5 ms·
Any bets on whether IBM will be able to keep afloat until 2035? They're still big but they keep making one unforced error after another. One surefire way to ge
by jacquesm 3y ago
Any bets on whether IBM will be able to keep afloat until 2035?
They're still big but they keep making one unforced error after another. One surefire way to get your customers to research the competition is by such immense price changes. This sort of thing is done gradually unless you are trying to get rid of a certain segment of your customers. Which may well be the case, but if it isn't they have a problem, and regardless you can't really predict how many of the customers you wanted to keep will leave as well. And that's before we get into reputation damage.
- pjmlp 3y agoWithout a problem, because HNers keep ignoring the whole set of services, patent records per year, R&D being done, its domain across Java, mainframe, micros, being the only UNIX that survived Linux, being one of the major Linux backers, being the main GCC driver while clang lags behind while Apple/Google backed away and everyone else enjoys its license, the xl toolchain used in some supercomputers...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 3y agoFor me, IBM is a quantum play supported by legacy mainframe business. Probably not long for this world, but if their quantum system 2 announcement actually goes well, hype may serve diligent investors well.
- btown 3y agoTurning quantum into a business model that is not only self-sustaining but at the level of profitability of IBM's legacy business... that's a big ask for even the most agile company with the best technologists in the world. And if they internally knew their Quantum System 2 was game-changing - why do this desperate move in their cloud business?
- bob1029 3y ago> that's a big ask If practical quantum does pan out, it will make this current AI situation look insignificant by comparison. It may also become extremely synergistic with the current AI movement. Quantum search will allow for us to seek out global minima across gigantic parameter sets. > why do this desperate move in their cloud business? Everyone is jacking up their prices. Microsoft would have to triple our cost before we'd think about tearing up our tech stack and moving again.
- jncfhnb 3y agoI doubt global maxima are meaningfully different than the local maxima achieved today tbh. Especially considering the effort to avoid overfitting.
- rightbyte 3y ago> Quantum search will allow for us to seek out global minima across gigantic parameter sets. Just like pouring water on the floor will find the global minima on it. Just wait until there is one puddle left. O(1). I am yet to be convinced quantum computers are real at all and not just some slow convoluted variant of an analogue computer.
- thatguy0900 3y agoPouring water on the floor is probably a pretty good example of finding a local minima
- jacquesm 3y agoIf the floor is the surface you are interested in and if you're not in space... It's gravity that does the sorting for you, if you want to do this in space at a minimum you will have to have a spinning container and the surface you're interested in had better be the floor.
- allenrb 3y agoYou’ve hit the nail on the head here, imho. The people running these clouds aren’t fools. Prices will absolutely continue to rise.
- oblio 3y agoMeh, if you've been following their day to day business, mainframes are just one part. IBM now is primarily a big IT consulting business (think Java, not zOS), one of those semi garbage shops like HP Consulting, Oracle Consulting, TCS, etc. They're a 2nd or 3rd tier company as far as job quality and compensation is concerned. I wouldn't worry about them, these companies will probably outlive the both of us.
- onionisafruit 3y agoThe company will be around, but it might only be in the form of a patent portfolio and government contractor. No telling if the government contractor will have their own data centers or resell other clouds.
- ilyt 3y agoI just hope they won't end up selling RedHat to MS in few years...
- onionisafruit 3y agoWould MS-owned RedHat be worse than IBM-owned RedHat?
- gustavus 3y agoThey have ironclad contracts with the DoD and other government organizations, and with the way those processes work if every person from the president to the peon decided they wanted to move everything off of IBM and were going to move heaven and earth to do it. They wouldn't even be able to start entertaining bids from other competitors until 2035. Beyond this IBM's core competency is winning government contracts, a niche very few other people have the desire or the resources, or the proper understanding of the necronomicon to enter.
- xyst 3y agoNow that you mention it. Isn’t the brand new FedNow program built using mainframe tech? Shit man, IBM will live on for centuries (assuming we get that far)
- throwawayForMe2 3y agoThe FRB moved the last of its major services off of the mainframe around 2017 I believe. It does use MQ as an interface.
- mhh__ 3y agoMainframes are technologically pretty interesting just wrapped in IBM poison
- rbanffy 3y agoYou are not forced to use the "poison" - you can get them as LinuxONE machines and run everything on top of a very thin hypervisor (which is necessary, since nothing runs on bare metal on the newer machines).
- mhh__ 3y agoAm I not then throwing away all the cool stuff that makes them unique? The poison I'm referring to is the IBM bean counters and lock-in not the software
- Finnucane 3y agoBy 2035, we will all be afloat.
- datameta 3y agoFull disclosure, IBM Systems employee here. I honestly think the server and mainframe development will remain regardless of what else happens. There's a niche between linux x86 box and supercomputer that won't likely disappear.
- ksec 3y agoNot IBM employee nor Shareholder but Agree. And even if they may disappear, it is obviously not before 2035. I am even willing to bet not even 2045. People asking these questions obviously have zero idea of IBM's mainframe and server business. May be it is worth mentioning, as little as 5 - 6 years ago more than half of HN have never heard of SAP.
- comex 3y agoBut half the top supercomputers are a cluster of Linux x86 boxes, and the other half are Linux on some other architecture.
- datameta 3y agoI think it's not accurate to call their architecture a cluster of machines. Either way I'm not referring to Linux as an OS - it is really the only choice for enterprise scale computing. Regardless of what architectures supercomputers use, their use cases are different from that of server/mainframe high performance compute. 8 cores with on-chip AI acceleration running at 5GHz sharing virtual cache, using ~256GB-1TB of of RAM at ~76-304Gbps transfer speed is something a major bank would use. It won't cut it for SoTA atmospheric modeling, molecular modeling, or something like rapid computational chemistry search space exploration. What it excels at is the ability to handle a blazing number of "ordinary" and AI inferenced transactions per second. Then there's the SAP HANA where entire workloads have data fully stored in the gargantuan RAM. Could I be neglecting to foresee certain trends in technology or industry? Perhaps. What I'm doing here is highlighting that the current niche is well served by POWER and Z. I don't see the current users switching entirely to Cloud - that ship sailed 5 years ago.
- jacquesm 3y ago
- bluedino 3y ago(Fortune 100 here) We're using their mediocre products and services and keep outsourcing even more crap to them!
- keep_reading 3y agoIBM has a GSA contract, so they'll never fail. Like Lowes. Home Depot might go out of business if the market crashes hard enough, but Lowes is protected as they're a GSA contractor. The Federal government will never let them fail. Too essential.
- sailfast 3y agoMany businesses have GSA Schedule contracts but most of them don’t get much business. For many, it’s not even worth the cost to obtain them.
- nvr219 3y agoIBM is over 100 years old and will be around for another 100.
- zjaffee 3y agoThey will be, their mainframe business is still pretty central to all things banking related. And I'm pretty airlines use them for critical services as well.
- Stranger43 3y agoFrom a financial perspective IBM's model of buying up customer's by taking over smaller successfull outfits, maximizing profit's while the quality goes down the drain and using that profit to restart the process have actually been successful enough over the last 2 decades since they switched from being an engineering company to an capital fund with a tech focus. This is probably just the same strategy ie IBM might have realized that their cloud department is as popular as it will ever be and is now entering the squaze phase of it's lifecycle.