3 ms·
Be careful. As a generalist (non-scientific) writer, I've had a few AI flagged text things (sentences and paragraphs). It was only when I showed the editor that
by YearZeroWriter 3y ago
Be careful. As a generalist (non-scientific) writer, I've had a few AI flagged text things (sentences and paragraphs). It was only when I showed the editor that my text had not changed since writing the flagged parts in going back to 2014 and 2016 that they said, "hmm, a false positive".
This normally happened when I context switched from dialog driven storytelling to long blocks of narrative storytelling. So, people should take each problem as a unique problem and not a systemic problem rampant through the system. Also AI check tools are different with differnt thresholds.
To me it feels like AI is part boogeyman too, "What are we going to do with this?! It's clearly our Y2K-borg-Napster-assimilation-with-VHS-and-CDs moment."
I will close by saying, if you are not augmenting your life with AI, you're only hurting yourself. I can guarantee you that your competition is doing this, (both as individuals and for their teams using Midjourney, Grammarly, ChatGPT, etc). I should also qualify that I don't take the hardline ethical stance on AI things (clearly). Some people do. I don't know what do with hardliners, it's damn hard to have a conversation these days.
- rawgabbit 3y agoThat is something I have been wondering about LLMs. Do they keep track of large chunks of text, they were trained on? e.g., Does ChatGPT know that "Four scores and seven years" was a speech given by Abraham Lincoln to commemorate the battle of Gettysburg? Or does some articles say ChatGPT just write "plausible" sentences. In other words, the reverse ChatGPT that tries to identify papers written by AI. Is it really sure that the text is plagiarized or is it simply "plausibly" written by AI. That is if something like this goes go to court and the judge asks serious questions... will these AI detectors be laughed at?
- thfuran 3y agoBased on the long history of taking complete nonsense very seriously in forensics, I'd say the odds are pretty good that it'll be taken way too seriously, at least for other AI systems, but perhaps not specifically plagiarism detectors if a large chunk of the jury has personal experience fighting with overzealous anticheat crapware at school.
- Miraltar 3y agoI think a lot of us would agree that using AI to help redacting a paper isn't inherently wrong. It's more about how it's done. Having an article go through peer review and get published with things like "As an AI..." shows that people don't use it to enhance their work but to produce quantity over quality and that the articles aren't really reviewed.