5 ms·
The fear of a nuclear fire that would consume Earth
- perihelions 3y ago- "The journal Science even published a piece on the question, in June 1946, on the eve of the US's post-war tests in Bikini Atoll. It stated that not only "non-scientists" are "disturbed over the prospect" of planetary ignition." Huh: that linked Science piece is actually not correct. Its safety argument is that nuclear fission of silicon and oxygen, the most common elements in the Earth's crust, are endothermic. That's true. It's also backwards: the actual problem is that nuclear fusion of light elements is exothermic, and in fact self-sustaining under certain conditions (extreme mass density). https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.103.2687.760.a https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.103.2687.760.a The piece doesn't touch nuclear fusion at all. Was the expert not aware of it? He should be: he's discussing (astrophysical) novae as an analogy – and those are precisely runaway thermonuclear fusion detonations. (Didn't they know that in 1946?) To be fair, he does clearly disclaim in that piece that he isn't a nuclear physicist. Still: it's remarkable that it's totally wrong, given the severity of the question it's attempting to answer (and the authoritative platform it's published in).
- drewchew 3y agoTitle should be "Scientists used to be afraid that a nuclear fire would consume the earth but don't panic..."
- jfoster 3y ago> Though analogies between artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons can be overstretched, the way this concern went from idle speculation to serious concern can teach us lessons regarding fears swirling around today's emerging technologies. Sounds like an overstretched analogy. There is no such principle which says that just because a theoretical concern in one area turned out to not be a problem in practice, all theoretical concerns will not be a problem in practice.
- scotty79 3y agoI think the analogy is apt. Same way the atmosphere is not a bag of nuclear gunpowder, our crappy, slow data centers (and even sand on the beaches that could be turned into silicon) are nothing even close to something being capable of powering humanity devastating AI singularity. It's not algorithms that stand in the way, it's crap computational capacity of our local physical reality.
- flangola7 3y agoWe don't know that. Humanity exterminating AI may only need a kilowatt of compute with the right algo
- random_mutex 3y agoAnd an some specimens from our species could do it with less
- scotty79 3y agoAnd people thought one nuke might start chain reaction of Earth atmosphere. It turned out it's not possible. Single human runs on 100W with algo and hardware optimized for more than million years. I think at some point we can do better with sand and electricity, but it's still far away. And AI research is terrible with algos. Modern miracle GPT is plain old multilayer neural network with some forward shortcuts and some parts hard coded according to ad-hoc "attention" idea. And learning algorithm is more than half a century old. The reason GPT performs is just the RAM and compute. We have every reason to be sceptical about AI apocalypse.
- r00fus 3y agoThey can replace their fear of nuclear Armageddon with the much more possible impending climate catastrophe.