3 ms·
Any keyboard will be a "contrived interface". The logical thing would be alphabetical order for ease of learning, but that would be terrible for speed. Altern
by dpark 15y ago
Any keyboard will be a "contrived interface". The logical thing would be alphabetical order for ease of learning, but that would be terrible for speed. Alternatively, you could go with something like Dvorak, optimized for speed, but at the end of the day Dvorak feels just as contrived, has the same awkward learning curve, and the evidence that it's significantly faster than qwerty is virtually nonexistent except for a couple of old studies whose results have not been substantiated by newer studies.
- mistercow 15y agoThe point is not that "contrived = bad". The point is that a contrived interface can be optimized, while multiplication tables are a fixed part of understanding multiplication in a positional system. On the other hand, you could argue that we could optimize our entire number system for learning by switching to a lower base. And in this sense I do agree that optimizing for ease of learning would be a mistake. If we taught base-3, learning multiplication tables would take one tenth of the time, but actually multiplying numbers would a lot longer. Analogously, I would gladly spend 10 times as long to learn a text entry method if it made me 20% faster in the long run. So I guess what I'm saying is that QWERTY should be replaced not because it's hard to learn, but because it can't possibly be optimally efficient.
- DanBC 15y agoDvorak is not faster, but it is significantly more comfortable. At least, that's what a lot of people say. I'd love to see some decent research. I guess it's hard to double blind for things like keyboard layouts.
- mistercow 15y agoYou could get a bunch of qwerty users/untrained typists and then train them to use randomly assigned keyboard layouts. Once training is complete, you have them type some long piece of text, and then fill out a questionnaire rating various qualitative points like tiredness. Finally, you do a statistical analysis to determine if layouts with more of Dvorak's purportedly beneficial features are correlated with higher comfort ratings. Of course, those features must be rigorously defined beforehand, and you must properly blind yourself when doing the analysis.