6 ms·
It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use, due to its (generally) transformative nature. Sure, if you really coax it, you can get code o
by satvikpendem 3y ago
It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use, due to its (generally) transformative nature. Sure, if you really coax it, you can get code or images out that look similar to existing ones, but the courts might see that generally speaking, it produces new content that has not been seen before, especially in the case of images.
Google Books literally copied and pasted books to add to their online database and that was deemed fair use, so something much more transformative like generative AI will likely fall under much broader consideration for fair use. Google Books was, yes, non-commercial, but the courts generally have the provision that the more transformative something is, the less it needs to adhere to the guidelines laid out for determining such fair use.
https://ogc.harvard.edu/pages/copyright-and-fair-use https://ogc.harvard.edu/pages/copyright-and-fair-use
- lewhoo 3y ago> Sure, if you really coax it, you can get code or images out that look similar to existing one I'd say it is possible to produce exact data as well. Try "Provide quote from King James' Bible Genesis :1-25" with chatgpt. You'll get a verbatim text. You can get the same with things like Moby Dick, but when I typed "Provide the first five sentences of the book A Game Of Thrones" I got: Certainly! Here are the first five sentences from the book "A Game of Thrones" by George R.R. Martin: "We should start back," Gared This content may violate our content policy or terms of use. If you believe this to be in error, please submit your feedback — your input will aid our research in this area. The model is clearly capable of reproducing verbatim data I think.
- smoldesu 3y agoThat's part of what made the Google Books ruling so shocking; it considered Google's transformation of "we digitized and indexed these books" to be transformative. If you punch the ASOIAF quote into it, Books will reproduce the text of Game of Thrones that had your query: https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=%22We+should+start+back%2C%22+Gared https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=%22We+should+start+b... It's still surreal that this is considered Fair Use, and even defended relatively recently (2013). It's hard to say where the ruling will land ultimately, but there seems to be an argument that verbatim reproduction doesn't matter.
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt's likely defended due to being non-commericial and for the public good, as I posted with my link to the Harvard page above. That was for literal copying and pasting so the bar for transformativeness is higher, but with generative AI where it can produce wholly new code/images, I think it will also be deemed fair use.
- twoodfin 3y agoAlso, extracting for a new purpose is fair use of long standing, distinct from something like sampling for the same purpose of composing music. Siskel and Ebert didn’t need to pay rights holders to extract from their works for public criticism.
- lewhoo 3y agoYeah. I wasn't so much trying to put weight on that you can get a fragment of copyrighted text, like Google Books also provides, but using the Bible as an example my point is you could technically get the whole thing bit by bit. You can't do that with Game of Thrones likely not because of capability but because of guardrails, because for a machine what's the difference if it's fed a copyrighted text or not.
- saurik 3y agoGoogle Books itself being some kind of fair use transformative work is unrelated to whether you could use the output of a Google Books query as part of a book you yourself have written (and like, clearly you can't).
- jacquesm 3y agoWill you indemnify those that follow your advice? Because 'transformative' is a pretty dangerous word to use in this context.
- satvikpendem 3y agoNo because I don't have that much money, but it looks like Microsoft will. They likely wouldn't if their lawyers did not think there was a reasonable chance that they'd win the lawsuits, likely from, again, generative AI being deemed fair use.
- 542458 3y ago> Will you indemnify those that follow your advice? I strongly feel that this is a terrible metric for comments on the internet. First, the person you’re replying to has nothing to gain and a lot to lose by saying "yes". Second, it invites silly corner case nitpicking. Their comment is written in reasonable plain English for other users reading plain English. It’s not a legal contract, and so leaves lots of loopholes. Sure, you could create a likely non-transformative LLM by training it on nothing but the text of Harry Potter with fitness measured by how accurately it exactly reproduces the complete text of Harry Potter, but that’s not what reasonable people are doing with LLMs.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's borderline legal advice and you have to be very careful with predicting how judges will rule on future cases. In a legal context certain words have immense power. In the context of copyright 'transformative' is one such case. It's a very fine line between 'transformative' and 'derivative' and you don't get to preempt the judiciary about how they will see things.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThis is not a legal context though. I am not a lawyer, I don't claim to be a lawyer, and even if I were a lawyer, no one in the internet should be taking my comments as legal advice in the first place. One should not need to disclaim everything they write with such a statement.
- CharlesW 3y ago> It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use, due to its (generally) transformative nature. This isn't how "fair use" works, in the sense that there can never be a blanket assurance like that. Also, whether the result is "transformative" is just one of many factors (see audio sampling/remixing).
- CamperBob2 3y agoIt's not how fair use works now, but many things about copyright law will have to change radically over the next few years. There's too much at stake.
- yladiz 3y agoWhat is at stake?
- jaysinn_420 3y agoBillions of dollars in investments that will partially benefit lawmakers?
- kube-system 3y agoWell, content creators and publishers have trillions.
- jojo100 3y agoContent creators and publishers are also the primary ones who are using generative AI. They aren't a united monolith against generative AI.
- CamperBob2 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- simion314 3y ago>It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use What if you train it only on my huge repo of GPL code? You are just remixing my code. Now you maybe think "let me train on 2 different devs GPL code", the remixed code will probably be 50-50 and you can get away with it ? If the 2 number is too small then tell me what the number N should be ? From how many people you need to "steal" code , mix it and the output is "original" ? Edit: my opinion is that AI should be fair, if you train it on open source then model should also be open source and output should also be open source.
- satvikpendem 3y agoWhat if I learned to code based only on your huge repo of GPL code? I'd just be remixing your GPL code at that point, right? Will you brand all of my output as being GPL as well?
- simion314 3y ago>What if I learned to code based only on your huge repo of GPL code? I'd just be remixing your GPL code at that point, right? Will you brand all of my output as being GPL as well? This never happens, you will first learn from a book or tutorials. But your idea is sound, have Microsoft buy books from the authors and train the LLM on those books then have the LLM solve new problems. If is an AI and not a text interpolating tool then it should be able to learn like humans from a few books.
- andybak 3y ago> This never happens, you will first learn from a book or tutorials. I have learned to code almost entirely from reading code. I hate tutorials and books. I occasionally skim docs but mainly for the code examples. So "never happens" is a curious take.
- qotgalaxy 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- riedel 3y agoI just want to highlight that this a very US centric view. A user of copilot in the EU might be confronted with a totally different legal regime. (No fair use per se, no copyright transferability, ...). It seems quite a bold move as being an internationally active company if there is no small print...
- satvikpendem 3y agoYes, I'm talking about American law specifically.
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoYeah but if it's ok in the USA the EU needs to allow it or they'll fall even farther behind.
- CaptainFever 3y agoIt's already allowed in the EU: https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainment-and-media/2023/06/text-and-data-mining-around-the-globe https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainmen...
- tremon 3y agono copyright transferability The economic part of copyright is transferable in the EU just as it is in the US, only certain moral rights (such as the right to attribution) are inalienable. edit to add: it's not just in the EU. According to Wikipedia, the same distinction is made in Brazil, China, India and Indonesia (among others, but those were a few big countries that stood out).
- riedel 3y agoThat is true: You are certainly allow to (exclusively) licence your works to others. Actually, I only meant it to be an example of how giving guarantees can become difficult if authorship is not clear.
- croes 3y agoDidn't Copilot produce an exact copy of code including the comments?
- Kiro 3y agoOnly if you push it into a corner, at which point you may just as well go to the repo and copy-paste the code you're trying to reproduce.
- Gigachad 3y agoTake a look at the prompts people use in these examples. They are always so contrived. Sure if you ask it to "Take this function exactly as it is from this file at this repo and output it without changes" it can do that.
- yencabulator 3y agoIs the contrivedness relevant to the legal question? It shows the model contains the copyrighted content and can reproduce it on demand.
- Filligree 3y agoYes. Courts will generally assign blame to whoever did the thing that caused a breach of the law, which in this case is the user. In other words, law isn’t a programming language.
- Gigachad 3y agoMy brain contains loads of copyrighted info. And if I exactly reproduce it from memory, it's copyright infringement. But if I come up with my own work, even if using that copyrighted info to learn from, it isn't infringement.
- yencabulator 3y agoI don't understand why people keep comparing humans and computers. The law does not treat machinery equal to a human.
- littlestymaar 3y ago> It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use Except that “fair use” is mostly an American thing. In many other jurisdictions (especially those with of civil law) there's such a wide principle, and there's only specific laws allowing some explicit kinds of use of copyrighted material that the law allows. In those jurisdiction, most uses of generative AI trained on copyrighted material are, more likely than not, illegal at least until the legislator actually changes the law.
- CaptainFever 3y agoTDM exceptions, which are already in place in a number of jurisdictions: https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainment-and-media/2023/06/text-and-data-mining-around-the-globe https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainmen...
- jcranmer 3y ago> It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use, due to its (generally) transformative nature. Have you read the recent SCOTUS decision in Warhol v Goldsmith? Because that's a pretty major redefinition of transformative for the purposes of fair use, and not in a good way for arguing that generative AI is fair use, especially because it ties transformative to the market impact. That generative AI is generally creating outputs that are directly competing with inputs (particularly in the case of generating images, where it's clearly competing with stock images) would make it dramatically less likely that a court would find that it is in fact transformative.
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoFrom what I understand, the "market impact" test is about the value of the specific work for which the copyright has been infringed. If, 99% of the times, the generative AI systems do not output anything that a court/jury would deem a derivative work of the original, I don't see how the "effect on the market" prong can be won by the copyright holder.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI think the Warhol decision is an entirely different kettle of fish. Just take a look at the pieces in question: the Warhol portraits don't really look that different compared to the original photographs. The benefit that generative AI has is that, when claiming copyright infringement, you need to specify individual works that were infringed. It's not enough to say "this work is an amalgam of these other ten thousand works, and we can't really tell you how." I could imagine if generative AI gives an identical, word-for-word match for an individual piece of source material it could be in trouble, but that's also the easiest type of thing to prevent from an AI company perspective. The fact is that existing copyright law just can't really encompass the kinds of societal concerns we have around generative AI.
- 3y ago
- aidenn0 3y ago> It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use, due to its (generally) transformative nature Purely mechanical modifications may not be considered transformative, and there's an argument to be made that LLMs are purely mechanical (in fact a US district court recently ruled that AIs cannot be authors of copyrighted works).
- amalcon 3y ago> (in fact a US district court recently ruled that AIs cannot be authors of copyrighted works). I thought that was because only humans and other legal persons can legally author things, not because of anything subtler about the nature of LLMs. See also the case where the monkey managed to take photos of itself. I'm not a lawyer, though.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> I thought that was because only humans and other legal persons can legally author things, not because of anything subtler about the nature of LLMs. It very explicitly was and made a point of noting that it was not addressing anything about whether and when a human author could hold a copyright on a work authored using AI.
- professoretc 3y agoCorrect, as usual, everyone interprets that case as 'OMG animals/AI created work is uncopyrightable!1!' but in reality it's just that animals/AIs cannot hold copyright. Whether a human using an AI can copyright the resulting work is still up in the air.
- nonfamous 3y agoIn the monkey-photo case, didn't the journalist attempt to assert copyright on the photo the monkey took with his camera, but was denied?
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago"likely" Big bet on legal costs based on something being "likely".
- saurik 3y agoGoogle Books is transformative in its use and for what it is, sure; and yet, if you do a query on Google Books and try to take the output and paste it into your book, that might not be fair use (and I only say "might not" instead of "would not" as maybe you are writing a research paper and wanted a quote from a book or whatever, but of course that's just a silly corner case someone would try to call me out for on an Internet forum). Just because Copilot might be itself a transformative work which is itself allowed to exist, that doesn't at all necessitate a conclusion that the developers who are using it are going to or should somehow be guaranteed not be committing their own copyright sins if they try to incorporate its output into their own works (any more so than one can or should assume all of the outputs of another human being are free of copyright entanglements, even though no one is as-yet claiming a human being is themselves infringement just because they saw another work).
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago> It's likely that generative AI in general will be deemed fair use Everybody seems to be saying this, but I really don't think there's even 50% chance of it happening. Google books was fair use because it was a public benefit and did not take away from publishers or authors, to the contrary it helped people find their works. Compare generative AI which extracts the essence of people's works and recreates similar works (in terms of style, etc) while cutting out the original authors completely. This potentially denies them the fruits of their labor. It's notable that it's a purely mechanical process and no human creativity is involved, except that which is extracted from other authors. Mere prompts don't count. The argument you're suggesting will hold is essentially "yes we're using copyrighted works, but we're doing it at scale and blending it, so that's ok".
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoSo many downthread comments pulling out the computers and brains are exactly the same meeeerrrrrr BS. "I'll keep saying it every time this comes up. I LOVE being told by techbros that a human painstaking studying one thing at a time, and not memorizing verbatin but rather taking away the core concept, is exactly the same type of "learning" that a model does when it takes in millions of things at once and can spit out copyrighted code verbatim." (I also love it when they're deliberately obtuse about it too. The past decade has made me sick of this trolling tactic.)
- dang 3y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and/or posting in the flamewar style? It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful. p.s. Also, please don't copy/paste comments on HN.
- r00fus 3y agoUltimately I find that commoditization enables the purest form of the banality of evil. Commoditized goods allows the bad to be sorted in with the good, allowing a price to be put on the commodity. Great where it's applicable but horrendous when it's improperly done - ie, home loans, or intellectual property. If your commodity markets aren't properly regulated you get a race to the bottom. If you are trying to commoditize something that shouldn't be, it's effectively enables white-collar looting or money laundering.
- nfriedly 3y agoI think it'll likely be deemed fair use because of how much money Microsoft and others are willing to throw at getting that result.
- slashdev 3y agoProvided you don’t use it to deliberately recreate a substantial part of a copyrighted work. Intent will matter here, and it’s difficult to prove. Even Microsoft is couching their guarantee here with an exception for this very case.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoYou're getting a lot of pushback, but the EU seems to agree with you: https://creativecommons.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/CC-Statement-on-the-TDM-Exception-Art-4-DSM-Final.pdf https://creativecommons.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/CC-St... https://www.notion.so/DSM-Directive-Implementation-Tracker-361cfae48e814440b353b32692bba879 https://www.notion.so/DSM-Directive-Implementation-Tracker-3... https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2019/790/oj https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2019/790/oj The TDM4 copyright exception allows datasets to be created consisting of copyrighted works, as long as there is a mechanism for rightsholders to opt out. This seems like the best of both worlds: the dataset is transparent, rightsholders can assert their rights, and certain AI companies can train on copyrighted material. Of course, this doesn't grant commercial rights for the trained model, only scientific and academic research rights. (I.e. it's fine for Meta to train and release a LLaMA model trained on books, as long as they're not commercially profiting from it, and there's a mechanism for authors to opt out.) I'm talking with Jordan from https://spawning.ai https://spawning.ai to try to build some kind of opt out system that makes sense for books. One could imagine doing this for music too. This is a European law, but unlike other overreaching EU regulations, this one seems like an extremely sensible compromise. EDIT: Oh, Jordan emailed me a correction: > Looking at your hackernews comment, my understanding is the right to opt out only comes for commercial research. So making a dataset for eleuther (or whomever you compiled it for originally) probably doesn't even require opt outs. It'd be if openai used it for gpt-5 and charged for it that it would be required. Wow. So this law actually applies to commercial uses of ML, and non-commercial uses such as LLaMA wouldn't even require an opt-out. That's wonderful. This gives researchers legal cover, and requires commercial uses to be transparent in their datasets.
- bsder 3y ago> as long as there is a mechanism for rightsholders to opt out. I really don't like this--opt-out never works because the scale advantages are backwards. It places the burden in the wrong place. The aggregators should have to get opt-in. Look at YouTube. Because of "opt-out", lots of people monetize content that they have no right to and it's up to the original author to have to fight the scale of a zillion uploaders. Only the biggest entities can do that. YouTube (and everybody else) should have to assert "You, the uploader, own this content" when they ingest it. Nothing else works. I wouldn't mind an exemption for research use, though.
- verve_rat 3y agoSure, that might work for some places, but some jurisdictions don't have a legal concept of fair use.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pyuser583 3y agoWhy is Google books so unusable then? Even documents in the early 20th century are inaccessible.
- ryukoposting 3y agoThere are cases where generative AI can be trained for the explicit purpose of ripping off a particular artist's style. Take a gander at all the artist/art style LoRAs for Stable Diffusion. Some of them are harmless (a Rembrandt LoRA for example) but others are trained to make convincing knockoffs of living artists who are trying to put food on the table.