3 ms·
Stop talking about it and call a law firm. Your local Bar Association will be able to give you a list of firms/attorneys that practice in this area, or your exi
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Stop talking about it and call a law firm. Your local Bar Association will be able to give you a list of firms/attorneys that practice in this area, or your existing lawyer may have a recommendation. Many law firms will give you a short consultation for free. Bring a succinct written summary of the facts with you that briefly describes the product, how you discovered the issue, and what you found when you investigated, with dates. Include a list of evidence items you have already collected. Litigation is difficult and expensive, but if you have a strong case (and it sounds like you do) then the law firm may take it on contingency in return for a larger portion of the settlement/judgment.
EDIT: I wouldn't trust the opinions of the 'just execute better' posters here, considering your competitors' employees already infiltrated your slack channel.
- muzani 3y agoUnless it was patented or the code copied, it's unlikely that it's illegal. But I'm not a lawyer.
- reaperman 3y ago> considering your competitors' employees already infiltrated your slack channel. It was a public community slack channel. There may have been proprietary/protected information shared in there but in my naive opinion (NAL!) that wouldn't be protected by trade secrets if it was shared publicly. Some things could still be protected by copyright or trademark but it's pretty unlikely. It's possible copying the API could be infringing but Google v. Oracle[0] makes that a very uphill battle. "Secret sauce" is highly valued by founders and product managers but IMHO it's generally overvalued and doesn't constitute a moat. For the most part, competitors are allowed to copy most things and leverage whatever other advantages they have over the original innovators. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_....
- anigbrowl 3y agoLitigation is about more than the legal argument alone, and the legal arguments often turn on specific facts that may seem general on casual inspection. Other factors to consider include cost, embarrassing facts that may emerge during discovery, and reputational damage. That's why cases are often settled on the eve of trial, sometimes for significant sums. Getting a professional opinion on the options is generally better than just making assumptions. Copycats and rip-offs are a fact of life, but that doesn't mean they should enjoy free reign. It's not that I think litigation is better than execution, but people exclusively advocating the latter are expressing an opinion about how they think things should work in a perfect world while not having any assets of their own on the line.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe 'Eve of Trial', how appropriate.
- dtornabene 3y agoPretty wild how much "just execute better" posts there are, one wonders if its the common response to a situation like this, from this community, and what that says about trustworthiness in general of YC "founder" types!
- jacquesm 3y agoYC isn't responsible for the actions of the founders of every start-up that they fund. Even worse: after funding them they have very limited ability to influence the companies they funded, after all, YC has a small minority stake and founders could just ignore them. Obviously YC can cut them off from further capital and blackball them but that may not be sufficient.
- dtornabene 3y agoon the contrary! They are indeed very much responsible, if only in part, for the actions of the people they are giving money and sharing connections with! Pretty sure there's an entire corner of criminal law and civil code covering exactly those responsibilities! And yeah, they can do all kinds of stuff to make sure that these things don't happen, or at the very very least publicly demonstrate that they will not tolerate it from future "founders" by responding appropriately to this one. I am always freshly amazed, probably from naivete, each time people make excuses for the terrible behavior of SV tech "founders" and the VCs that prop them up. I shouldn't be, on this forum, and thats on me.
- jacquesm 3y agoAs a seed investor and VC investor I'm happy to inform you that it very rarely happens that seed investors or VCs have a controlling interest in the company. You may have a board seat. And if you don't like what the company is doing your most powerful move is resign from the board. Another option is to force a shareholder vote, but if the founders still hold the majority (as they should, at this phase) that will be overruled. I'm freshly amazed by the lack of basic corporate law knowledge in the context of HN, this is really something that should be known if you partake of conversations like these. I agree they should respond appropriately, but depending on what happened that response may not satisfy you.
- invalidname 3y agoIf you go this route be sure to grab evidence now. Screenshots, logs and anything you can to show the product similarities and IP issues. Before they change stuff and try to erase it.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://slack.com/help/articles/201658943-Export-your-workspace-data https://slack.com/help/articles/201658943-Export-your-worksp...
- ewe 3y agothis is gold, thanks folks
- jacquesm 3y agoGood luck with this. It must be very frustrating to see this happening. Make sure you cross your 't's and dot your 'i's before going to court on this and offer them to settle first assuming you have hard proof that they copied your work product. Document everything. They item would be whether or not YC is aware of this and whether or not your application or parts thereof somehow made it to these people. If it did you have a much stronger case, if it did not then you need to document very carefully which bits you believe have been copied, timestamp the works and make sure your lawyer gives you a fair assessment of what to expect in terms of costs and what your claim will be. I can't look into your walled but depending on how much backing you've got you may be able to hit the pretty hard or you may have to walk away from it, even if you have proof, hard to tell.
- nico 3y agoUnless you have tons of funding and lawyers already on retainer, this is horrible advice Legal fees will drain your funds faster than anything else and you will probably not see any benefits from it In fact it might be what makes your company fail (taking away the focus from building your business)
- jacquesm 3y agoOf course it isn't horrible advice, legal affairs are dealt with by lawyers and courts. If you have a product out there in the market you should go to bat for it. And yes, it might make your company fail. But that goes for a well funded competitor outright copying your product as well.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat are the indicators you're seeing in this story that legal fees would have a real ROI? I think it's good to be skeptical of paying elective legal fees.
- aaaaaaaaaaa10 3y agoThis would require millions in legal fees.
- jacquesm 3y agoNot it won't. If it is an outright copy (that's relatively easy to prove) you can have an injunction issued, besides that the bad press alone might get them to back off. I've brought a lawsuit like that and won << $100K.
- aaaaaaaaaaa10 3y agoHow many hours in legal fees did you pay for your attorneys?
- jacquesm 3y ago