4 ms·
>401k has one other advantage: it is clear where the money is and who controls it. I'll add another one: the investor can tailor their risk to where they are i
by ghaff 3y ago
>401k has one other advantage: it is clear where the money is and who controls it.
I'll add another one: the investor can tailor their risk to where they are in life. At some point, it probably makes sense to put even most of my savings in very low risk, low yield bonds.
But that point is probably not when I'm in my twenties.
I actually understand the appeal of a (presumably) low risk "guaranteed" annuity payout at retirement that may have been a long ago benefit you never really thought about. But it probably wasn't really free and probably doesn't represent a better investment than if you were given the actuarial share of the money paid into the pension on your behalf instead.
- bluGill 3y agoA pension should be able to look at demographics and even better manage that risk. You have no idea if you will live to 105 (a few years ago I saw a headline suggesting 175 might be a reasonable life expectancy for young people today - even more unknown though I don't know if it is true), or die at 63. You might have some family history as a guide, but odds are yours is average: sometime between 65 and 95 with a peak around 78. Realistically, for almost everyone our expected lifespan is so close to even that we shouldn't be tailoring our investing to anything out than our age. A lot risk annuity payout is a great insurance against living to 105. I tell people when they retire they need to figure out the minimum they need to live on and invest in a guaranteed annuity that will pay that amount (ideally inflation adjusted) until they die. However because annuities are not really a great investment, don't put any more than that in them. Plan for a more normal lifespan.
- ghaff 3y agoI pretty much agree with all that. An annuity or two isn't bad. I'll have one through a long-ago DB pension and another through a charitable trust that wasn't really a great financial "deal" but I wanted to donate and it provides another income stream. But they're pretty much just nice add-ons (in addition to social security of course). I'm not against annuities, including DB pensions. I just don't think (honestly funded) DB pensions are this fantastic benefit that's been yanked away from people who could have taken the same amount of money and invested it otherwise.
- bluGill 3y agoDB is better only because many of people who think about their investments are falling for a scam.
- ghaff 3y agoThat comes close to being: "Let the professionals handle it and you'll be fine." I mean, I can also pick a financial advisor at one of the major brokerages and they'll take their skim but probably won't do anything really bad.
- bluGill 3y agoI know enough people who have fallen for scams...