2 ms·
> If you do, and then even "scale down" your tip, then it's you who are the exploiter, sorry. If you hire a landscaping company, the workers are underpaid eith
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> If you do, and then even "scale down" your tip, then it's you who are the exploiter, sorry.
If you hire a landscaping company, the workers are underpaid either because they're in the country illegally or because that hiring practice is widespread and suppresses wages. So these are exploited workers.
Tipping isn't generally expected for landscaping. Are you the exploiter if you hire one and don't tip the workers? If not, why doesn't that make you the exploiter? Should you also tip Amazon drivers and PhD candidates and women of every profession including ones who make more money than you?
The criteria can't be that they would be getting exploited without it, because that's arguably true of all of them. Probably of everyone in one way or another. So is your argument just status quo bias?
- rendall 3y agoExploitative was GP's assertion, not mine. The entire argument is suspect and self-serving.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt doesn't matter which word you use. If a worker whose employer you're paying to do something is underpaying them, is it your obligation to make up the difference?
- rendall 3y agoAt least now you no longer pretend that your stance against tipping is but selfless regard for the plight of the exploited worker. Choose: a) Establishment A charges 40% more and pays the workers fairly with benefits and actively refuses tips, or b) Establishment B has the same menu and quality, only charges normal prices and has an expectation of tipping the staff 15%. Maybe from the inherently altruistic goodness of your heart you only ever go to Establishment A, lighter of wallet but warmed by your moral virtue, but most people will go to Establishment B and pay the tip. That's your choice. You might not like it but that's the reality. What you don't get to do is have establishment B's prices with establishment A's tipping policy. Maybe, being clever, you think c) Establishment C charges 15% more and pays it directly to the workers but they must actively refuse tips Believe it or not, C has been tried and it is universally disliked by staff and customers. Staff will happily go to work at B where they can earn more through hard work. Because most people are not no-tip assholes. Customers would rather go to B (and tip) where they can get better service for the same cost. To answer you directly, yes. Yes. If the convention is that the business charges less and you make up the difference, then yes you do. You have an obligation to make up the difference.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> At least now you no longer pretend that your stance against tipping is but selfless regard for the plight of the exploited worker. Is it not? The status quo persists in the absence of some change. You're essentially arguing that a local maxima is preferable to descending the slope to reach the global one. > Customers would rather go to B (and tip) where they can get better service for the same cost. The reason businesses charge $9.99 instead of $10.00 is that psychology plays a large role in consumer behavior. The "false advertising" component of culturally mandated tipping is a competitive advantage in the absence of something to counteract it. It's like saying companies should just avoid hidden fees because customers don't like them. The trouble is the companies that use them get more customers because their prices appear lower. > Staff will happily go to work at B where they can earn more through hard work. Because most people are not no-tip assholes. So in order to make C work you need customers to make B unsustainable. (Also somewhat obviously, if staff "can earn more" the other way then you haven't added the amount to their base wages that makes up for the lack of tips.) And you have a similar psychological component with workers as with customers, because it's harder for workers to evaluate the risk of slow business. Tipping is very casino psychology. People remember the time they got a $50 tip, not the time they stood around all day for $2/hour and there were no customers. They do the math for this week and don't consider what this compensation structure is going to do to them in an economic downturn. If you knew C doesn't work without doing something to counteract the dark patterns in B, why did you recommend it as a solution? Do you have an actual alternate proposal that could feasibly lead to the end of tipping? > If the convention is that the business charges less and you make up the difference, then yes you do. You have an obligation to make up the difference. What if you want to change the convention?
- rendall 3y agoI've already addressed all of these questions. Bottom line is if your stance made your life more difficult while making workers lives easier, I'd be more inclined to listen and take what you say seriously. But it doesn't. The workers earn less and conveniently you get to keep more money in your pocket, all while you get to tell yourself and anyone who will listen that you are fighting racism and exploitation or whatever. Ok, I'm done with this conversation. I will read whatever response you have and it will likely be the last word.