3 ms·
I don't see anything particularly disqualifying raised in this take on the new cyber direction. Its concerns around limiting free expression, duty to adhere to
by keepamovin 3y ago
I don't see anything particularly disqualifying raised in this take on the new cyber direction.
Its concerns around limiting free expression, duty to adhere to standards of care, and market power could be alleviated by suitable legal tests.
I agree liability for vulns in court is problematic because of the elaborate possible futures that can occur in court, and the costs involved, but I see that this would likely be set by a sensible implementation of these ideas as a "last resort", with plenty of escape hatches to avoid it on the way, leaving the effect not toothless but just.
I'm interested to see where this will go, I don't think it will be a bad thing for my company's cybersecurity products.
A potential for abuse tho I think is the misuse of whatever collection of laws and rules results, to compel and gag deliberate weakening for the purposes of maintaining backdoor access, which should instead be negotiated through dedicated channels (warrants etc).
Whenever there's commentary on new laws, it's pertinent to ask what lobbyists might be representing what interests in any discussion? I don't know the answer here, but I'd like to see speculation.
One awesome thing that I hope results from this is that more lay people get somewhat conversant in what constitutes secure by design software. An increase in such security literacy can only be good--I think! Unless it's like that situation where people go to their doctors with their diagnosis and treatment already worked out thanks to Google, and are just looking for the doc to rubber stamp it! Which...depending on you and your doc, might be the right choice! Haha :)
- phoehne 3y agoI think I would rephrase one sentence 'what constitutes secure software by design.' to 'it may make some places actually realize there's an activity called software design, which is when you think about how the software should be have before you whack something together.'
- keepamovin 3y agoYes! Haha :)
- fallingknife 3y ago> more lay people get somewhat conversant in what constitutes secure by design software This will never happen anymore than laypeople will start thinking about the engineering principles behind building the reliable internal combustion engine in our cars. We want things that work without us thinking about it, and that's the end of it.
- keepamovin 3y agoHmm, I don't know about that. While I agree with your point that we shouldn't have to think about the intricacies of operation of nice things, to some extent that's not true and there are things we should think about, because we need to be responsible ourselves. In other words, I think there's a certain level of trickle down expertise, and in fact, verily that's how culture grows its knowledge over time. Look at the history of hygeine: at first people laughed in the face of invisible germs, now people know to wash hands, and even, recently, they wear masks when sick. Among a plethora of other hygenic practices. Yes, there will always be hold outs: dubious food-truck kitchens I be lookin' at ya--but overall I think people do learnings over time and pass em down to the subsequent generationisms. Or don't ya think so? :) ;p xx