3 ms·
> It's weird to say, but we should crash the economy if it can slow down climate change. I mean there are plenty people in other parts of the world who don't ha
by acdha 3y ago
> It's weird to say, but we should crash the economy if it can slow down climate change. I mean there are plenty people in other parts of the world who don't have such a high standard of living, and it's not that big of a problem.
The thing is, we have no reason to believe halting climate will do anything other than boost the economy. The reason for inaction despite the fact that it’ll make tons of new jobs, and remove major consumer costs and widespread reductions to health & quality of life caused by cars, is that certain specific sectors of the economy will shrink. The fossil fuel industry has spent half a century funding science deniers and consolidating their political power to prevent action on climate change or their pollution. They’re not acting on behalf of the entire economy, just their shareholders.
A simple example: beef is a solid order of magnitude worse than other common protein sources (with the possible exception of lamb in some countries). We could see huge reductions in our food-related emissions simply by eating pork or chicken instead, and almost nobody would say that’s an intolerable lifestyle hit but the beef industry isn’t going to let that happen easily because it’s bad for their revenue even if it’d mean most people save money.
- iamegypt 3y ago[flagged]
- acdha 3y ago> It's absolutely not given that removing beef from our diet would make things much better. It is - the food input & land requirements are less efficient - and it’s absurd to say that eating pork or chicken instead is so miserable that people won’t abide it.
- burnernumber9 3y ago> It is - the food input & land requirements are less efficient you are assuming that everything else will stay the same, which is a very common bias. > say that eating pork or chicken instead is so miserable that people won’t abide it. there are literally billions of people that do not eat various specific foods and beverages in conformity with various religious, cultural, legal or other societal prohibitions. Try to convince your neighbor to eat dog instead of beef.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago> We could see huge reductions in our food-related emissions simply by eating pork or chicken that would be great, if only more than 2.5 billion people did not eat pork for various religious or cultural restrictions. food restrictions are among some of the most difficult habits to overcome, proven by the fact that they resisted for thousands of years. we could also eat insects or worms, but we don't it, what makes you think that 1.8 billion Muslims would suddenly start eating pork like it's not a big deal? In my opinion Paracelsus said it right: it's the dose that makes the poisons. Americans who eat the most red meat per capita (a lot more than anyone else), could eat less meat in general. How? Simple: by making it a lot more expensive. Between 2020 to 2022, Europeans consumed 32.4 kilos of pork, while the per capita consumption of beef was significantly lower, at 10.3 kilos in total. How Much Beef Does the Average American Eat? The average U.S. consumer eats 25.9 kilograms (57.1 pounds) of beef per year. For the last 60 years, U.S. meat consumption has risen steadily. In 1961, the average was 93.7 kilograms (206.5 pounds) of meat per year. By 2020, that number had risen to 126.73 kilograms (279.4 pounds) per year. The most notable period bucking this trend of growth is from 2008 to 2013, a decrease that likely resulted from the 2008 recession. proving that the economic angle is effective in reducing the consumption of meat in the US.
- acdha 3y ago> that would be great, if only more than 2.5 billion people did not eat pork for various religious or cultural restrictions. I used “other common protein sources” to avoid having to list every single alternative from fish to nuts, and I’d note that the populations for whom that’s true traditionally ate proteins which were not beef because it’s comparatively expensive: chicken, fish, legumes, nuts, cheese (still way less CO2), etc. That’s the key thing here: we’re not asking people to eat Soylent green or extruded nutrient pellets, or to never eat beef, but simply to restore the range of foods from their own cultural tradition prior to the mid-20th century western promotion of beef as the highest status protein. My grandfather grew up eating beef twice a year (when his cousins dairy culled the herd) and it was fine - I’m sure he’s do it again if it meant his great grandchildren had a better world.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago