5 ms·
Proposed US Rule for Portable Generators Will Save Thousands of Lives and $1B/Yr
- throw9away6 3y agoDo we really need to increase the cost of generators by adding safety features against gross negligence? Adding that feature in will makes people think that it’s safe to run generators indoors because the sensor will cut off when it’s not. Except inevitably the sensor will fail or the co will end up moving to a basement and killing someone
- Our_Benefactors 3y agoAdding seatbelts will make people think it’s safe to crash!
- jjeaff 3y agoThe old economist joke is that if you really want to prevent crashes, don't put airbags and seat belts, put a spear on the steering wheel pointing right into the driver's face.
- pdonis 3y agoYes, adding safety features to cars does make people more likely to engage in risky behavior, and as a result the accident rate goes up. Look up "moral hazard".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI’m not sure I understand - you’re saying if the failsafe fails someone might die (presumably not common event), yet without the failsafe many people are assured to die (apparently a common enough event), so therefore we shouldn’t have the failsafe? I’ll wager people run the generator without any thought as to whether there’s a cut off or not and that’s why they die. It seems like a real on the margin case that someone thinks “I can run this indoors safely because the safety mechanism will cut off once it’s unsafe” and simultaneously the failsafe malfunctions. Comparatively to “I’m not very smart and the power is off so I’m going to run a gasoline engine inside my house” seems to be pretty common today. Without any data on how much such a failsafe costs it’s hard to evaluate if the cost of the safety feature is that burdensome, but for each of those “not smart going to run a generator” that doesn’t kill their entire family, there will be at least someone who got a good bargain on the feature by not killing everyone in their house.
- pdonis 3y ago> you’re saying if the failsafe fails someone might die (presumably not common event), yet without the failsafe many people are assured to die (apparently a common enough event), so therefore we shouldn’t have the failsafe? No, he's saying that the failsafe adds no value for the vast majority of generator users, because they take responsibility for their own actions and their consequences and learn how to properly use their portable generators. So requiring the failsafe by regulation is punishing all of the responsible adults because of a few irresponsible people. That doesn't make sense. The people who should suffer the consequences of being irresponsible are the people who are irresponsible, not everybody else. > apparently a common enough event 1300 deaths and 77,000 injuries--over 17 years. That's not common at all; it's miniscule. From what I can gather, about 10% of households have portable generators. That's 30 million of them in the US alone. In the same period of time, roughly 510,000 people in the US died in traffic accidents (roughly 30,000 a year times 17 years). And that's even after decades of government regulations imposing safety features on vehicles. So not only is regulation like this unfair and nonsensical, it doesn't even work. People who insist on being irresponsible will find a way to do it no matter what regulations you impose. The rest of us should not have to suffer the burden of ever-increasing regulations that don't even work. > for each of those “not smart going to run a generator” that doesn’t kill their entire family, there will be at least someone who got a good bargain on the feature by not killing everyone in their house This kind of reasoning does not justify a government regulation. It only counts the benefit to the miniscule number of people who can't be responsible on their own. It doesn't count the cost, both in the ever-increasing burden of regulations we all have to deal with, and the ever-increasing power we are forced to give the government on such grounds, which then gets misused in more and more ways.
- V__ 3y agoI understand that a company might skimp on reducing emissions, but why skimp on a carbon monoxide detector and an automatic shutoff? It would maybe increase the production cost by what, 5 dollars? But be good for marketing and avoiding the possible negative PR if one's branded generator would kill someone. If the 'free market' can't even do the bare minimum, it's no wonder everything gets regulated to hell.
- jjeaff 3y agoThis is a perfect example of a market failure where you need some government intervention because the general public is not great at assessing risk level, or even knowing about some risks. If companies could sell generators with a big sticker on them that says "with new feature that prevents shark attacks" now that might actually get people interested in buying it over the competition. But a CO shutoff probably doesn't get many people interested.
- pdonis 3y ago> This is a perfect example of a market failure where you need some government intervention because the general public is not great at assessing risk level, or even knowing about some risks. No, it's a perfect example of how the government's standard response to a small number of people being stupid and irresponsible is to punish all of the not stupid, not irresponsible people. I don't need a CO detector and automatic shutoff on my portable generator because I have a clue and won't run it indoors. And, as other commenters have pointed out, a CO detector and automatic shutoff are now two more things that can break on my generator--probably right when I need it most, when the power is out. But if this regulation passes, I won't have a choice; I'll have to suffer the consequences of the cluelessness of others. How is that fair? How does it even make sense? Why penalize the actual mature adults just because a few people can't be bothered to be mature adults?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLife isn’t fair. Laws protect the broad population interest. One person’s inconvenience is someone else surviving. Regulation written in blood and whatnot. A vocal minority will complain, this will get built into the supply chain, and a decade or two from now, only older folks will complain. For everyone else, they’ll wonder why they didn’t have them before. So it goes. Notice how much safer cars are versus decades ago. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/21/generators-carbon-monoxide-shutoff-switch-texas-cpsc https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/21/generators-carbon-mo... > Portable generators are one of the deadliest consumer products on the market, killing about 80 people in the U.S. each year and poisoning thousands of others.
- p1mrx 3y agoA carbon monoxide detector is an expendable component that needs to be replaced every 5-7 years. If such a rule is enacted, the first step should be to define a standard interface for replaceable detector modules.
- jjeaff 3y agoThat's for a whole unit with batteries and some other components. I'm not sure if that means that the sensor itself only lasts 5-7 years.
- rickboyce 3y agoIt’s the sensors themselves that have a limited life - the units that have a fixed battery have a battery life that exceeds the sensors useful life. The common / low cost carbon monoxide detectors use a chemical reaction (either a fuel cell or one of a few reactions that produce a colour change in the presence of CO) - the chemistry degrades with time and exposure causing the sensitivity to drop off over time. I’m not sure how much of a safety margin they have (like could it still detect dangerous levels at 2x it’s design life or something) but a quality generator would have a life of several times that of a CO sensor at least so replacement will definitely/hopefully be a design consideration.
- jjeaff 3y agoI have a CO sensor for an arduino that I haven't used yet that cost a few dollars. I haven't noticed in the manual any mention of expiration.
- p1mrx 3y agohttps://www.dfrobot.com/product-686.html https://www.dfrobot.com/product-686.html > MQ7 datasheet > "Its service life can reach 5 years under using condition."
- oakwhiz 3y ago50 Hz generators are exempt for some reason. Those can be perfectly usable with a variety of loads such as a home server lab... I suppose that anybody running the generator properly would have to add a fan to the generator in order to reduce false trips. But false trips can still happen from CO sensor degradation over time, it's a single failure point. It's a shame that everything has to be made worse just because some people think that you can run a generator indoors for some reason, despite it being covered in warning labels about exactly that.
- jjeaff 3y agoI'm sure you'll be able to put a piece of tape over the sensor port.
- oakwhiz 3y agoIf you read the proposed rule, there is mention of tamper resistance requirements and compliance with third party standards which were previously not enforced. It does seem a bit concerning. For example: (f) Tamper resistance. (1) A portable generator system for controlling CO exposure shall be tamper resistant. The system is considered tamper resistant when any part that is shorted, disconnected, or removed to disable the operation of the system prevents the engine from running. In addition, all parts, including wiring, which affect proper operation of the portable generator system for controlling CO exposure, must be (a) permanently sealed or (b) not normally accessible by hand or with ordinary tools. It is permissible for different parts of the portable generator system for controlling CO exposure to meet either option (a) or (b), provided all of the different parts meet at least one of these two options.
- cbhl 3y agoWhat is the correct way to send feedback/comments for this proposal? In particular I'd like to see so-called "solar generators" or "power stations" be out of scope for requiring "carbon monoxide detection" features, since they're literally just batteries + inverters.
- pdonis 3y agoUnfortunately the deadline for comments on this proposed rulemaking was June 20, 2023: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/04/20/2023-07870/safety-standard-for-portable-generators https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/04/20/2023-07... It's wonderful how the public doesn't actually find out about these things until it's too late.
- pdonis 3y agoComments that were submitted can be found here: https://www.regulations.gov/document/CPSC-2006-0057-0118 https://www.regulations.gov/document/CPSC-2006-0057-0118
- p1mrx 3y agoI tried sending a message to https://www.cpsc.gov/About-CPSC/Contact-Information/Commissioner-Richard-Trumka-Jr-Contact-Form https://www.cpsc.gov/About-CPSC/Contact-Information/Commissi... about standardized CO detector modules, but I don't think it worked: /!\ Unable to send email. Contact the site administrator if the problem persists.
- fgsfds028374 3y agoI see portable gensets abused so much on boats these days, situated in ways that virtually guarantee CO pooling in the cabin. I think we need to administer intelligence tests before selling these things to people.
- CapstanRoller 3y agoHow would this work for people who run small generators in an off-grid setting, typically in an enclosure outside the house?
- willcipriano 3y ago> It will also save the American people over $1 billion dollars per year in costs related to those deaths and injuries. People smart enough to run generators correctly on the other hand now have to pay for safety features they do not require.
- instagib 3y agoI had to do the “do you want to startup a semi in your living room?” example to get people to understand running a generator indoors is a huge mistake. Just turn on a fan they say. Open a door. The number of people who would without hesitation start a generator indoors is far too high. It’s against OSHA of course.
- taylodl 3y agoFrom the article's first paragraph: Over 1,300 people died from carbon monoxide poisoning caused by portable generators between 2004 and 2021 alone. [1] Another 77,000 people were hurt in that same period. Worse yet, a quarter of all fatal incidents associated with portable generators involve multiple deaths at once, some involving entire families.[2] Now let's run those numbers: (2021-2004)*1000000000/(1300+77000) = 217,114 For this US rule to save $1B/yr then each incident must cost $217,114 for deaths and related injuries. I'm not buying it. Obviously this rule is a Good Thing - I'm not disputing that and I'm not disputing it should be adopted. I'm disputing this yellow journalism claim that adopting it is going to save us $1 billion per year. Even with the hight cost of medical care in the US it's easy to see this isn't the case.