4 ms·
>I’m disappointed by the tech community’s acceptance of privacy invasions The whole point of privacy sandbox is to reduce privacy invasions. There exists a pr
by charcircuit 3y ago
>I’m disappointed by the tech community’s acceptance of privacy invasions
The whole point of privacy sandbox is to reduce privacy invasions.
There exists a problem on the web where anonymous visitors are being served unrelevant ads. That provides a bad experience to visitors and reduces the amount of money websites can make.
There should be an API that makes a compromise between privacy and utility so that users can get a better experience anonymously visitable websites.
The absense of such an API for this will strengthen walled gardens and disincentivize users from visiting them and site operators from making them.
- jemmyw 3y agoThis seems like a non problem. If people are reading a tech website then they probably have some tech related interests. If they're reading an article about bicycles then... People don't like seeing their "interests" follow them around into unrelated content. That's my anecdotal observation anyway.
- charcircuit 3y agoThis disadvantges sites which are not about a topic with a good CPM even more than they already are. People also don't spend 100% of their time on websites who topic is what they are interested in.
- dzikimarian 3y agoWell, maybe they simply shouldn't advertise bikes if they are not related to bikes? It would heavily de incentivise pages with trash content that exists only to expose you to ads. That would be really good for internet.
- malwrar 3y ago> That provides a bad experience to visitors and reduces the amount of money websites can make. That’s a nice fantasy, but the number of ad-blocking users and ratio of advertising revenue on mobile (where adblocking is harder) vs PC suggests to me that the content of ads doesn’t affect user experience nearly as much as the quantity and intrusiveness of ads. I think the second part of your sentence is the real problem being addressed, nothing about advertising is actually designed to directly benefit consumers. I think you would be hard-pressed to find people who actually factor ad relevance into their enjoyment of an ad-supported product.
- charcircuit 3y ago>nothing about advertising is actually designed to directly benefit consumers. Allowing customers to be connected with businesses that are able to offer something of value to them is a direct benefit.
- malwrar 3y agoIt’s a benefit in the same sense that someone walking up to me on the street and trying to sell me on something is benefiting me. I’m walking down the street to get to point B (or browsing a site to read an article), not be hawked goods unsolicited. Relevance of the good to my interests is at best irrelevant.
- charcircuit 3y agoIf you were hawked goods unsolicited it would be a waste of your time if you were not interested in your goods. If you were interested in those goods you would find value in this interaction.
- hakfoo 3y agoThe problem is a complete trust breakdown. If browsers had a "provide us some preferences to customize advertising" flow in their onboarding, users would feel in control, and the data might be of high quality. Ideally, you'd have some compartmentalization options (don't show community X my interest in product Y). That's completely infeasible now: there's such a hostility and adversarial relationship with customers, that any data provided through a voluntary, opt-in process would be seen as suspect from day 1. Not without reason-- users would be prone to select garbage in the attempt to reduce ad load or cause undue cost to advertisers. Even if the users played along, would also likely be hijacked by self-serving technology players-- would there be an interoperable way to probe customer preferences, or would they be aggregated by, and only available on, specific platforms? Since the industry has already destroyed any trust and quality relationship between users and advertisers, AdTech has to resort to continuing to poison the ecosystem through constant surveilance to retrieve "more reliable" data than asking customers what ads they might care about. There's a potential to claim some subtext in user activity that would reveal preferences the customers won't manually disclose, but that's also the exact that the surveilance practices cross from useful to creepy.
- sys_64738 3y agoWhere's the "No Ads" checkbox? Ad companies would never honor a "No Ads" checkbox just as they didn't honor the no tracking checkbox. Ad companies like GOOG publish sanitized propaganda to peddle their latest attempt to coerce and entice users in a new direction. The death of GOOG can't come soon enough. They are cancer to the internet.
- hakfoo 3y agoI can understand why there wouldn't be a "no ads" box from a business standpoint. Ad-supported sites could say "we currently have no better business model than advertising, but we could make the ads less terrible if you help". Nobody does this because the trust is completely gone. If you claim "we can offer you crappy ads or better ads", nobody really believes you'll do that, and there are some very dubious definitions of "better ads". So people demand the financially impossible, "no ads". There's also a lot more hostility towards internet ads than other media, in part because trust was broken very early on. Bad internet ads are a lot worse than bad traditional-media ads. Other media had effective limits on how obnoxious an ad could be: if you accidentally lingered your eye over the Kroger ad in the newspaper, it didn't expand and crowd out the latest Covid statistics. The injury-lawyer ad on TV couldn't provide a vector for a zero-day that permanently dialed your set to Telemundo. I also suspect there was a lot more "ad curation" in legacy media-- the ad choice still reflected on the publisher, and the cost of entry was high enough to filter out some of the most scammy ads. (Could you pull off the "Punch the monkey and win a PS3" scam if you had to pay for high-quality print ads?) The result: people who never hit the "30 second skip" button on their VCR remote are intimately familiar with uBlock Origin.
- sys_64738 3y ago> There exists a problem on the web where anonymous visitors are being served unrelevant ads No, the problem is that ads shouldn't exist at all. Ad companies like GOOG should just die.
- charcircuit 3y agoAds keep things on the internet free to use and access. It also allows many sites to be viable to run in the first place. Removing ads from the web would destroy a large chunk of value and disincentivize the use of the web and push these sites to just build on top of a social media app which is able to be get ad funding via native apps instead of a website. This results in more centralization.
- zekrioca 3y ago‘Compromise’. That’s the main issue with something as important and as ‘uncompromisable’ as privacy.
- charcircuit 3y agoThere is no way for someone to use the internet with total privacy. There are compromises people are willing to make.
- zekrioca 3y agoMaybe exercise your creativity a little more.
- JohnFen 3y ago> There exists a problem on the web where anonymous visitors are being served unrelevant ads. I don't think that's actually a problem for anybody but the advertisers, and screw them.