4 ms·
It's not the role of the police to be pinning crimes on people, that's the judicial system. The police just collect evidence, and, as I understand it, the Miran
by stavros 3y ago
It's not the role of the police to be pinning crimes on people, that's the judicial system. The police just collect evidence, and, as I understand it, the Miranda warning just means that there's no "off the record" when talking to the police.
In other words, it doesn't mean "we're going to twist what you say as much as we can", it means "we'll tell the court whatever you tell us, even if that's self-incriminating".
Pretty much what you'd expect, really.
- FFP999 3y ago> It's not the role of the police to be pinning crimes on people I don't think the cops got this memo, could you please tell them.
- simoncion 3y agoYep. AIUI, Miranda's only change to the status quo was to make it mandatory for the cops to _tell_ you what the status quo is. Prior to Miranda they didn't have to tell you shit, and were probably justifying it to themselves with some lame "Ignorance of the law is no excuse, so if you don't know that you have a right to an attorney, that there is no 'off the record' conversation with a cop, and that you don't have to tell us shit, then that's your own damn fault." justification.
- Simulacra 3y agoThe judicial system prosecutes the cases that the police bring to them, with the evidence collected by the police, with the witnesses, etc. all found, interviewed, and provided by, the police!
- vintermann 3y agoAnd if they feel like it, with testilying.
- alphabettsy 3y agoNo. That’s the police and prosecutors. The judicial system are the courts and judges who apply the law and adjudicate the cases brought before them, hence the judicial name. Prosecutors and police are two branches of the same tree.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoIt's not quite that. The police don't HAVE to write everything down, or record everything, etc. And they're anti-aligned with you. So things you say in custody can and will be used against you, but not everything you say can be used in your defense. Which is why you should never talk to cops without your attorney, especially if you're being arrested.