6 ms·
The Development of the M1 Garand and Its Implications
- mcpackieh 3y agoSeems like a classic case of the innovator or early adopter's dilemma. If you're one of the first to do a new thing (in this case, semi-automatic rifles for your army) then you risk getting stuck with something that lacks refinement (smaller cartridge, removable magazines, select fire). Those latter two were retrofitted to the M1 to make the M14, but the full sized rifle cartridge wasn't a good fit.
- Zak 3y agoThe US military's new M7 rifle with its 6.8x51mm cartridge suggests current military leaders do not think the full-power rifle cartridge was a mistake.
- unethical_ban 3y agoIt was a mistake at the time, but we've come around full circle a bit. If I recall correctly, and I am not a military expert, engagements are happening at longer distances again and enemies have stronger body armor. Thus the need once more for a large cartridge.
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoThe shift is more that that the military leaders think that the battle environment is changing again and this is to preempt that shift. Part of it is the perceived expectation of going against infantry with better body armor, and part of it is improved electronics. The M7 has a fire control computer built into the optic which should allow for easier engagements at extended range.
- rgoulter 3y agoThe French small arms seem particularly afflicted by this. The Lebel rifle is notable for being the first rifle which used smokeless gunpowder. (This made the bullet much faster; but also didn't reveal the shooter's positions in the same way that blackpowder did). Smokeless was so good, that the rifle's development was rushed, in secrecy. Aside from being smokeless, the Lebel had technology that was the state of the art at the time... but, within a few short years, was almost obsolete for its lack of rapid loading, and its awkwardly shaped cartridge. I think the French were working on replacing their infantry rifles with the next-generation technology of repeating rifles, but were unable to do so before WWI.
- legitster 3y agoAnother thing not touched on here - horse cavalry was still a concern before the war! A round being large enough to kill a horse quickly is part of the reason they were so big to begin with.
- paganel 3y agoFuture Marshal of the Soviet Union Zhukov was a cavalry man in the Tsarist Army during WW1 (he got injured somewhere in Eastern Transylvania while riding his horse at some point) and in the inter-war period he served in a cavalry unit in Izyum (or close to it), a city known today because of its vicinity to the Ukrainian - Russian front. He had a love of horses throughout his career, which probably explains this famous victory parade photo. [1] Of course, at some point during the WW2 Eastern Campaign horse-traction became very important, especially for the Germans (hard to do logistics beyond the Don river when there’s no railway nearby). I have a feeling that at some point in the future (when the oil will have run out, for example) we’ll get back to horse-assisted warfare. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idol_(stallion)#/media/File%3AGeorgy_Zhukov_9.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idol_(stallion)#/media/File%3A...
- hef19898 3y agoAs it turned out, the 5.56 mm round is not the best choice neither. Hence a variwty of 7.62 mm chambered rifles in use and the new US army assault rifle. As with everything engineering, it is a trade off.
- exhilaration 3y agoNot mentioned in the article is that Americans can buy their very own M1 Garand via the Civilian Marksmanship Program: https://thecmp.org/cmp_sales/rifle-sales/ https://thecmp.org/cmp_sales/rifle-sales/
- Balgair 3y ago~$800 per rifle, for those that went looking through the page and couldn't find it. If others know of reputable sources that are cheaper, please link!
- AlgorithmicTime 3y agoThat’s definitely the best price you’re going to find for a serviceable Garand.
- carbocation 3y ago> Effective October 1, 2023, the CMP’s new yearly limit on M1 Garands will be 6 per calendar year. Fascinating.
- bhtru 3y agoBelieve this refers to per person. Otherwise this would be quite the robust program to only move 6 deadstock rifles a year.
- carbocation 3y agoYes, sorry, it's clear in context that it's per person: https://thecmp.org/sales-and-service/m1-garand/ https://thecmp.org/sales-and-service/m1-garand/
- bombcar 3y agoNote that you can get them decently cheaper third hand, or so I’ve seen.
- rlonstein 3y agoI have childhood memories of the M1. We spent summers at unlikely places like Camp Perry, Ohio and Quantico, Virginia. My father, a civilian, was an instructor and shot for the state team. I ran around the bases and spent time in the 1000yd pits. I wish I still had the unofficial "pit pig" t-shirt. Later as a teen I didn't have the patience to strap myself into a shooting jacket and bake in the sun so never developed the skill he had.
- Clubber 3y agoIt's never too late. I shoot as a hobby. I got introduced into it as a young kid shooting single shot .22LR in summer camp (it was a different time), or maybe at my grandparent's farm; I was so young I don't remember. It gets me outside, gives me something to look forward to and you can really nerd out on reloading and DOPE charts and all that. Gun smithing isn't that hard for most things, so you can nerd out on that too, like building your own computers.
- rlonstein 3y agoOh, I know, I have an application to a local range sitting right here! But I have other non-tech hobbies in motorcycling, metal working, and archery... I haven't made the time.
- Clubber 3y agoCareful with those motorcycles. I rode them for a while but stopped when I kept reading about deaths every day for 2 weeks. Also recently found out our neighbor lost their college age son to a motorcycle wreck. It's the other drivers and there isn't much you can do about it, even if you are an expert rider. They're fun, but damn, not worth it to me.
- rlonstein 3y agoThank you, I won't jinx myself but I'm going on my thirty-sixth year as a motorcyclist including years riding (and bicycling) in NYC. I improve my odds by practicing annually and wearing fully armored gear including spine and chest protection. I ride more cautiously and anticipate more than I used to but I am aware it's not going to make a significant difference if a SUV crosses the center line at speed.
- h2odragon 3y agoI know one guy who still hunts to feed his family, he's out year round and in any weather... He swears by an M1. Everybody else I know who has them doesn't really use them; they're a backup thats on the rack because they saw it cheap at a show or got it from someone as a gift etc. "every long arm collector should have one"
- shipscode 3y agoThat guy must be jacked, lugging an M1 around the woods is no joke.
- rlonstein 3y agoWhere is he? I ask because in the Northeast most game is taken at relatively short distances, tens rather than hundreds of yards. That's one heavy rifle to lug around if he's stalking. The old school Model-94 30-30 is around seven pounds and considered heavy.
- h2odragon 3y agoWest TN. He uses a 4 wheeler and tree stands as well as hunting a couple large cornfields. I doubt he'll be doing it that much longer, if he hasn't already given up; I know his knees bother him.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoProbably one of the most stable rifles I've ever fired. Don't use it with regular 30-06 though, you need a special version with less powder (and thus less power).
- psunavy03 3y agoAmmo manufacturers make ammo that's labeled to be spec'd as M1 or M2 ball. You have to look for it but it's not hard to find. Or just roll your own. The specs aren't hard to find online, so long as you also bounce them off a reputable reloading manual and don't just freelance.
- H8crilA 3y agoIf you're confused as to what exactly is M1: https://youtu.be/eb_a7u3K8Bo https://youtu.be/eb_a7u3K8Bo Even Apple has joined this amazing naming convention.
- czbond 3y agoThanks - I was wondering what the new CPU/GPU on the "older" M1 platform is that I missed.
- d_silin 3y agoPity the article didn't mention SVT, Soviet mass-produced battle rifle and close equivalent of Garand. Arguably more modern design, similar to M14 in features (adjustable gas regulator and detachable magazine).
- trothamel 3y agoI was able to visit the Springfield Armory a few weeks ago, and they had a large section on the Garand. Here's a couple of pictures I took, including serial number 1, serial number 51 (the first machine-made M1 Garand), and serial number 6,084,405 (the production M1). https://photos.app.goo.gl/snByHzmLP8fHVA2X6 https://photos.app.goo.gl/snByHzmLP8fHVA2X6
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoThe Garand paratrooper model kept my grandfather alive in the Army Air Corps. He had a deactivated one clutched by deer hooves on a plaque mounted near the ceiling.
- distantsounds 3y agoYouTuber RetoAhoy did a fantastic video on its history and modern references in video games: https://youtu.be/6HEAA0C6a4Q?si=ugQa1N3uYTW2Ncok https://youtu.be/6HEAA0C6a4Q?si=ugQa1N3uYTW2Ncok
- briffle 3y agoInteresting discussion on how they tested with a .276, considering they are tooling up to move the US military from a 5.56mm to a .277/6.8mm round in the new xm7 rifles. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/.277_Fury https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/.277_Fury
- Lammy 3y ago> Secondly, the en-bloc clip ejected with the last bullet, making a distinctive ping. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoBWUs8poYU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoBWUs8poYU
- emmelaich 3y agoAside, the mentioned Audie Murphy has an impressive record. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audie_Murphy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audie_Murphy > He received every military combat award for valor available from the United States Army, as well as French and Belgian awards for heroism. > After the war, Murphy embarked on a 21-year acting career. He played himself in the 1955 autobiographical film To Hell and Back, based on his 1949 memoirs of the same name,
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoM1 is a great autoloader, and this article really spells out the difficulty in getting the Defense Department to . . ahh . . stop looking towards the past. I was gonna say something different but thought better of it. I'd also like to shine a light on early efforts at an individual squad automatic weapon in the former Russian Empire, culminating in the 1915 Fedorov Avtomat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedorov_Avtomat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedorov_Avtomat Ian McCollum did a Forgotten Weapons on this one as well https://youtu.be/M7yhQXFKHMc?si=-nd4mNhsA-DHbqzr https://youtu.be/M7yhQXFKHMc?si=-nd4mNhsA-DHbqzr The Russians had arguably the most combat experience with high volume of fire in defense, thanks to the experiences of the Russo-Japanese war, and what's more, they sought to capitalize on it, seeing it as working hand in hand with the geographic strengths of the Empire. The Revolution put a serious speed bump in that, obviously, as the most forward thinking military folks were not going to get on terribly well during the purges. Tukhachevsky says hello. But if the Fedorov had just a slightly different timeline, we could have seen a very different infantry landscape in late-WW1. As it was, we had to wait for the AVS-36 to make its appearance as the first selective fire battle rifle.
- riku_iki 3y ago> we could have seen a very different infantry landscape in late-WW1 but there were plenty automatic rifle designs by the ww2, still most infantry used bolt action rifles, likely bottleneck was in reliable mass manufacturing.
- benj111 3y agoThere's a couple of issues. 1. Militaries generally feared their soldiers using too much ammo. Eg the magazine Lee Enfield was only supplied with one magazine, and early on was only intended to be fired single shot with the magazine used in an emergency. 2. Cost. You see all kinds of conversion proposals to update bolt action rifles for this reason. I believe the French actually updated flintlock rifles all the way up to breach loaders rather than buying new.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoYeah, they were stuck with what they had tooling for. That was specifically brought up in the case of the Red Army: they had designs, but they couldn't possibly supply the numbers. Not after the purges, and then the utterly preposterous losses of 1941-1942. Which, well, a lot of that was the purges. It forced them to re-equip the whole Red Army three times over. I guess without the purges, a whole lot changes. It's a huge wildcard in the alternate history. Also, doctrine, logistics, the everything . . just didn't know what to do with a infantry platoon when everyone has a machine gun. It screwed up the machine . . and, let's be honest, the infantryman's small arm is a teensy tiny minority of where casualties come from. Even back in 1941. Far better to keep the big wheel turning with motorized transport, artillery, aircraft.
- sorokod 3y agoUnusual to find a typo on acoup. It is "Mosin Nagant", not "Mosin Nagat".
- mcmoor 3y agoIf you're early enough there are actually tons. Some suspect it's to fool some bots who copy articles immediately after it's released.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoSpeaking of it's rate of fire, at one point the ATF declared that a shoestring was a machinegun because it could be used to make an M1 rifle fire in an automatic fashion[1]. A decade or so later, they backpedaled a bit and said that shoestrings are only machineguns when they're attached to M1 rifles in a way that causes them to fire multiple times with a single trigger pull [1]: https://i.imgur.com/269aaSq.jpg https://i.imgur.com/269aaSq.jpg
- queuebert 3y ago"How to Build a Machine Gun on a Shoestring Budget"
- rideontime 3y agoThat seems reasonable.
- panarky 3y agoAccording to the literal text of the statute quoted there, the definition of "machinegun" hinges on a "single function of the trigger". If the shoestring achieves rapid fire by causing multiple functions of the trigger, how is it a machinegun by that definition? Also, for anyone like me who expected that jpg would be a photo of the shoestring instead of text on paper, here's what it looks like. https://i.imgur.com/5N3EHxh.jpg https://i.imgur.com/5N3EHxh.jpg
- aardvarkr 3y agoHere’s the shoestring-modified M1 in operation. That’s pretty clearly a fully automatic weapon. https://ifunny.co/video/shoestring-machine-gun-in-september-2004-the-atf-decided-that-mKGWzGMC8?s=cl https://ifunny.co/video/shoestring-machine-gun-in-september-...
- panarky 3y agoHow would you re-write the statute so that it would apply to this?
- 3y ago