TLJ was review bombed (movie sucked tho). Critics gave a good score out of fear imo. It's just an outlier for that rule. Oscar worthy - best picture, best acto

TLJ was review bombed (movie sucked tho). Critics gave a good score out of fear imo. It's just an outlier for that rule. Oscar worthy - best picture, best actor, etc. Best original song isn't a top tier category. That year also had weak competition. The Greatest Showman was nominated in a single category, and it lost to Coco. I don't know where you got that it won. Coco got nominated in two categories, one of which was important, and won both. Coco also within 3% difference on rotten tomatoes.