4 ms·
I believe most of the new-model online/for-profit universities actually had to buy older universities to get their accreditation. So I doubt that "play[ing] th
by gojomo 15y ago
I believe most of the new-model online/for-profit universities actually had to buy older universities to get their accreditation.
So I doubt that "play[ing] their game better than they do" by pursuing traditional accreditation is really the disruptive strategy here. Blow up the whole rotten credentialist system and replace it with something very different.
(A meta-credentialing service might be a neat startup. With an explosion of non-traditional courses, certifications, and credentials, which actually hold up as meaning something? Communicating something here is a process, trust, and even data/statistics challenge – a nice community/tech opportunity.)
- padwiki 15y agoShoot, you've gone ahead and skipped ahead to phase two of our master plan. Try not to tell our competitors...
- twelvechairs 15y agoI agree - very hard to start a (long-course) educational institution without first establishing the credibility (in the actual industry, not to the govt.) of the certificate you get at the end of it. What a system like this really needs is a strong way for future employers of graduates to rate their relative ability (eg. 'according to our benchmarks this person's ability in python lies _x_ far between the average coder on github and [insert famous python user here]'). Perhaps establishing 'credentialing' should come before establishing a school?
- padwiki 15y agoYou would think so, but we actually can't even apply for regional accreditation until the first student graduates from a full degree program. Yes, the system is rigged against new entrants.
- olalonde 15y agoThe optimal ecosystem in my mind would be one where the institutions offering accreditation are completely independent from the ones offering teaching. Aside from the obvious "division of labor is a good thing" argument, it would open up all sorts of possibilities: - Ability to take courses from multiple "universities". This will provide an incentive for "universities" to compete on a course by course level. - The burden of trust will mainly shift to the "accreditator" side, making it easier to open up new "universities" without prior reputation. Of course, they will still have to convince prospective students that their courses are good. - For companies: ability to compare prospective employees credentials in a more objective way. There will presumably only be a few "accreditation" companies unlike the current large amount of universities in the world. The only downside I can think of is that the accreditation institutions might not be testing what the universities want to teach or what the students want to learn. Also, universities/student might optimize for passing the exams rather than learning. Is that much different from the status quo though? It might be too early, but it might give some ideas for a startup.