4 ms·
Consumers are ultimately the ones that account for all of the problem. Not a drop of oil gets pumped from the ground without the consumer demand. And the thing
by rayiner 3y ago
Consumers are ultimately the ones that account for all of the problem. Not a drop of oil gets pumped from the ground without the consumer demand.
And the thing about climate change is that consumption is much more equal than financial wealth. A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less.
- pharmakom 3y agoCarbon consumption is still highly skewed.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe average net worth of someone who flies private is $190M, and flying private has an outsized carbon footprint. Okay if we tax those miles and pay Climeworks (direct air carbon capture is currently the only legitimate carbon offset mechanism) to suck the CO2 back out of the air? This is not even hard, we can bill based on their ADS-B broadcast flight track. Agree that the problem with the investments of the wealthy driving climate change is consumer demand that needs to be destroyed (EVs, heat pumps, solar, factory farming protein, etc). https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-footprint-gap-between-rich-poor-expanding-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-f... https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/billionaire-emits-million-times-more-greenhouse-gases-average-person https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/billionaire-emits-mi...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DennisP 3y agoI think that's a great idea. But taxing private flights won't do that much on its own. From googling the other day, flying is 2% of total carbon emissions and private jets are about 1% of that, for 0.02% total.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe problem is there is no one single solution, but a bunch of them executed in parallel. Which makes sense when everyone globally is treating the atmosphere like an open air burn pit for combustion.
- alanfranz 3y agoThere’s no single activity that accounts for 50% of carbon emissions. And if there was, we probably all contributed to it. We need to shave co2 off everything, as if we were doing weight reduction to a bicycle.
- lukas099 3y ago> direct air carbon capture is currently the only legitimate carbon offset mechanism Source and/or explanation?
- callalex 3y ago“Carbon offsets aren’t doing their job/overstate impact” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37284764 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37284764
- godelski 3y agoIt definitely isn't the only offset mechanism. But it is the only reduction method, by definition. Reduction not in production rate obviously, but total levels. We definitely should be funding research (because systems aren't good enough yet) into these systems because we're not acting fast enough and CCS has the advantage of acting on the lag effect. But this is no excuse to not also reduce emissions. They're coupled: we need less CCS the less we produce which is nice especially considering nuclear is a cheaper option than CCS at this point.
- Spivak 3y agoYes and if you change what's on offer you'll see the demand change. Consumers are good and service takers, the only person that can stop releasing carbon is the person actually releasing the carbon. You will never move a river by asking each drop, you build a dam.
- laserdancepony 3y ago> A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Found the millionaire coping with his excessive consumption. No really, I don't own a car, don't fly, don't go on cruises, don't go on vacation three times a year any other way, live in a 50 sq m flat without anything but the most basic amenities. And you know why? Because I'm poor, that's why. Like most of Earths population. So don't try to tell me my carbon footprint is the same as Gordon Geckos, it simply can not be true.
- ericjmorey 3y agoThe US military is by far the largest consumer of oil.
- throwaway894345 3y agoConsumers don’t demand “products manufactured from fossil fuels”, they demand products (full stop). Indeed, I suspect most consumers have an environmental bias which isn’t reflected in the market for lack of transparency (how do you tell if a product is green or merely green washed?) and also because fossil fuels are and have long been heavily subsidized.
- morsch 3y ago> A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less. That is just not true. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-footprint-gap-between-rich-poor-expanding-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/feb/04/carbon-f... There are many other sources.
- godelski 3y ago> Consumers are ultimately the ones that account for all of the problem. You got this backwards. It's like trying to clean up a river by only picking up trash at its mouth. You're not going to do a great job. Consumers can only buy what's available. Most people are too poor to make choices other than that on price. Capitalism can work great for price reduction but one way to do price reduction is quality reduction. If the whole non-luxury market is focusing on price reduction and the easiest way is to achieve that is quality reduction then guess what happens. On the other hand, if quality has to hold constant -- which happens when consumers are less price sensitive and won't go for a slightly cheaper option when competitor tries quality drop -- you have to research and build better and/or cheaper. BUT if most major players try the same strategy of quality reduction at the same time then consumers never get the chance to indicate to the market that they value quality. > A Wall Street banker doesn’t have a carbon footprint that much higher than a regular person. Maybe even less. Maybe don't guess and check first. We're on the internet, you don't have to respond immediately and state something that is verifiably false. While we don't have good refined data on specific jobs, there is strong correlation with wealth levels and specifically consumption rates. But if you're modeling a Wall Street banker as someone who works all day, takes the subway, sleeps, and never takes vacation then sure, that's lower. But don't confuse the mean and the median. Edit: Taking our analogy from above: if all producers simultaneously have to do "x" then all consumers automatically also choose "x". This is where regulation can play a role since you can do things like "all cars must get at least 50mpg" or have a more market driven approach like "$100 fee per ton CO2eq" and use that fee to perform such actions like sequestration and/or research to make sequestration effective and cheap.
- tonyedgecombe 3y ago>Consumers can only buy what's available. We live in an era of unprecedented consumer choice. Especially for the rich who you rightly pointed out are the source of the problems we are trying to ameliorate.
- godelski 3y ago> We live in an era of unprecedented consumer choice. In some ways yes, in some ways no. Markets aren't exclusively driven by consumers and such framing is incredibly naive. You can't buy the fruit that doesn't exist.
- jabradoodle 3y agoSorry but this is insane. I want electricity, or more accurately I want to heat my home, wash my clothes, etc. It is not my consumption that has caused us to continue subsiding oil and not investing properly in renewables for over half a century.