17 ms·
Firearms regulation has a real "gun of Theseus" problem: if you have multiple parts combined into an illegal weapon, which one of those is the illegal part?
by pjc50 3y ago
Firearms regulation has a real "gun of Theseus" problem: if you have multiple parts combined into an illegal weapon, which one of those is the illegal part?
- psunavy03 3y agoGenerally the one that makes it illegal. For the AR platform, for instance, that would be the full-auto trigger group and a lower receiver drilled for a third hole to accommodate it. Some pro-gun people have gone to great lengths to find loopholes in the machine gun laws, and most of them are currently tied up in litigation with the ATF.
- lazide 3y agoAh, but you said it yourself. Is the third hole the problem? Or the drop in auto sear? Or the combination? According to the ATF, it’s any of the three of course. Plus anything else that they don’t like.
- unethical_ban 3y agoIn absence of an easy definition, what is illegal should be the gun which has the capability that is banned. If someone wraps a shoestring around a trigger group to make it "automatic", boom, it's an automatic weapon, seize the gun and arrest the citizen. It's the characteristic. It's why banning guns based off scary black foregrips is silly. If we were to limit guns meaningfully in the US, we should ban all semi-automatic weapons with interchangeable magazines. You still have bolt actions, revolvers, shotguns, but this lowers rate of fire/reload time in combination well enough to meaningfully encumber terrorists. For the 2A crowd ( of which I am a tepid member), my main principle is that citizens should be no less armed than their domestic law enforcement. So if we as a country made such a change, we would have to set a date past which domestic law enforcement must also switch back to revolvers and shotguns only. And now we really live in a fantasy world! Truly, it would be better for society to be less armed, but we're past the point of no return. I say this as someone who owns close to a dozen firearms, including mosins, AR-15 and several semi-automatic pistols.
- lazide 3y agoYup. And it always was, near as I can tell. For a long time it’s been about the PR and how it ‘feels’ when selling the law though, not about actually solving a real problem. The reason why Law Enforcement is never going to do that is because they regularly run across criminals that are already better armed than they are. LAPD started carrying AR-15s (and for many units full auto M4s) because of the North Hollywood bank shootout [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout] for instance. And there have been many instances since then. This isn’t a theoretical concern for normal folks either, even in the Bay Area. Just a few years ago, there was an attempted home invasion robbery in Sunnyvale by someone armed with what clearly would be classified as an assault rifle in CAlifornia, with what looked like a drum magazine. [https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/sanfrancisco/news/police-2-armed-suspects-attempt-to-enter-sunnyvale-home-overnight/ https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/sanfrancisco/news/police-2-armed...] Both are major felonies to possess in California. Which, of course, isn’t likely to stop someone who was clearly intent on committing several felonies already. They never caught them, so it wasn’t clear if it was fully automatic or not. Thankfully the owner was suspicious enough it didn’t turn into an actual home invasion, and Sunnyvale has enough bored cops the perps bugged out before they could force the issue. But this isn’t that unusual or isolated of an incident. And very few places are as well run as Sunnyvale. The laws definitely stop anyone law abiding from having something similar. So why should someone law abiding be willfully handicapped against something like that? Cop or civilian? We can argue training or licensing, burden of proof to show you’re law abiding, or whatever - but that’s not the state of the situation in CAlifornia as I’m sure you’re aware. Or most of the other states where possession of those things is illegal. It’s just flat out illegal - unless you work for the police, anyway.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI think we see the same picture. Well, finally, I would say that a blanket ban on the sale and manufacture of new semiautos with switchable mags would very likely make them disappear over time the way automatics would, for criminals as well. Then you aren't criminalizing their possession, but the supply will naturally go down. I get your point about how bad guys have good weapons sometimes and so people and cops need to be armed, too.
- hajile 3y agoIt goes WAY beyond that. In an AR-15, if you put a dot of paint where you would drill the hole for the pin that makes it automatically, that prison time even if it’s never drilled and it’s physically impossible to install the pin for the auto seer. Likewise, a guy recently got put in prison for painting the design for an automatic part on a piece of sheet metal. The ATF needs to be reigned in hard. Information isn’t the same as doing.
- hef19898 3y agoIs it so? Besides the US, everybody else has it figured out, one way or the other...
- lazide 3y agoReally? Name one. I’ve looked into Regs in a number of countries, and they all either outright ban nearly everything unless you work for the gov’t, or have the same issues. The US just has massive amounts of complaining and BS going on in every area, so it’s more visible. In Switzerland, for one example, you’d just hear some griping from dude at the range, not be able to link to a an hour long YouTube video on it. The tricky part here is the US is essentially 53+ different entities legally, with large and meaningful differences between each of them and some overlap. Less than an hours drive can take you from ‘no magazines over 10 rounds or years in jail’ to ‘60 round drums on sale, don’t forget to pickup a few up after renting a couple machine guns and sending a few thousand rounds down range’. With no real border in between. In the rest of the world, those are national borders, with customs inspections. You can pay some folks in Vietnam to be able to shoot RPGs no issues, and Finland/Scandinavia is generally permissive with firearms for instance. And if you know someone in Russia (especially Chechnya I hear) and have money, no issues getting pretty much anything you want and the paperwork to say it’s all good. Good luck doing that in their neighbors or as a normal Joe though.
- hef19898 3y agoYou just made my point: Automatic firearms are illegal for civilians, barrel length for semi-automatic ones and magazine size is heavly limited (the former min, the latter max limits). The result: A shit ton of less gun violence and mass shootings. So yes, everyone else has it figured out. Only the US insists on being the real world version of the movie wild west. You want to wear tacticool gear and camo, fire automatic weapons? Join the armed forces. That so makes SpecOps cos olay so much harder and requires discipline, regulations and includes the risl of being shot at by equally trained people in active shooting wars. Ranting at the range and posting on YouTube is much easier in comparison, that is true.
- 3y ago