3 ms·
> English is a bit odd due to having several different words for an animal and its flesh How odd is this? I noticed something odd in Mandarin: cow: niu 牛 bee
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
> English is a bit odd due to having several different words for an animal and its flesh
How odd is this? I noticed something odd in Mandarin:
cow: niu 牛
beef: niu rou 牛肉
sheep: yang 羊
mutton: yang rou 羊肉
pig: zhu 猪
pork: rou 肉 [it's possible to specify 猪肉, but not necessary]
deer: lu 鹿
venison: lu rou 鹿肉
And some where the distinction doesn't exist in English:
chicken (animal): ji 鸡
chicken (food): ji rou 鸡肉 [English pullet refers to the animal, not the meat]
goat (animal): yang 羊
goat (food): yang rou 羊肉
But there's also this one:
jellyfish (animal): shuimu 水母
jellyfish (food): haizhe 海蜇
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xeonmc 3y agoI think you failed to realize that 肉 just means "meat", in the most general sense possible. Under no circumstance is the character by itself ever directly denotes pork. So there's really nothing odd about saying "chicken meat" or "cow meat" when you want to specifically specify the flesh of the animal for consumption.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> I think you failed to realize that 肉 just means "meat", in the most general sense possible. Yes, I'm aware of that. (It isn't restricted to meat; it will also, much like the English word "flesh", refer to the flesh of fruit.) > Under no circumstance is the character by itself ever directly denotes pork. But this is just false. The character by itself directly denotes pork. It's not an unusual use. The constructions with 肉 are not being given as examples of using a different word for the animal and the food. They all use the same word. The example was the one at the end of the list, 水母 vs 海蜇.