3 ms·
The simplest explanation is politicians excluded taxpayer funded defined benefit pensions from any regulations ensuring their solvency, such as ERISA 1974 and P
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
The simplest explanation is politicians excluded taxpayer funded defined benefit pensions from any regulations ensuring their solvency, such as ERISA 1974 and PPA 2006. Why? Because future taxpayers can always make up for underfunding.
Voters today want lower taxes today. Politicians today want votes today. Government employee union members want maximum compensation, and union leadership is composed of older employees who will collect benefits in the short term.
So, how do you deliver both lower taxes (than a competing politician) and market pay? By using benefits where you can fudge the numbers with plausible deniability.
For example, the federal government requires non taxpayer funded pension plans to calculate the present value of the benefit using corporate bond yield curves, which were ~4% and below for the last 10+ years.
https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/pension-plan-funding-segment-rates https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/pension-plan-funding-se...
In the meantime, most taxpayer funded pensions were using 7%+, some even 8.5% return on investment assumptions to calculate present value of the benefit.
The higher the discount rate (or ROI) assumption, the cheaper the benefit is today (since you are expecting the investment to pay the benefit to grow quicker). And as a rough estimate, the sensitivity of the discount rate is 15%, meaning a 1% difference in the discount rate assumption will change the present value (or liability) by 15%.
Which means when a government uses a discount rate 2% and 3% above what non governments have to use, that means your government is understating liabilities by 30%+, which means either they have to make up for it by investing in riskier investments, and most likely hosing down future taxpayers to make up for the underfunding.
These reports show a ranking of the levels of deferred compensation funding throughout the US. Note the relatively bad position of Chicago and Illinois, hence why this thread exists.
https://www.truthinaccounting.org/resources/page/state-reports https://www.truthinaccounting.org/resources/page/state-repor...
https://www.truthinaccounting.org/resources/page/city-reports https://www.truthinaccounting.org/resources/page/city-report...
- ghaff 3y agoAside from the challenges of switching over deeply-ingrained systems, it's really hard for me to make the case for DB pensions today, especially with them largely gone from the private sector. Yes, a lot of people don't voluntarily save for retirement as much as they should to supplement social security and other benefit programs. But my response to that is something the lines of "OK. Let's stipulate that's an issue. Why are we only solving it for public sector employees?" I suspect the answer is at least partly because voters won't give us enough money to pay today's salaries so we need to obfuscate our costs and kick the can down the road. But that's not a very satisfactory answer.
- cool_dude85 3y agoI'd say it's a very easy case to make. Pensions are much cheaper than individual private plans and place various financial risks on the party that can actually afford to manage it (and spread it across the entire employee base). The pension holds the risk for me that I live longer than I planned, or that the market crashes the month before I turn 65. Being a large professionally managed fund, it's in a great position to do so, and it even spreads the cost around! I don't have to pay some insurance company a huge premium to get an annuity, the pension gives me the annuity at cost and probably with much better terms. The only argument you give is that the private sector got rid of them. Well, don't ask me to eat shit just cause you're happy to.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Pensions are much cheaper than individual private plans and place various financial risks on the party that can actually afford to manage it (and spread it across the entire employee base). This is obviously false given the underfunded states of pretty much all taxpayer funded pensions in the US. > Being a large professionally managed fund, it's in a great position to do so, and it even spreads the cost around! I don't have to pay some insurance company a huge premium to get an annuity, the pension gives me the annuity at cost and probably with much better terms. A pension fund manager is not doing anything more special than a simple target date retirement fund does. The job has been automated away. The only savings comes from shafting future taxpayers, which is why almost no non taxpayer funded entity offers DB pensions anymore. Also, there exists a defined benefit pension plan for all US residents called Social Security. But the federal government has the power to issue new money, which no one else does.
- cool_dude85 3y ago>This is obviously false given the underfunded states of pretty much all taxpayer funded pensions in the US. You have confused two different but related issues. Let me be more explicit. My pension fund provides all employees who join with certain benefits. Let's say over the course of 50 years we look at what it costs to provide these benefits in some constant dollars and it's 100 bucks. I claim that the cost for all employees using individual retirement accounts to achieve the same benefits as the pension, they would have to had paid e.g. 110 bucks. I can't prove this claim but can provide some explanation: Each individual fund is much smaller and is paying much higher fees, both management fees and transaction type fees. Each individual is much harder to insure than the group and has to go to a for-profit insurer to get an annuity (as they have with the DB pension). They pay the risk and for the insurer's profit. Each individual has to manage pre-retirement market risk and pay a price to do so, e.g. they're using target date funds and the money is in low-yield bonds for the last few years before they retire, losing returns at exactly the time it's most costly. The question of funding is separate. It's up to my employer to decide if they want to set aside the whole 100 bucks up front that the pension costs or if they only want to set aside 80 bucks. So, either the pension is fully funded, or 20 short, either way it's cheaper.
- cool_dude85 3y agoMy pension currently uses around 6% assumed rate of return for the purposes of calculating unfunded liability, and has, over the past 24 years, returned 6.03%. Further, keep in mind that the real pension costs are actual dollars leaving the fund and are not directly affected by assumed discount rates. The effect of a low discount rate is simply to have more money in the pension fund, but at the end of the day the liabilities are the liabilities and the discount rate doesn't enter into it. It may be wise to put more away now, but even pay-as-you-go pensions have a long history of working out even if there is greater risk.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> may be wise to put more away now, but even pay-as-you-go pensions have a long history of working out even if there is greater risk. What is the definition of working out? Of course they work out, as long as there is enough of a tax base to keep soaking. But that is a poor definition of working out, as I have no interest in paying for labor performed decades ago. When it doesn’t work out is when you get into a Detroit situation. Or most recently, Chester, PA, where there isn’t a sufficient tax base to soak anymore.
- cool_dude85 3y agoDefinition of working out would be the pension costs are still a reasonable and manageable cost as compared to e.g. payroll or the budget. City bankruptcies do occur, I'd argue that blaming pensions is just a scapegoat, but hey, that's me. I haven't looked into Detroit's books, much less Chester PA, Detroit city limits population right now is sub-1920 levels and around 1/3 of where it was in 1950. Such a change would put enormous stress on the finances of any large city, pension or no.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoA properly funded pension should be a non factor in a city’s finances. The fact that leaders in previous decades punted costs (unnecessarily) into the future when the city’s economic productivity ended up not being able to afford is the problem, and what we are discussing on how to avoid (by simply not offering deferred compensation).