4 ms·
Well also the derailments and accidents. That can't be cheap. Do they just convince themselves it won't happen?
by SoftTalker 3y ago
Well also the derailments and accidents. That can't be cheap. Do they just convince themselves it won't happen?
- passwordoops 3y agoThey convince themselves that with their market power, they'll be able to absorb the cost of any settlement... which has been the case for a while now
- Nevermark 3y agoToday, corporate leaders are fundamentally, and therefore rationally, aligned toward optimizing short term results. Their personal risk is short term profit shortfalls, while shareholders and the corporation as a whole carry the longer term risks. Even more misaligned, is the case of public companies. The shorter term someone holds shares, the more impact they have (buying & selling) on current share price, while demanding shorter term results. Without actual personal accountability from company leaders, criminal & civil, no amount of long term corporate risk, will change their rational response to incentives. There is a good reason that dynamic companies “over compensate” their leaders with eye watering stock grants. It isn’t well earned compensation. It is a tool to align interests, benefitting everyone. But for slower growing companies, that is too costly. So for all companies, liability protection for shareholders should be matched by liability acceptance not just from the corporation as a whole, but when it comes to malfeasance, individuals responsible for the malfeasance.
- gruez 3y ago>but when it comes to malfeasance, individuals responsible for the malfeasance. How would that work? Individuals actors within corporations are already responsible for malfeasance. If you took it upon yourself to commit some crimes to boost your KPIs so you get a bigger bonus (eg. threatening employees with violence), being in a corporation isn't going to protect you. Even if you're the boss and you're telling your direct reports to commit crimes, that's still a crime.
- Nevermark 3y agoMalfeasance in the regulatory violations and culpability for irresponsibility sense. Not just criminal. If the corporation is found culpable, or pleads no contest to culpability to reduce their fines or other repercussions, then executive, management or individual culpability would be determined (if any) by an outside party chosen by the board, acting in the interest of shareholders. Details, are not the point I am making, but that is one model. Whatever the process, it would be set in the corporate bylaws, and a minimum process required by stock exchanges to maintain listing. And possibly by law regarding corporate requirements - given law is what defines the balance of shareholder liability vs. corporate liability. This would add corporate employee liability to that balance.
- gruez 3y ago>then executive, management or individual culpability would be determined (if any) by an outside party chosen by the board, acting in the interest of shareholders. What makes you think that "the big fish" will end up being punished, rather than the low level employees?
- Nevermark 3y agoThe devil is always in the details. I can see this improving things simply because the possibility/process of accountability is likely to result in more responsible behavior from everyone. But I can see your point too.
- taberiand 3y agoThey probably convince themselves they'll have moved on to something else before then, or otherwise get a hefty golden parachute when shtf and they bail out
- wredue 3y agoNo silly. They just complain to the feds when it happens, and get a nice big fat day of “getting away Scott free” while tax payers foot the majority of the cleanup cost. The saying is “privatize profits, socialize losses” for a reason.
- gruez 3y ago>while tax payers foot the majority of the cleanup cost. source?
- kortilla 3y ago> The saying is “privatize profits, socialize losses” for a reason. It’s a saying because it’s a catchy socialist rallying cry, not because it has any relevance to the event in question.
- hughesjj 3y agoIt's also a saying because it's trueeee (See: Superfund sites, this event in question, climate change, highways and car based infrastructure, etc...)
- gruez 3y ago>highways and car based infrastructure, etc...) If you follow this line of logic, it quickly gets absurd. The whole point of government is to do things that benefit society as a whole, but aren't feasible to do on a for profit basis (eg. roads, police, schools, etc.). Private companies and individuals are inevitably going to reap benefits as a result. If that constitutes "privatize profits, socialize losses", then you're just describing a properly functioning government. Going back to the initial point, what are governments supposed to do? Not build highways? Not have the police because that would "privatize profits" because private business no longer have to fund their own security?
- doctor_eval 3y ago> The whole point of government is to do things that benefit society as a whole, but aren't feasible to do on a for profit basis Err.. that’s a very unique definition, and certainly not one that’s universally accepted. > If that constitutes "privatize profits, socialize losses", then you're just describing a properly functioning government. One of the many roles of legitimate government is to protect the safety of citizens, aka voters. But corporations are incentivised to reduce costs. When these principles come into conflict, unfortunately the corporates tend to win (at least in the short term), at the expense of everyone else. A “properly functioning” government would balance these conflicts such that the cost of doing business was not socialised, for example by preventing companies from “cheating” by externalising costs that their competitors do not.