2 ms·
I feel almost exactly the opposite. The practice of tipping is reprehensible. It was rooted in racism and still used for this in some areas. It shifts the risk
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
I feel almost exactly the opposite. The practice of tipping is reprehensible.
It was rooted in racism and still used for this in some areas. It shifts the risk of slow business from the proprietor who is more able to affect it to the workers who aren't. It misleads consumers by making prices effectively false advertising when the tip which is allegedly optional is in practice not. It's a mechanism for tax evasion, but only by higher income people who make an unusually large amount of money from tips. Everything about it should be destroyed.
So I avoid establishments where this is expected, not because I think it's socially harmful not to do it -- I think it's socially harmful to do it. The reason I avoid them is that people get so upset when you tell them this, that it's easier to avoid the environment where it comes up. But even that feels like a cowardice because the result at scale would be to reduce the number of such establishments rather than to reduce the prevalence of tipping within those establishments.
Which is the other reason it feels right to promote this. If you evaluate it as your own individual contribution, anyone by themselves will make no significant difference in either direction. A single digit number of dollars to a stranger at an interval of months or years is not going to affect their life. But if you evaluate the effect at scale -- what if everybody did this? -- the effect of everybody doing it would destroy the practice, which is a powerful good.
- rendall 3y agoTo even have a hope of convincing me that you're not just an entitled, unprincipled miscreant, you have to do more than just "avoid" tipping establishments. You have to not go to any establishment that has tipping. If you do happen to find yourself at one for some reason, and you neither tip nor tell the server upfront before they take your order that they're not going to get a tip, then you're just a loser who takes advantage of the cheap prices set by the social convention that the customer adds 15% to the listed price. There is no convincing me otherwise.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> If you do happen to find yourself at one for some reason, and you neither tip nor tell the server upfront before they take your order that they're not going to get a tip, So you would be fine if someone, or everyone, actually did this? What if your issue is not with tipping whatsoever but rather with the default being 15% instead of 0%, so that tips are only for exceptional service?