3 ms·
I’m sure this is well intentioned, but the precedent of schools hiding things from parents is ripe for abuse: https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/15/sexual-vi
by rayiner 3y ago
I’m sure this is well intentioned, but the precedent of schools hiding things from parents is ripe for abuse: https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/15/sexual-violence-reports-rise-drastically-at-schools-education-department-data-shows-429663 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/15/sexual-violence-rep....
This is also an illustration of how individualism increases reliance on the State. Children are necessarily dependent—their brains are incomplete. If you seek to free them from their parents, you need to substitute the guardianship of the State. Someone has to help kids develop their gender identity—and it’s not just the fraction of a percent of kids with gender dysphoria, but all kids struggling with their body image-the court here simply determined that overworked teachers and administrators are better positioned to do that than parents.
- snotrockets 3y agoThere's a reason (some) kids don't come out to their families. This isn't deciding who knows best, but simply reinforcing children's right to protection when needed, including from their families. (And people, children included knows their gender better than any one else).
- lokar 3y agoThis does not prevent teachers from telling the parents, it simply removes the requirement that they do so.
- beached_whale 3y agoThis neglects that many children absolutely cannot tell their parents these things. It can result in them being tortured(mental and/or physical abuse). It also negates that, the UN convention on the rights of children(which the US is the only country to not sign on to) does state that children have a right to privacy. Children are not parental property and parents are not privy to everything without the childs consent.