4 ms·
I much enjoyed this one: > Sally (a girl) has 3 brothers. Each brother has 2 sisters. How many sisters does Sally have? https://benchmarks.llmonitor.com/sally
by 6510 3y ago
I much enjoyed this one:
> Sally (a girl) has 3 brothers. Each brother has 2 sisters. How many sisters does Sally have? https://benchmarks.llmonitor.com/sally https://benchmarks.llmonitor.com/sally
It states that the correct answer is 1.
This is incorrect!
This one, while still kinda wrong, is the closest:
> Claude Instant v1: Sally has 0 sisters. The question provides no information about Sally having any sisters herself.
1) A sister is a female who has one or both parents in common with another individual.
2) A brother is a male who has one or both parents in common with another individual.
It takes only one shared parent to make someone Sally's brother. She will always be his sister but he can have additional sisters that share the other parent.
Sally's mum is Jane and her dad is Jim. Jane had a son with Jack. Jack had 2 daughters with Zoe. Jim had 2 sons with Mary, Mary had 2 daughters with Dan.
Zoe Jack Jane Jim Mary Dan
\ / \ / \ / \ / \ /
sis1.1&1.2 brother1 Sally brother2&3 sis2.1&2.2
Sally has at least zero sisters.
Also possible:
Sally's mum is Jane and her dad is Jim. Jane has a son and a daughter with Jack. Jim has 2 sons and a daughter with Mary.
Jack Jane Jim Mary
\ / \ / \ /
sis1&brother1 Sally brother2&3&sis2
Sally has at most 2 sisters.
We should be this dense about the question.
- pneumonic 3y agoSiblings and half-siblings are not the same.
- 6510 3y agoIt's my second language. Is it not correct to call a half-brother your brother in English? I seems very odd to say it is not a brother at all? Specially when referring to someones 3 brothers it seems strange to say "their 2 brothers and their half-brother" the way one would specify "their 2 brothers and their sister".
- 6510 3y agoThe dictionary says a brother needs one parent in common. Therefore I'm right and everyone else is wrong. (the jokes on you everyone else!) The LLM's are just more wrong which is just a different kind of wrong.