5 ms·
Leaked Google pay data shows how much employees report making
- skilled 3y agohttps://archive.ph/h2V8X https://archive.ph/h2V8X
- sakex 3y agolevels.fyi has the same info
- spoonofyoukw 3y agois there a link to the leaked spreadsheet?
- frays 3y agohttps://www.levels.fyi/companies/google/salaries/software-engineer https://www.levels.fyi/companies/google/salaries/software-en...
- spoonofyoukw 3y agoEverybody knows about levels.fyi. I was asking about the leaked spreadsheet which has the data on Google US's 200k employees.
- saagarjha 3y agoThis is an internal spreadsheet with voluntary submissions. Not every person submits data.
- compiler-guy 3y agoIn fact, the percentage of people who supply data is fairly low.
- joshuamorton 3y agoIt's fairly high for something voluntary and that isn't announced anywhere except by word of mouth.
- theGnuMe 3y agoWell those numbers do not look good across ethnicity and gender.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoThey look great if you intend to prove inequality of opportunity using inequality of outcome.
- ironSkillet 3y agoThere may also be major selection bias in the statistics as the numbers were self-reported and voluntarily submitted as far as I can tell.
- theGnuMe 3y agoYou can run an analysis comparing these to Google's H1B offers which have to be at the prevailing wage or higher.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jncfhnb 3y agoUgh. Don’t show diversity outcomes without breaking them down by level at the same time.
- korkoros 3y agoConsidering that the company I work for tried to hide their gender pay discrimination by "releveling" all the women who were getting systematically underpaid, you should in fact report these data without disaggregation. "Those people make less because they are all lower level" is not a mitigating factor for pay discrimination.
- jncfhnb 3y agoAs someone who’s done a bunch of DEI analyses for companies, I don’t really believe you understood what you’re saying happened. That really does not make sense. It would be a massive organizational change for some niche cherry picked reporting stats that few people look at. Does not sound plausible at all. This stuff is genuinely hard to implement. You absolutely need to normalize for level when determine pay discrepancies. As well as hiring, retention, and promotion rates. It’s silly to suggest otherwise. Frankly a lot of companies fail to do this and are convinced they have huge problems when in fact things are pretty fair at the individual level and on track to gradually diversify over time. But you can’t just snap your fingers and diversify the top of an org. It takes a long time.
- korkoros 3y agoI work for a federal defense contractor that is required to prove in Department of Labor audits that pay is not discriminatory. The possibility of losing those federal contracts is an existential threat to the company. Definitely not "niche cherry picked reporting stats that few people look at." The significant restructuring (affected several hundred people) that you describe did in fact occur.
- jncfhnb 3y agoHmm, no, still don’t believe it. That’s just absurd. I just refuse to believe that they systematically demoted women / promoted men to try and obfuscate pay differences at original levels. This idea is surely much more expensive to implement than just paying the women more. It’s also fairly easily discovered by an audit of any competence or whistleblower. And the women would surely have a strong negative reaction to this which is an operational risk of them just leaving. What you are proposing happened is illegal discrimination to begin with, but it’s also really difficult to do. Seems more likely a willing company would prefer to simply lie
- renewiltord 3y agoEnterprise sales has no commission at Google? Or is the commission small?
- ghaff 3y agoIt could be rolled under bonus which is quite high for sales. I'd be very surprised if there wasn't some sort of incentive structure.
- compiler-guy 3y agoThis is correct. It is rolled into bonuses of various kinds.
- pylua 3y agoIn theory it is not possible to report 100% accuracy here, as I do not have to reveal my gender or race to the company I work for, correct ? That is unless not specified is a category. I personally feel like it is not the companies business to know this about me. Is there a legal requirement around this ?
- cmilton 3y agoI believe the data is being collected to help prevent discrimination based on any of those characteristics.
- pylua 3y agoI get that, but I am wondering if there is a legal right to privacy here. Besides , is it anyone’s business as to what I identify as ? Is it ethical to force me to reveal this ?
- cmilton 3y agoMost forms I have seen asking for this information now include the option to not disclose it. “Prefer not to answer”
- compiler-guy 3y agoThis is run entirely by employees with no company involvement.
- bonniemuffin 3y agoThe second sentence of the article says "voluntarily submitted". Nobody was forced to reveal anything.
- pylua 3y agoI am questioning how anyone can decision anything based off any data regarding this topic accurately , including governments or courts. Seems like it is all good faith but no way to validate the results.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lsy 3y agoDoes BI not have anyone on staff familiar with statistics? The map with “minimum salaries” seems to just prove that a more populated office location will contain a broader range and more extreme outliers of self-reported salaries. A previous article on this topic claimed that Software Engineer had the highest max salary but there are probably just more people with that title at the company than any other title.
- KoftaBob 3y agoThe person whose ethnicity is labeled "Indigenous software engineer" cracked me up. I pictured a race of humans born with ctrl + c + v buttons on their fingers
- blululu 3y agoLess than 10% of the company self reported salary data over an unspecified time window, and a limited set of aggregate statistics are reported from this distribution. Certainly interesting information, but unfortunately I don’t think you can make honest inferences from these figures. Any comments or interpretations are little more than speculations and are basically deceitful.
- sneak 3y ago> "We compensate Googlers based on what they do, not who they are," said Google spokesperson Tamani Jayasinghe in a statement. Isn't this famously false, given that they pay large disparities depending on someone's country in which they work? This only holds true within a specific country. Doesn't Google also try to dock your pay if you move out of a HCOL city, too?
- powerset 3y agoWho != where
- restes 3y agoFair, but also where != what
- sneak 3y agoWhat passport you are able to receive, and where you can resultantly live and work, is a function of who you are. Nationality is a protected class for purposes of discrimination, at least in US laws. (Not that US law applies, just as a reflection of the moral context.) Yet Google happily uses this opportunity to pay wildly different amounts to people doing the exact same work. In any case, this clearly invalidates the first claim, that people are paid based on what they do. They're paid actually based on their replacement cost in the place they are legally restricted to do it. To make a contrived example, this means that a woman in a LCOL country/city will earn less than a man in an HCOL country/city, for the exact same work. All of this pay equity stuff is total nonsense and posturing as long as Google is taking advantage of labor market arbitrage (which their staff cannot easily do, not being multinational themselves). If they truly believe in equal pay for equal work, it should plainly apply across national borders that staff cannot cross. Anything else is lip service.
- bathtub365 3y agoSomeone’s nationality and their location are two different things. It’s a big stretch to conflate them like this.
- saagarjha 3y agoIf I remember correctly a previous version of this article basically just copy/pasted the highest numbers they could, which meant that they focused on random typos. There was a running joke and a bunch of memes about some entry level engineer making 700k base, because I think it was very clear that they mistyped “178k” or “187k” as “718k”. For an L7 engineer bases go a bit higher but numbers that high, with that little equity, are unheard of. It’s highly likely nobody with an understanding of how compensation works looked through this table.
- kepler1 3y agoWhat strikes me about this story (and "reporting" in general) is how eager people writing stories are to stir up the worst kind of racial/gender-based implications without any further responsibility for analyzing or self-doubting the top level findings they're throwing in front of the audience. You would think that anyone presenting statistics that call into question some kind of differential treatment by race, ethnicity, or gender would take a moment to point out the cautions in the data. Or even express some doubt about writing the story to begin with. But no, for some reason, we are fascinated by the "0th order analysis" of inequities by race, almost want to see it blown up into incorrect interpretations and incentivize reporters to produce such stories. I think there should be a code of ethics where reporters should be questioned about what they seek to accomplish with half-assed analyses like this, if they fail to accompany it with huge warnings about what it hasn't taken into account that could explain differences: -- age -- experience -- selection biases in employees tenure (both hiring and departures) etc. Without this kind of info, all these stories do is shout an alarmist call that "this isn't fair" and then fail to produce any backup for the claim, but rile everyone up.
- givemeethekeys 3y agoThe only useful take away here for most people should be how little most other companies get away paying.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]