5 ms·
On a per-incident basis? WMD are called WMD because those weapons are capable of mass destruction. At the scale of cities or entire urban regions (tens of mil
by dredmorbius 3y ago
On a per-incident basis?
WMD are called WMD because those weapons are capable of mass destruction. At the scale of cities or entire urban regions (tens of millions of individuals) for a single weapon deployment. Possible more for chemical, radiological, or biological weapons.
The most egregious attack you list saw 86 fatalities. A large number, yes, but fewer than might be caused by, say, a train derailment or collision particularly where riderships are high. (The worst rail accident in Indian history killed up to 800 at Bihar in 1981 <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bihar_train_derailment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bihar_train_derailment>, as many as 1,700 or more in Sri Lanka following the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Sri_Lanka_tsunami_train_wreck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Sri_Lanka_tsunami_train_w...>; and Europe's worst rail incident at Ciurea in 1917 killed 800--1,000 <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ciurea_rail_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ciurea_rail_disaster>.)
Even allowing that, say, the truck bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993 had been successful, casualties would likely have been on the order of thousands of deaths, and that's a fairly maximal potential (the original twin-towers WTC saw daily occupancy of about 50k people maximum, though the capacity was as much as six times higher). The 1993 Oklahoma City Bombing of the Murrah Federal Building, a far more typical urban structure, killed 168.
Compare with the loss of life from what are now considered small nuclear weapons, air-dropped rather than missile-delivered, at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, with a combined death toll of from 129 to 226 thousand. Attacks from modern ICBMs could kill many millions.
Vehicle attacks can be mitigated by reasonably simple countermeasures including spike strips, webbing, barricades, blast walls, and bollards. Intercontinental-range missiles pose a somewhat greater challenge.
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=yGeOvLgB9U4 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=yGeOvLgB9U4>
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=N_OhTL8TYpk https://yewtu.be/watch?v=N_OhTL8TYpk>
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=XOBvB2ZUuP4 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=XOBvB2ZUuP4>
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=4JBgnhnMOtY https://yewtu.be/watch?v=4JBgnhnMOtY> (Warning: loud soundtrack)
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=Zp85-dBwslE https://yewtu.be/watch?v=Zp85-dBwslE>
Soft targets are of course always vulnerable (by definition). But countermeasures, rapid responses, and surveillance against planned attacks can help minimise total risk.
- jacquesm 3y ago> Trucks aren’t dual use in the same way rockets are. Is what I was responding to and I only observed that more people have died from truck attacks than from rocket attacks. You'd have to go back all the way to WWII V-weapons to show alternatives but these weren't dual use at all, the 'V' stands for 'Vergeltungswaffen' which is revenge weapon, I don't think anybody would argue they were 'dual use' until many years later some of the technology that went into them was repurposed by von Braun et al to create the American space program. Though I'm sure that the engineers may have thought at the time that they were busy with space travel. Besides that only one of those really was a rocket, the others are more like primitively guided flying bombs. SpaceX makes dual use hardware, and just dropping a SpaceX Falcon 9 on some city without a payload would be illustration of that dual use. Trucks normally carry goods from one place to another. But they can also be repurposed as weapons and a single truck attack roughly matches the number of casualties of the V2 rocket attacks, with one hit on a cinema killing more people than the truck attacks but on average the truck attacks appear to be far more deadly. The V2, from a statistics point of view was a complete failure, on average 2 casualties per rocket built and fired, truck attacks kill far more people on average. And even if they are 'easy to defend' against in principle they aren't easy to defend against in practice because there will always be times when large crowds are present near a road giving access. There must be millions of such situations every year and the vast bulk of them are not protected at all.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAddressing the strict interpretation point, JumpCrisscross is incorrect, and you are correct, in that trucks are in fact dual use. The more salient problem is that that really isn't the relevant consideration. In a risks-based assessment, military and security planners in general put far more weight on adversaries who have access to missiles (particularly those with both range and effective targeting and/or navigational capabilities) than they do those who can make, buy, beg, borrow, or steal trucks. And that has implications for incident investigation reports. It's not about dual purpose. It's about overall strategic threat. A truck (absent explosives) might kill a few tens of people in direct vicinity if applied against a crowd. It's not going to strike tens, hundreds, or thousands of kilometers away, without warning. Trucks cannot be unleashed against an adversary half a world away within 45 minutes, as a ballistic missile can. Few trucks have been observed travelling faster than the speed of sound, let alone at the hypersonic velocities of an ICBM. Again: it's not about dual purpose. It's about the overall threat. And the far more reasonable response to JumpCrisscross would have been to point out the weakness of their argument, replacing it with the far more relevant argument (as I've laid out here), and assessing the initial concern, which psunavy03 expressed clearly: The same technology that lets you put a payload in space can let you put a nuclear (or conventional) warhead over a city. The first space launchers were repurposed ICBMs, and so space tech falls under ITAR and other export controls. Which is a plausible and sufficient explanation of why NTSB investigations of rocket incidents are not made public in the same exhaustive detail as one of a truck-based highway accident. Sometimes it's useful to pull back and look at the overall picture and see if your argument makes sense.