2 ms·
That DB pension still has interest rate risk over a period of decades. And, although with some exceptions (charitable trusts and the like), an equivalent annuit
by ghaff 3y ago
That DB pension still has interest rate risk over a period of decades. And, although with some exceptions (charitable trusts and the like), an equivalent annuity is mostly not a great investment for individuals, there are a lot of other ways to manage risk if you're happy with a modest 6% or whatever return. For starters, I can buy long-term treasuries although that may be too safe by itself. And almost certainly wouldn't be the optimal investment for an early-career employee who may be starting to think about saving for a house down payment.
I'm perfectly happy to have an early-career pension coming that I probably didn't really think twice about at the time. However, overall, myself and I imagine most of the people here would prefer to invest their own money rather than count on the pension from the company they worked for long ago (assuming they worked for them long enough).
But maybe you just prefer effectively being forced to save at a low-risk rate which is what a DB pension is.
- cool_dude85 3y ago>That DB pension still has interest rate risk over a period of decades. That's the employer's problem, not the pensioner's. Again, the large corporation that can afford to manage the risk is forced to, rather than the individual retiree. >But maybe you just prefer effectively being forced to save at a low-risk rate which is what a DB pension is. No, it's an effective guarantee of the benefits I'll receive upon retirement. I don't invest in anything as part of the pension. Now, I'll agree that some individuals would long-term beat the 6% that the pension fund will get (presumably with higher risk). But for the entire employee base to each individually beat it seems very unlikely to me. Even to collectively beat it and accept that some unlucky duckies will eat dog food when they retire, I think is not very likely.