that makes fab tools?
- sparky 15y agoMost companies only make a small fraction of the tools you need for a full fab; for examples of heavy hitters in key areas like lithography, chemical mechanical polishing, and ion implant, see ASML, Nikon, Canon, Applied Materials. For any given tool, there are usually 1 to 3 major vendors.
- 15y ago
- Maro 15y agoWhat do they mean by "rough justice" in this context?
- wmf 15y agoReading between the lines, it sounds like NVidia thinks that TSMC is taking all their profit and they'd like to get a fair share.
- ghshephard 15y agoSomewhat off topic, but does anybody know how to disable extremetechs craptastic mobile interface? I've got twice the resolution of my laptop on my iPad, and the mobile site looks like it's been optimized for my circa 2002 palm treo 650.
- mrschwabe 15y ago+1 can't stand how Extremetech's mobile site hijacks an otherwise fine rich web experience. On Opera for iPad (which is great for browsing HN stories btw, because of its awesome tabs) Extremetech defaults to the mobile site and its just a blank white page.
- CamperBob 15y agoSpam every contact address you can find with a (polite) message pointing out that iOS users don't need, or want, special mobile sites. It can't hurt to try.
- pvarangot 15y agoHmm, the other day I was talking about exactly this with a coworker. This being that transistor cost is not getting exactly cheaper when you factor in R&D and complicate the manufacturing process. I think Intel will be able to bundle a "good enough for playing AAA games in 1080p with maxed out graphics" video processor into the main CPU in about one/two years, maybe less. Those CPUs will be more expensive that the tinier (in transistor count) ones. This will happen around when they hit 14nm. NVIDIA will go out of bussiness or become a niche company dedicated to vector processing for scientific computation or heavy workstations, and maybe a small player in the ARM market with their Tegra architecture. Maybe AMD will go the same road, making something similar to Intel but using their ATI technology. Bonus 1: too bad, no more Singularity mumbo-jumbo in less than two years. Bonus 2: I am one of the few that believes ARM will never be relevant in the desktop/laptop/console/gaming segment, because of what I think Intel will come up with.
- excuse-me 15y agoThere is no good-enough with AAA games short of Hollywood photo-realism and that's a lot of GPU transistors away.
- wmf 15y agoThat's not true if AAA games are ported from six-year-old consoles.
- pvarangot 15y agoI meant good enough in "good enough when compared to what a dedicated card can offer for the same price", not "the absolutely unbeatable graphics". If transistor price doesn't decline for discrete graphic card manufacturers, there will be no more transistors in your GPU ever again, unless you pay a hefty premium for the transistor count difference. This is what NVIDIA is complaining about in the article. They will have to compete with Intel's bundled graphics card, and not only in the lower segments of the market but also the mid and high/mid segment.
- excuse-me 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- 6ren 15y agoIf cost/transistor continues to not improve, industry-wide, it spells the end of Moore's Law, at least for mainstream applications where cost is a primary factor. However... where size itself (and power consumption) are the primary factors, there will be demand. Which means that SoC GPUs will adopt new process nodes more vigorously than video card GPUs. http://www.embedded.com/electronics-news/4304118/Imagination-outstrips-all-other-GPU-IP-suppliers http://www.embedded.com/electronics-news/4304118/Imagination... Sounds like disruption.
- lien 15y agoNvidia Doesn't have a choice no matter how unhappy they are with tsmc. TSMC is the biggest fab that every fabless manufacturer uses. Every single fabless semi has no choice but TSMC. If tsmc can't deliver on the 22nm technology, no other fab will be able to. The 22nm is extremely difficult most skus fail. Hence intel wins.