5 ms·
> ...a network of ceramic water pipes and drainage ditches at the Chinese walled site of Pingliangtai dating back 4,000 years to a time known as the Longshan pe
by bell-cot 3y ago
> ...a network of ceramic water pipes and drainage ditches at the Chinese walled site of Pingliangtai dating back 4,000 years to a time known as the Longshan period.
Reaction: If the site was "walled" (and not somehow occupied after the builders simply abandoned it), then obviously the engineering skills and social organization for large-scale infrastructure construction did exist.
> The level of complexity associated with these pipes refutes an earlier understanding in archaeological fields that holds that only a centralized state power with governing elites would be able to muster the organization and resources to build a complex water management system.
Reaction: That "earlier understanding" sounds very comfortable and convenient, if you are an archaeologist with elitist social biases, or dependent on support from members of a social elite, or who is a member of his society's social elite. Wealthy and powerful people rationalizing that poor and oppressed people somehow "needed" them was already an old trope when the first pyramid was built.
- duxup 3y agoI don't understand why ANY determination has to be made about "social elite" or ... "non-social elite" matters. The fact that construction and some planning took place seems to just be evidence that some planning and construction took place.
- dmix 3y agoThey said the lack of evidence of social stratification in the burial sites and house sizes contrasted with other sites near by. Plus remember this is the headline a news site chose not the scientists. It's very plausible journalists (including university PR teams) care more about social elitism than the archaeologists which is why it's the HN headline. The archaeologist is just using the only evidence they have which is some pipes, a cemetery, and few remaining structures to extrapolate about the community.
- diogenes4 3y agoCausal evidence is basically non-existent in archaeology. You are correct that, deductively, we can conclude little more about society from this other than that construction took place. Archaeology attempts to collect all possible evidence and weigh the potential narratives. This can be especially effective at teasing out trends across many sites and cultures. Are we likely getting details wrong if we were to infer a specific society from these trends? Absolutely. We will likely never know most aspects of these cultures—but if that's your goal, even well-documented history will fail us. We know a lot about the lifestyles of european benedictine monks, for instance, because they were excellent record keepers, but we still can't answer basic questions about their lives. Anyway, with this specific article social stratification is one of those things with little ability to extract a narrative from a single data point, but whose importance emerges when collated with others. And it does sound a bit editorialized for modern narratives, but that's probably not intended by the researchers.
- eru 3y ago> We know a lot about the lifestyles of european benedictine monks, for instance, because they were excellent record keepers, but we still can't answer basic questions about their lives. That's why finding their garbage or where they emptied their latrines is often more insightful than finding yet another written record.
- bluGill 3y agoOnly because they have left so much written record that we don't really expect that another record will tell us something we didn't already know. The less we know about some culture the more valuable written record would be - but often it isn't available. When we already know a culture well archeology can tell us where they ideals they wrote about themselves don't match reality. When we know nothing though, archeology leaves us with a lot of evidence that we don't really know what to make of.
- eru 3y agoMaybe. Though people rarely write down the things that we now find most interesting. Have a look at very old newspapers or magazines. It's almost irrelevant today who won the latest elections or what scandal happened to whom; the old ads are typically the most fascinating part. Similarly, we have a treasure trove of old clay tablets with complaints, mundane contracts, letters by normal people etc. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complaint_tablet_to_Ea-n%C4%81%E1%B9%A3ir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complaint_tablet_to_Ea-n%C4%81... Those are much better at shining a light on how people lived, then the typical drivel about 'important' events we get in most early writing.
- digging 3y ago> I don't understand why ANY determination has to be made about "social elite" or ... "non-social elite" matters. Generally, archaeology is interested in knowing information about past societies.
- peteradio 3y agoElites to poors - See! Without us you wouldn't have the pyramids! Poors - WTF do I want a pyramid for?
- piuantiderp 3y agoElite: did you say something? Get back to work!
- mcpackieh 3y agoAlso the poors - All right, but apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, the fresh-water system, and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?
- renewiltord 3y agoIt's not "comfortable" or "convenient". People are just trying to piece together stuff to find the most likely hypothesis. For instance, if you saw evidence of a successful space program you'd assume that it requires government. That's because there are natural difficulties with these enterprises that require some degree of coordination because you have free-rider problems, transit provider problems, etc. The coordination mechanisms can be a whole bunch of things: we use markets very effectively today, but we also use governments or religions. And yes, it could be another mechanism but someone has to postulate one such mechanism and find tests that it does not fail. What's interesting is that the evidence pointed overall to one mechanism and now it points to another. This sort of low-brow stuff fills people who read this stuff so much. "the elites", god.
- no_butterscotch 3y agoI feel like you read more into this and maybe added in your own biases. I don't think these archaeologists are interested in worshipping society's elites. Maybe hundreds of years ago when you had to be an elite to be an archaeologist.
- edgyquant 3y agoThe Chinese government funds archaeology in the hope it legitimizes the Chinese state as the most ancient. Pointing to a time when the state wasn’t there, yet society flourished, would delegitimize the Chinese state in their eyes.
- hmm37 3y agoYou're kidding right? Chinese philosophy always talks about a golden age prior to when the state didn't exist. Even the current Chinese Communist government believes in the idea of primitive communism, that is before the slave societies of e.g. the Shang dynasty, there were more or less stateless societies. Although already by the Zhou dynasty philosophers were stating that societal changes, specialization, etc. made going back to such ways close to impossible.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoPerhaps they want to avoid another: "Century of humiliation" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoThe trouble is that the presence of a state doesn't prove anything. There is no such thing as a stateless society. Every society is governed, even if the governing isn't formalized in some way that is identifiable to a particular understanding. Families, tribes, etc. are societies that, too, are governed. You just have to define "govern" accordingly, and the Chinese state is very keen to understand "the state" as overbearing, master of initiative, controlling, intrusive, etc. But when you look at societies in the past, something also reflected in the writings of Thomas Aquinas in which he discusses the duties of the state and its citizens, the role of the state was and was seen in rather restrained terms (the total sum of concrete things a given state does is partly dependent on circumstances, of course). It functioned more like a referee. And that makes sense. Citizens live their lives in time and place and so on, and the state responds when something concerning the common good requires its attention. It is bottom up, in this sense (though we cannot reduce society to the sum of its individuals). But the state isn't "running" things as if it were some godlike puppet master that animates the universe. The trouble with the present Chinese state is the manner in which it governs and the deeply flawed presuppositions about society, the state, and the individual that it is founded on. And so in this sense, it is clear why they would want to emphasize centralization to argue in favor of their particular vision of statehood, a kind of Tsarist, or as Koneczny would say, Turanian domination. Societies do need a state, but it does not follow that they need something like the crushing behemoth that bears down on China.
- woooooo 3y agoIt's the opposite. There's a lot of pressure in academia to find and publicize examples of "not hierarchical and male dominated" settlements, especially ones that achieved technical successes. A friend once received a 10 email tirade over several hours by making some benign metallurgical observations that some bronze was likely imported, because it contradicted this narrative for a given location.
- godelski 3y ago> There's a lot of pressure in academia Be careful to over generalize. There's a clear distinction in political divides between STEM departments and the humanities. But both even have inner differences. As an example, if you study Country X, you may or may not have certain conditions required to gain access to historical documents that are controlled by said country. Even if you don't live in that country and aren't leaving, those documents are on loan from said country and they control access. Long story short, stop over simplifying things and google Simpson's Paradox.
- ETH_start 3y agoSTEM is also totally captured by left wing ideology. It's still more accountable to reality through controlled experiments, due to its domain of inquiry being the hard sciences, so maintains more scientific rationality, but the situation is bad nonetheless.
- godelski 3y agoIs this something you've experienced or something you've been told. Because if the latter than my experiences differ from what you've been told.
- ETH_start 3y agoIt's what I've observed, and experienced through personal interactions. The sample size of the people I've interacted with is admittedly very small.
- mannykannot 3y agoThere's another example of bottom-up infrastructure construction in the barbed-wire telephone networks which sprung up in western America... and, of course, there's the whole FOSS movement. If we trace the latter back through Unix and Bell Labs, both of these come together in the person of Alexander Graham Bell, though his vision of communications technology infrastructure was, of course, quintessentially top-down. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/barbed-wire-telephone-lines-homesteaders-prairie-america-history https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/barbed-wire-telephone-...
- Ebree 3y agoTo be fair Pharaohs at least felt deep responsibility for own subjects well-being, active defence of state borders and common interest of own folk living there. But not to the self defeating level of Sargon of Akkad and the first socialist welfare state's collapse known to history.
- pimlottc 3y agoIsn’t it great how technologists are smarter than every other profession?!?
- bell-cot 3y agoIf only... https://xkcd.com/435/ https://xkcd.com/435/ (I'd put programmers in with the biologists, roughly.)
- naniwaduni 3y agoComputer scientists ought, by all rights, be hanging out with the statisticians in the no-man's land between physics and math. The actual practice of the field rates maybe about a psych, though.