4 ms·
H2Fly – Breaking the Hydrogen Barrier
- fourthark 3y agoH2. Twin fuselage. Get it?
- belter 3y ago"First Piloted Flight of Liquid Hydrogen Powered Electric Aircraft" - https://www.h2fly.de/2023/09/07/h2fly-and-partners-complete-worlds-first-piloted-flight-of-liquid-hydrogen-powered-electric-aircraft/ https://www.h2fly.de/2023/09/07/h2fly-and-partners-complete-...
- _Microft 3y agoThe novelty here seems to be that they used liquid hydrogen instead of gaseous hydrogen on a fuel-cell powered, piloted, electric aircraft. This doubled the range that they could achieve on their experimental aircraft to 1500km (~930mi).
- adrian_b 3y agoYes, but they only use vague words without any numbers that could support their claims that hydrogen is viable as an aircraft fuel. They should show the weights, volumes and costs for standard kerosen tanks and their liquid hydrogen tanks with the associated equipment, e.g. pumps, at the same stored energy. At equal stored energy, the liquid hydrogen tanks must be much bigger and much more expensive, and as soon as they are partially empty they will also be heavier than the partially empty kerosen tanks. The maintenance costs and the risks of failure for the cryogenic equipment will also be much greater. They do not say any word about any new technique used in their hydrogen fuel cells. All the kinds of hydrogen fuel cells remain too expensive, either due to using too expensive catalysts or because they have parts with a short lifetime, which must be replaced periodically, e.g. fluoropolymer membranes for low-temperature fuel cells or ceramic electrolytes (e.g. of ceria or zirconia) for high-temperature fuel cells.
- p_l 3y agocryogenic hydrogen was always the centerpiece of hydrogen powered flight. IIRC gaseous simply didn't have the right energy density to be viable. cryogenic also increased efficiency of jet engines and opened avenues for higher speeds (Tu-244 design, for example, for ~ Ma 3 supersonic transport plane)
- audunw 3y ago“Inherently safer than kerosene and synfuels” - No way. Or at least: I don’t think we truly know yet, until they’ve flown for a few years. I used to think hydrogen was extremely safe. It’s super light right, so it should quickly vent away if there’s a leak? Then a hydrogen gas station nearby exploded. Didn’t look like it was very airtight to me, but somehow enough gas collected for a big explosion. It’s extremely hard to prevent hydrogen leaks. The cause of the explosion was a fitting that wasn’t tightened to just perfectly the right torque. Supposedly the procedure to fix this is to have every fitting double checked by a second person. Doesn’t sound inherently safe to me. There’s no warning if there’s a hydrogen leak. There’s no smell or visible gas. The right mixture of hydrogen and air will practically self ignite. There was no source of fire at the gas station. The tiniest invisible spark can set it off. I was also surprised by how loud the explosion was. The explosion is fast. It will rip things apart. On the positive side, it’s over very quickly. You’re not going to have a lingering fire from fuel that has sprayed everywhere like with Kerosene. I think hydrogen CAN become perfectly safe with the right engineering. I think the solution will be that every single piece of tube or valve that has hydrogen flowing through it needs a double tubing around it with active ventilation, and sensors where it vents out to check that it has the expected air flow and no hydrogen gas is detected. But inherently safe? No way
- foobarbecue 3y ago> There’s no smell or visible gas. FWIW, this is also true of methane. An odorant is added to the stuff that's put in gas pipelines. Couldn't they add the odorant to H2 as well?
- merek 3y agoH2 molecules are small and thus prone to leaking through small breaches in the containment. Odorant molecules are much larger and less likely to escape.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoAt least methane burns with a visible flame in daylight.
- 3y ago
- goethes_kind 3y agoIs electric propulsion even viable for passenger jets?
- goethes_kind 3y agoMaybe I am naive, but let's say that using liquid hydrogen instead of synthetic kerosene would use 1/3 of the input energy. OK. To me, it seems way more feasible to triple the amount of input energy capacity (build more solar, wind, nuclear, ...whatever), than to completely redesign aviation around a fuel with such unforgiving constraints. What am I missing?
- credit_guy 3y agoYou're not missing anything. What everyone else is missing is that to achieve net zero you don't need to decarbonize everything. The planet absorbs about half of the CO2 that we emit (see the IPCC FAQ 5.1 [1]). If we decarbonize everything but aviation we are well into negative CO2 emissions territory. [1] https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/downloads/faqs/IPCC_AR6_WGI_FAQ_Chapter_05.pdf https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/downloads/faqs/IPCC_AR6_W...
- mdorazio 3y agoPerhaps that traditional engines shoot greenhouse gas straight into the stratosphere and that’s a bad thing?
- goethes_kind 3y agoI was talking about carbon neutral synthetic kerosene which is a step beyond green hydrogen in the power-to-gas pipeline.
- mdorazio 3y agoNot sure how I was supposed to get that from your comment or why you think kerosene is a better solution when burning it in jet engines still puts greenhouse gas straight into the atmosphere? I feel like I missed some big piece of your argument here.
- qfiard 3y agoSynthetic kerosene was the hint. You can make carbon neutral kerosene in the same way as biofuel, it doesn't add greenhouse gases to the atmosphere since the carbon it contains was captured from the atmosphere. Not a perfect solution as it doesn't solve the impact of contrails and there is the problem of how to generate so much biofuel, but it is a valid way to decarbonize flying.
- rdevsrex 3y agoI think Hydrogen is a great fuel to replace natural gas for generating electricity. But is it safe enough for commercial airplanes? I don't know, we'll have to see.