3 ms·
This is going to be a rant... I am an Indian! Currently staying in Bangalore. Indians don't buy Technology? This is BS, right? Indians pay for technology all
by kamaal 15y ago
This is going to be a rant...
I am an Indian! Currently staying in Bangalore.
Indians don't buy Technology? This is BS, right?
Indians pay for technology all the time. From the poorest to richest. Just because they don't click on paypal and the money doesn't land in your start up's account it doesn't mean Indians don't pay up. The average levels of Piracy in India will more or less be the same as they are around the world.
Indians pay for things that bring them value. Not just because you built something. And it is you who built it.So first understand what value you bring common Indian masses.
I know of Auto drivers and cab drivers who get costly metering and taxi dispatch systems fitted to their vehicles. And they are really poor people. They are paying for technology, because it brings value to them. Do you know how many people use mobiles phones in India? Even the poorest people might be earning less than $1 a day(I know many beggars who carry mobile phones) use mobile phones in India, and they pay their bills.
I know Temples, Churches, Mosques use scrolling displays outside their compounds for various announcements. The displays survive in tough weather. And they sell. They bought it because it adds value to them.
I know ordinary middle class people, buy handy glucometers( for diabetes/blood sugar level testing) and Nebulizers and Sphygmomanometers(To check their blood pressure levels), Glucometers made by Accecheck. Why do they buy this technology? Because it brings value to them.
Millions of middle class Indians use solar technology and rain water harvesting systems. And they pay for it, you know why? Because it brings value to them.
I can go on and on... Citing examples.
India is like every other country and Indians are like people from any other nation.
People pay up when they see some value in the product. So any time you accuse Indians of not paying up. Ask your self a simple question.
What value does my service/product bring to the people
If you can't come up with a good answer to this question. Really the problem is with your product strategy.
Not Indians. Or India as a whole.
PS:
In this case 'Tax filing' software/means is worth dime for a dozen in this country.
EDIT : To all people who are downvoting this, Truth is bitter. An MVC site which has a thousand clones or which doesn't bring any value is not bound to succeed.
Seriously ask your self what value you bring to the world or why should people buy from you.
- free 15y agoCompletely agree. I am supremely confident that given the size of the market and the pace at which it is changing it is a great place to start a company. Also somewhat curious as to why lot of people are being so skeptical about it.
- kamaal 15y agoThe problem basically is the belief that there is runaway success in web/iphone/android app start ups and anything else will require a lot of work. This forces people to spoil their thinking that there is easy money in such places. Most people don't know they are getting into Schlep blindness(http://paulgraham.com/schlep.html http://paulgraham.com/schlep.html) I know a lot of guys who think they can become millionaires the moment their MVC site goes live. This is the problem. In general cases. Building anything awesome is difficult, not just in India but any where in the world. Building things which bring value is even more difficult. Building things which bring value both in physical existence and software requires lot of work and patience. Unless people understand this, things won't change.
- asto 15y agoI am also an Indian, also from Bangalore. India and other poor nations account for a larger share of piracy worldwide. Here's a somewhat old study but it still serves to prove my point. http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_sof_pir_rat-crime-software-piracy-rate http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_sof_pir_rat-crime-soft... Almost all the auto drivers here use the meters that come with the auto. Newer 4-stroke autos have better mileage so auto drivers or auto lending firms buy them and they come with digital meters by default so more autos are starting to get them. I don't know about taxies because I don't use them. Most temples, churches and mosques here don't. Buying a glucometer saves a trip to the doctor just for that. It is a reduction of cost and there is no cheaper way to do it. In the case of software however, piracy or a cheaper option is almost always available. Of course you can go on and on but you have proven nothing. You have chosen to speak of a minority who do understand the value of technology and pay for it. I can also show you people/businesses who use FOSS or legally purchased software in Bangalore. Would that mean piracy doesn't exist here or that it is not prevalent? There is always the outlier class in any society. You cannot depend on them for a viable business in most cases.
- kamaal 15y agoYour post only proves my point(That people build things without knowing what value they add). Do you know how much metering for an auto costs? Do you know how much Taxi Dispatch system for a taxi costs? And neither the meter or the TDS comes with the Auto/Taxi. They have to pay for it from their pockets. I know this as a my father is a Taxi Driver. Do you know how much booking for taxis happens through emails/SMS and other online systems. The number is enormous. Those who sell, sell. Those who whine, whine. Coming to your point about Glucometers, again, people buy them because they need them regularly. So they pay for value. Why shouldn't they? I know at least 3 homes around me, and I live deep in Bangalore, not in BTM and Jayanagar types where only rich people live. People in those 3 homes have Nebulizers. They are ordinary middle class people who earn less than me. Your problem is simple, You refuse to learn from failures. And you believe the problem is with people around not with you. If you have the same attitude you will never succeed in business. Business requires learning a lot from feedback. Piracy is a global problem, Not just in India. Your assumption that Piracy is an Indian monopoly is ridiculous to say at the least. You say viable business cannot be set up in India. From where do you think crores of Indians derive their livelihood from? Have you heard of Jamshedpur an entire city set up by Tata's? Again as I said, those who know how to do buisiness in India do it by building value. Those who can't just whine. Lastly code is not the answer to all the problems in world/India. And business success doesn't depend on code alone. It depends on understanding people's problems and solving them. People pay if there is value, not just because its built.