2 ms·
>I'm not sure my "theory" of government would fit into a HN post but it would include things like legitimacy, monopoly of force, right to taxation, distribution
by gruez 3y ago
>I'm not sure my "theory" of government would fit into a HN post but it would include things like legitimacy, monopoly of force, right to taxation, distribution of income, democracy, representation... things like that. Ideally, modern government going back to the Magna Carta is there to protect those without power from those with it.
Okay but that says nothing of why schools and roads are provided by the government but food is not. The theory I gave straightforwardly explains why.
>Anyway - the argument I'm making is that the phrase "socialise losses, privatise profits" accurately describes what actually happens in the world.
I'm not arguing it doesn't. In fact I'm arguing the opposite, which is that it's so good at "accurately describes what actually happens in the world" that it doesn't just cover "bad" things, it also covers "good" things. Outside of transfer programs, most things that the government does are "socialise losses, privatise profits".
>In the end, it's basically just a large scale version of "follow the money".
What's the principle here? I'm sure teachers unions and textbook companies benefit directly from public schools. Companies that hire knowledge workers also probably indirectly benefit. All of the groups probably engage in some sort of political lobbying and/or campaign contributions. Given all that, what should we conclude if we "follow the money"?
- doctor_eval 3y agoFood is provided by the government, it's just done on the basis of subsidies. The USA in particular has - or at least had - some serious problems with overproduction of certain grains due to misaligned government incentives. Anyway - if you think you can explain the purpose of government in a single sentence then nothing I can say is going to change your mind.
- kortilla 3y agoProviding food stamps for low income is privatizing profits (the receivers of food stamps) and socializing losses (everyone who pays taxes). It’s a pointless saying because it describes far more than the idiots who parrot it really intend and when you actually analyze what it means to be against it, the outcome is the opposite of what socialists want.